Why The Independent's Crossword Should Live 2026

Why The Independent's crossword should live on is a question puzzling many solvers after news that the newspaper plans to discontinue its cryptic puzzle. The Independent has long been home to an excellent puzzle crafted by talented setters. Since 2016, it has been online-only, and while we used to link to gems from its cryptics weekly, something changed: the interface. The puzzle player lacked links, and completing puzzles felt like trying to write on mashed potatoes with a hammer. It felt removed from the crossword ecosystem. Many persevered, but printing a PDF was a challenge of solver commitment. Now, with discontinuation looming, we must ask: why kill a puzzle that could thrive with minimal effort?

The Value of The Independent's Crossword

The Independent's crossword is more than a pastime; it's a cultural staple. Cryptic crosswords challenge the mind, build vocabulary, and foster a community of solvers. The Indy's puzzles, created by excellent setters, have provided countless hours of enjoyment. Discontinuing them ignores the puzzle's potential. With a few tweaks to the online interface, it could have a busy, happy home. Puzzles have never been bigger, as evidenced by the rising popularity of events like the Guardian's Cluesletter launching on 13 October. This newsletter, covering all things puzzle-related, shows that interest is high. The Indy could tap into this enthusiasm effortlessly.

Interface Issues: A Solvable Problem

The main gripe among solvers is the clunky interface. Unlike other crossword platforms, The Independent's player lacks intuitive navigation and linking. This makes solving frustrating, driving solvers away. However, this is a solvable problem. Investing in a user-friendly interface would not require massive expenditure. Many successful crossword sites offer seamless experiences, proving it's feasible. By neglecting this, The Independent is losing a dedicated audience and missing an opportunity to grow.

Comparing Crossword Platforms

To understand what The Independent could achieve, consider how other platforms handle crosswords. The table below compares key features.

As shown, The Independent lags significantly. But with improvements, it could compete. The Guardian's upcoming Cluesletter is a prime example of community engagement. The Indy could replicate this success.

Key Takeaways

• The Independent's crossword has a dedicated following and cultural significance.
• The online interface is a major barrier to solver enjoyment and retention.
• Investing in a better interface could revitalize the puzzle and attract new solvers.
• Discontinuation would be a loss to the crossword community and the newspaper's brand.

Why Discontinuation Is Baffling

The decision to discontinue is baffling for two reasons. First, the online puzzles could easily have a busy, happy home with little effort and expenditure. Second, puzzles have never been bigger. The rise of puzzle events, like the Guardian's Cluesletter, and the popularity of contests like September's Genius (won by Jude Barker from Nottingham) show a thriving community. In Turnstone's puzzle, solvers remove Fibonacci-related words such as 'artichoke' from Fibonacci-numbered clues and indicate their grasp of the theme by placing ZERO at the unclued entry. Such creativity deserves a platform.

FAQ