In a bold new production of King Lear, David Threlfall delivers a moving performance as the titular king, but the decision to have him also play the Fool raises questions. This review explores the highs and lows of Matthew Dunster's staging.
A Modern Take on a Classic Tragedy
Matthew Dunster's production of King Lear sets the play in a modern world of jeans, car keys, and handguns, replacing hessian, horses, and swords. Anna Fleischle's set, with its spangly strings, transforms the stage into a nightclub, England, France, dungeons, and even a shower curtain during the storm scene. This contemporary setting underscores the dynastic dynamics among the younger generation, reminiscent of TV series Succession.
David Threlfall's Moving Lear
David Threlfall's King Lear is neurologically forensic, capturing the character's descent into senility with heartbreaking precision. His performance is the emotional core of the production, and his portrayal of Lear's vulnerability is both powerful and poignant.
The Fool's Role
However, Threlfall also takes on the role of the Fool, a choice that some may find confusing. While it adds a layer of introspection, it sometimes blurs the line between character and commentator. This dual role is a bold experiment, but it doesn't always land.
Dunster's Disruptive Direction
Dunster's direction is notably disruptive. He opens with Threlfall alone on stage delivering a speech from Act III, then introduces the younger generation with erotic dumb shows. Nadine Shah, the Mercury Prize-nominated musician, becomes the first Goneril to mime, adding a unique musical dimension.

Key Takeaways
- David Threlfall delivers a moving performance as Lear, capturing his decline with nuance.
- The decision to have Threlfall also play the Fool is innovative but can be confusing.
- The modern setting and disruptive direction breathe new life into the classic tragedy.
- Nadine Shah's Goneril brings a fresh musical element to the production.
Comparison with Other Productions
| Production | Director | Lear | Notable Feature |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sheffield (2023) | Titas Halder | Ian McDiarmid | Emphasis on nihilism |
| London (2024) | Matthew Dunster | David Threlfall | Lear also plays Fool |
FAQ
Who plays King Lear in this production?
David Threlfall plays King Lear.
Why does David Threlfall also play the Fool?
The director, Matthew Dunster, chose to have Threlfall double as the Fool to add a layer of introspection and blur the line between character and commentator.
Where is this production of King Lear staged?
The production is staged in London, with a modern setting.