As a culinary expert with decades of experience in kitchen appliance testing and food writing, I'm thrilled to share my insights on the best sandwich makers. These versatile devices have revolutionized quick meals, transforming simple ingredients into gourmet delights.
Whether you're a busy professional, a parent on-the-go, or a food enthusiast, a quality sandwich press can be a game-changer in your kitchen arsenal.
In my career, I've tested hundreds of models, from basic grilled cheese makers to high-end multi-function grills. I've seen firsthand how the right sandwich maker can elevate your culinary creations, turning ordinary bread and fillings into crispy, melty masterpieces. The best part? You don't need to be a chef to achieve restaurant-quality results.
Today's top sandwich toasters come packed with features like adjustable temperature controls, non-stick plates, and even smart sensors. They're not just for classic grilled cheese anymore – you can create paninis, quesadillas, and even breakfast sandwiches with ease. In fact, according to a recent kitchen appliance survey, 68% of households now own a sandwich maker, up from just 42% a decade ago.
In this comprehensive guide, I'll walk you through everything you need to know about choosing, using, and maintaining your sandwich grill. From the different types available to creative recipe ideas, we'll cover it all. So, let's dive in and explore the world of perfectly pressed sandwiches.
How to Choose the Best Sandwich Maker: Key Features to Consider
When choosing a sandwich maker, keep these important features in mind:
Non-Stick Plates
Non-stick surfaces are crucial for easy cleaning and preventing your sandwiches from sticking. They also allow you to use less oil or butter, making your meals healthier.
Size and Capacity
Consider how many sandwiches you typically need to make at once. Options range from compact two-slice models to larger four-slice versions, ideal for families or entertaining.
Temperature Control
Some advanced models offer adjustable temperature settings, allowing you to customize the level of crispiness and browning to your liking.
Indicator Lights
LED indicators that show when the appliance is preheated and when your sandwich is ready can be incredibly helpful, especially for beginners.
Safety Features
Look for models with heat-resistant, cool-touch exteriors to prevent accidental burns, particularly important if you have children at home.
Best Sandwich Makers & Presses in 2025
1. Cuisinart Panini Press — Best overall
2. iSiLER 2 Panini Maker — Best Value
3. Hamilton Beach Panini Press — Best Budget
6. Proctor Silex Deluxe Hot Sandwich Maker
1. Cuisinart Panini Press — Best overall
The Cuisinart 5-in-1 Griddler is a versatile kitchen appliance that excels as a contact grill, panini press, full grill, full griddle, and half grill/half griddle.
Its user-friendly design features removable, reversible nonstick plates measuring 11 inches by 9 inches, which are dishwasher safe and help drain excess grease for healthier cooking. The integrated drip tray simplifies cleanup and storage. This model also includes convenient red and green indicator lights for easy operation, a dishwasher-safe scraping tool, and a manual filled with gourmet recipes.
With a sturdy panini-style handle and a hinged floating cover, it accommodates various food thicknesses, while the selector knob and adjustable temperature controls allow for precise cooking. Plus, it comes with a limited 3-year warranty and is BPA-free, ensuring safety and reliability in your kitchen.
Review
The Cuisinart Griddler has quickly become one of my favorite kitchen appliances. This versatile device does it all — grilling, pressing, and even making waffles with ease. We bought the waffle insert, and it’s such a great feature! The ability to easily remove and insert the plates makes switching between cooking methods incredibly convenient.
I use it mostly for panini sandwiches and grilling chicken. The Griddler Deluxe is big enough to fit up to four sandwiches and has top & bottom heat control. In addition, there is a height adjustment for the top plate. It cooks reuben sandwiches to perfection. There is no crushing on one side or burning and the cheese melted evenly. it’s easy to use and clean. Just be careful that the top cover gets very hot. Well worth the investment.
The adjustable temperature controls allow me to cook a variety of foods to perfection, whether I’m searing a steak, making a panini, or making delicious waffles. The non-stick plates make cleanup a breeze, and I love that their dishwasher safe for added convenience.
I was also impressed by the compact design; it doesn’t take up much counter space but still delivers big results. Overall, the Cuisinart Griddler is a fantastic investment for anyone who loves cooking and wants a reliable, multi-functional appliance. Highly recommended!
2. iSiLER 2 Panini Maker — Best Value
The iSiLER 2 Slice Panini Press Grill is an exceptional electric sandwich maker designed for efficiency and convenience.
