The Israeli government is promoting a counter-film that mimics the NAZA documentary, an award-winning film detailing mass killings of civilians in Gaza, in an attempt to counter its findings. The original NAZA documentary, directed by Oscar-winning filmmakers Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor and produced by the Guardian, is currently in cinemas and will be shown in more than 50 countries.
Israel's Response to the NAZA Documentary
The Israeli government has denounced the NAZA documentary and announced plans to strip Abraham and Szor of their citizenship, accusing them of treason. In recent days, Israeli embassies have been promoting a link to a hastily produced online film entitled NAZA: The Real Story. This counter-film mimics some of the style of the real documentary, including the use of anonymised interviews shot on rooftops in Tel Aviv, and is hosted on a website called nazadocumentary.com.
The Making of NAZA: The Real Story
Ariel Averbuch, an Israeli attorney and army reservist who made the new documentary, described it as an "offensive move" intended to shift the world's focus from allegations about the Israeli military's killing of civilians toward claims that it is the "most moral army in the world". Another filmmaker listed on the website for NAZA: The Real Story is Roi Danino, a candidate for the rightwing Israel First party. The website domain was registered on 16 September, six days after NAZA's premiere at the Venice international film festival.
Key Takeaways
- The Israeli government is actively promoting a counter-film to challenge the NAZA documentary's findings.
- The counter-film, NAZA: The Real Story, mimics the style of the original but presents a different narrative.
- Filmmakers of the original NAZA documentary face threats of citizenship revocation and treason accusations.
- The domain for the counter-film was registered shortly after NAZA's Venice premiere, indicating a rapid response.
Comparison of the Two Films
| Feature | NAZA Documentary | NAZA: The Real Story |
|---|---|---|
| Director(s) | Yuval Abraham, Rachel Szor | Ariel Averbuch, Roi Danino |
| Producer | The Guardian | Israeli government (promoted) |
| Premiere | Venice International Film Festival | Online (nazadocumentary.com) |
| Main Message | Allegations of mass killings of civilians in Gaza | Claims Israeli military is "most moral army in the world" |
| Distribution | Cinemas in 50+ countries | Online, promoted by Israeli embassies |
Implications for Free Speech and Propaganda
This development raises significant questions about free speech, propaganda, and the role of governments in shaping narratives. The original NAZA documentary has been praised for its investigative rigor, while the counter-film has been criticized as a rushed attempt to discredit it. The Israeli government's actions against the filmmakers, including threats to strip citizenship, have sparked debates about artistic freedom and political dissent.
FAQ
What is the NAZA documentary about?
The NAZA documentary details allegations of Israel's mass killings of civilians in Gaza. It is directed by Oscar-winning filmmakers Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor and produced by the Guardian.
Why is Israel promoting a counter-film?
Israel is promoting a counter-film to challenge the findings of the NAZA documentary and to present its own narrative that the Israeli military is the "most moral army in the world".
What are the consequences for the filmmakers of NAZA?
The Israeli government has announced plans to strip Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor of their citizenship and has accused them of treason.
The battle over the NAZA documentary and its counter-film highlights the power of media in shaping public perception and the lengths to which governments may go to control the narrative.