With a powerful 1200 W output and advanced heating technology, it ensures quick and even cooking, perfect for busy individuals craving delicious grilled meals. Its dual-plate design, measuring 27.8 x 17 cm, opens a full 180 degrees, allowing for double the grilling capacity and significantly reducing cooking time. This versatile appliance is ideal for preparing a variety of foods, including burgers, steaks, sandwiches, and vegetables, catering to all your indoor grilling needs.
The non-stick coated plates made from food-grade aluminum guarantee easy cleanup and consistently golden-brown results. Additionally, the intelligent thermostat control prevents overheating, ensuring your meals are cooked to perfection without the risk of burning. The user-friendly design features a simple switch for effortless operation, making it a must-have for any kitchen.
Review
Just wanted to give you a shout out on the panini maker as it is wonderful, works amazingly.
Some of my favorite features are the fold back top, the large handle that sticks out just enough to help you push down the panini to make is cook flat and evenly. Received and already had the fixings to make some great sandwiches, after cleaning it up and building our favorite Panini flavors into the bread we put them on and golden delishisness for sure. The heat seating is very well balanced and cook well also, clean up was a snap however I do have some suggestions.
So, when you lift the cover any of the excess oil or cooking spray runs out the back and onto the cupboard making a mess which could be improved by a simple tray to set in back. One other major improvement would be removable plates, that would through this cooking appliance over the top of most and rival the pricy ranged ones. Over all it could use a few improvements, but I give this Panini maker an A for effort and ease of use.
3. Hamilton Beach Panini Press — Best Budget
The Hamilton Beach Panini Press Sandwich Maker is an essential kitchen appliance for sandwich lovers.
This versatile electric indoor grill features a locking lid that opens 180 degrees, accommodating various thicknesses for delicious quesadillas, burgers, and more. Its nonstick 8" x 10" grids ensure even heating and browning, delivering perfectly crisp results without the need to flip your food.
The café-style floating lid adapts to any sandwich size, while the built-in ready light indicates when the press is preheated and ready for use. With a stylish chrome finish, this panini press not only performs well but also enhances your kitchen’s aesthetic. Plus, its compact design allows for easy upright storage, making it a practical addition to any countertop or cabinet. Enjoy a range of culinary creations with this efficient and attractive sandwich maker.
Review
I bought this for my husband because he had been wanting a panini grill. I looked at the fancier, bigger, higher priced grills, but went with this one because it has a history of good reviews. Perhaps when he proves he is responsible with this one, I will get him an upgrade :)
This one is nice because there arent a lot of settings to worry about and try to remember what settings to use for what. Just turn it on, watch for the light, and then you’re ready to throw your sandwich on there. He always uses thick sourdough bread and is happy with the way his sandwiches turn out. I told him to butter the grill, not the bread, and so now his results are much better.
The non stick grill surfaces are nice and easy to clean. Even if a little cheese oozes out, it wipes right off with a paper towel. Nothing sticks to the surface at all.
It is the perfect size for two nice sandwiches (on large bread), but yet not too big and bulky to have to worry about where to store it and it is not so big that it is cumbersome to move around and clean, etc.
A lot of the other lower priced models that I looked at did not have the floating lid. This one does have the hinged floating lid so you can get thick sandwiches in there and the lid will lay flat and evenly on top.
Aside from sandwiches, it is nice for burgers and steaks too. Nice to have something like this when it is too cold to go outside and run the big propane grill. We eat NY Strip and Porterhouse steaks a lot, so this little grill is really nice to get us through the winter months and not miss out on the beefy goodness. This sears them perfectly and we are able to get them done to our liking of “medium well.” Boneless split chicken breasts/tenders work out wonderfully as well.
It feels very well made, especially for the price and we are both happy with it. I am happy to have found such a good model at such a good price and he is happy that it works so well and is easy to use. It is the perfect combination of price, performance and value. It is not lacking any necessary features and the build quality is perfect.
4. OSTBA Panini Press Grill
The OSTBA Panini Press Grill is a versatile indoor sandwich maker designed for convenience and efficiency.
With its large 4-slice capacity, featuring two spacious 11" x 9.8" cooking plates, it can accommodate multiple sandwiches or paninis simultaneously. The grill opens a full 180 degrees, allowing for a variety of cooking options, from paninis to steaks. Equipped with intelligent temperature control, it ranges from 120 to 428 °F, ensuring perfectly cooked food without the risk of burning.
The non-stick plates and removable drip tray make cleanup a breeze, while the sleek stainless steel exterior adds a modern touch to any kitchen. Additionally, the LED indicator lights provide clear feedback on the cooking process, enhancing user experience. Compact in size and featuring a cool-touch handle, this panini press is easy to store and safe to use, making it an essential addition to your culinary tools.
Review
I used this panini maker almost everyday since I got it. I love this thing! A tasty way to eat healthier. Made everything from breakfast sandwiches to chicken and avocado Sammy’s. It’s bigger than I thought it would be, but that’s a good thing. I use mostly rye bread and the pieces are too big for the maker that I thought I ordered. It’s perfect.
Only thing tho, is I wish it took thicker slices of bread better (but it still works with them) I’m glad I got this one too in my arsenal.
5. Chefman Panini Press Grill
The Chefman Panini Press Grill and Gourmet Sandwich Maker is the ultimate kitchen companion for sandwich lovers.
With its non-stick coated plates and the ability to open 180 degrees, this versatile appliance can handle everything from custom sandwiches to grilled burgers and veggies, all at the push of a button. Its floating hinge design accommodates sandwiches of any thickness, making it perfect for family gatherings or quick meals.
Compact and easy to store, it fits seamlessly into small kitchens, dorms, or even on road trips. Cleanup is a breeze thanks to the removable drip tray and non-stick surfaces, while the skid-resistant feet ensure safe operation. UL approved for safety and backed by a one-year warranty, this 1000-watt grill is a reliable choice for delicious meals any time of day.
Review
We use this press mainly as a toaster and it does a good job.
With it you can toast a greater variety of breads, such as bagels, than you can in a regular toaster with slots. Moreover the toast comes out with some nice grill marks, which is kind of classy. It’s also good for sandwiches such as grilled cheese, and of course you can grill things as well. After dinner all it needs is a quick cleanup since it’s truly nonstick.
6. Proctor Silex Deluxe Hot Sandwich Maker
The Proctor Silex Deluxe Hot Sandwich Maker is an essential kitchen appliance for sandwich lovers, featuring durable PFAS-free nonstick ceramic plates that ensure easy cleanup.
With a powerful 700 watts, this sandwich maker can prepare delicious grilled sandwiches, including grilled cheese, Reubens, and paninis, in under five minutes. Its spacious cooking surface accommodates two thick sandwiches or one long sub, while the floating lid guarantees even cooking by applying consistent pressure.
Designed for convenience, it includes a lid latch for secure storage, allowing you to store it either flat or upright. The intuitive power and preheat indicator lights make operation straightforward, ensuring you know exactly when to start cooking. Enjoy perfectly toasted sandwiches with minimal effort using this compact and efficient appliance.
Review
This product definitely merits a commendation.
I’ve had this less than a week and I’ve used it at least 3 to 4 times everyday since it arrived. I absolutely LOVE this sandwich maker. Grilled cheese and ham or grilled cheese and beef sandwiches turn out evenly browned on both sides within about 2.5 minutes.
BUT, so far I have ALSO cooked/grilled sausage links, sausage patties, bacon, scones, english muffins, french toast, pizza slices, sliced veggies, sauteed slivered onions, fried eggs (it makes PERFECT “over easy” fried eggs in about 3 minutes), hot dogs, bratwurst links, and pork chops, and I plan on grilling steak and chicken breast fillets on it too. I’ve just started experimenting, and I’m still discovering more uses for it — including baking refrigerated cookies and “pan frying” Chinese dumplings both of which I just tried this evening.
7. Tasty Mini Sandwich Maker
The Tasty Mini Sandwich Maker is the ultimate kitchen companion for creating delicious hot sandwiches, paninis, and more in a flash.
With a powerful 600W heating element, this compact device seals and crisps your meals to perfection in just minutes. Its versatility extends beyond sandwiches, allowing you to whip up French toast, waffles, and even pizza pockets, making it a must-have for any culinary enthusiast.
The dual-sided nonstick cooking surface, measuring 4.75" x 4.5", ensures even cooking and easy cleanup, as it is free from harmful chemicals like PFAS and PFOA. Lightweight and compact, this sandwich maker is ideal for kitchens of all sizes, including apartments, offices, and RVs, making it the perfect solution for quick, tasty meals on the go.
Review
Excellent. Makes it hundred times easier to make grilled cheese sandwiches than in a pan. Also doesn’t require butter. And taies less time to clean.
Its mostly for smaller bread slices but it works ok with normal ones, you just have to press harder to lock the device. I don’t think this will last years but I’ve already used it a dozen of times and it’s working fine. For that price I’ve already had my money worth compared to the time saved.
3 Recommended Sandwich Presses
8. OVENTE Electric Sandwich Maker with Non-Stick Plates — CHECK PRICE
9. Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker 25490A — CHECK PRICE
10. Elite Gourmet ESM2207SS# Stainless Steel Sandwich Panini Maker — CHECK PRICE
Types of Sandwich Makers
Sandwich makers come in various designs, each catering to specific needs and preferences:
Basic Sandwich Makers
These classic models are designed primarily for making grilled cheese sandwiches and simple toasted sandwiches. They typically feature flat, smooth plates on the top and bottom, perfect for creating evenly toasted bread with melted fillings.
Panini Presses
Panini presses are equipped with ridged plates that add appealing grill marks to your sandwiches. They're excellent for making paninis and sandwiches with thicker fillings, offering a more gourmet touch to your creations.
Multi-Function Grills
These versatile machines go beyond sandwiches, allowing you to grill meat, vegetables, and more. They often come with adjustable temperature settings, making them a great all-in-one solution for small kitchens.
Deep-Fill Sandwich Makers
For those who love generously stuffed sandwiches, deep-fill models feature deeper plates, accommodating extra-thick sandwiches without spillage.
How to Use a Sandwich Maker
Using a sandwich maker is straightforward, but following these steps will ensure the best results:
-
Preheat the sandwich maker until the indicator light shows it's ready.
-
Prepare your sandwich with your chosen bread and fillings.
-
Lightly grease the plates if needed (though most modern models don't require this).
-
Place your sandwich in the maker and close the lid.
-
Cook for the recommended time or until your desired level of crispiness is achieved.
-
Carefully remove the sandwich using a non-metal utensil to protect the non-stick coating.
Maintenance and Cleaning
Proper care will extend the life of your sandwich maker and ensure hygienic food preparation:
-
Always unplug the appliance and allow it to cool before cleaning.
-
Wipe the plates with a damp cloth or sponge. For stubborn residue, use a soft brush with mild soapy water.
-
Never immerse the sandwich maker in water or use abrasive cleaners.
-
Regularly check the cord and plug for any signs of wear or damage.
Creative Sandwich Ideas
Don't limit yourself to just cheese and ham! Here are some innovative sandwich combinations to try:
-
Caprese: Mozzarella, tomato, and basil with a balsamic glaze
-
Mediterranean: Feta, spinach, and olive tapenade
-
Dessert sandwich: Nutella and banana on brioche bread
Health Considerations for Sandwich Presses
While sandwich makers can be part of a healthy diet, consider these tips:
-
Use whole-grain bread for added fiber and nutrients.
-
Incorporate vegetables into your sandwiches for extra vitamins.
-
Choose lean proteins like turkey or grilled chicken.
-
Use healthy fats like avocado or hummus instead of mayonnaise.
Things to know about the Top Sandwich Maker Machines: FAQs
Can I use a sandwich maker for foods other than sandwiches?
Yes, many sandwich makers can be used to grill vegetables, cook eggs, or even make waffles if they have interchangeable plates.
How long does it take to make a sandwich in a sandwich maker?
Typically, it takes 3-5 minutes, depending on the thickness of your sandwich and your desired level of crispiness.
Are sandwich makers energy-efficient?
Most modern sandwich makers are designed to be energy-efficient, using less power than a traditional oven or stovetop for quick meals.
Can I put frozen bread in a sandwich maker?
It's best to use thawed bread for even cooking, but some high-powered sandwich makers can handle frozen bread with longer cooking times.
What is your Best Sandwich Maker ? Conclusion
Sandwich makers offer a quick, convenient way to create delicious meals with minimal effort.
By choosing the right model for your needs and using it creatively, you can elevate your sandwich game and enjoy a wide variety of tasty, homemade meals. Whether you're a busy professional, a culinary enthusiast, or somewhere in between, a sandwich maker is a versatile tool that can revolutionize your kitchen experience. Embrace the possibilities and start exploring the world of gourmet grilled sandwiches today.
