The debate over whether Spanish tortilla should include onion has raged for years, but a 1599 recipe book may finally settle the argument. The Spanish tortilla is a beloved dish, and the question of onion versus no onion has divided purists and modern cooks alike.
Recently, the Real Academia Española (RAE) reminded us of this historical gem on Instagram, dusting off a 1599 cookbook that reveals how our ancestors ate in the 16th century. The book, titled Libro del arte de cozina, is essentially a recipe book detailing culinary techniques, food and drink advice, and the secrets of the steward's trade.
The 1599 Cookbook That Started It All
The Libro del arte de cozina is a window into the past, offering a comprehensive guide to cooking in 16th-century Spain. It covers everything from basic techniques to the proper way to serve meals, and it includes a recipe for a tortilla that might surprise modern cooks.

According to this historical text, the original Spanish tortilla was made with eggs and onions—no potatoes in sight. This is because potatoes, native to the Americas, did not reach Europe until well after the 16th century. So, the earliest tortillas were simple mixtures of eggs and onions, cooked in a pan.
What the Recipe Reveals
The recipe from 1599 describes a dish that is essentially a onion and egg omelet. It instructs the cook to beat eggs, mix them with chopped onions, and cook the mixture until set. This simple preparation was likely a common meal for people of various social classes.
The absence of potato is a key detail. Potatoes were not widely accepted in Europe until the 18th century, and even then, they were often viewed with suspicion. So, for at least two centuries, the Spanish tortilla was a potato-free affair.
The Onion Versus No-Onion Debate
The debate between concebollistas (those who believe onion belongs in the tortilla) and sincebollistas (those who adamantly oppose it) is a passionate one. The 1599 recipe clearly supports the concebollistas, as onion was a foundational ingredient.
However, the modern tortilla, with potato as a star ingredient, did not emerge until potatoes became widely available. Once potatoes were incorporated, the question of whether to keep the onion became a matter of personal preference and regional tradition.
In many parts of Spain, especially in Madrid and the north, onion is commonly included. In other regions, particularly in the south, it is often omitted. The debate is not just about taste but also about identity and tradition.
Why the 1599 Recipe Matters
The 1599 recipe provides historical evidence that onion was part of the earliest tortillas. This doesn't necessarily end the debate, but it does give the concebollistas a strong historical argument. It shows that the use of onion is not a modern innovation but a practice that dates back to the origins of the dish.
For food historians, the recipe is a valuable piece of the puzzle. It helps trace the evolution of Spanish cuisine and the incorporation of New World ingredients like potatoes. It also highlights how recipes adapt over time, reflecting changes in agriculture, economics, and taste.
How the Spanish Tortilla Evolved
The journey from the 1599 onion and egg tortilla to the modern potato tortilla is a fascinating one. Potatoes were initially grown as ornamental plants in Europe, and it took centuries for them to be accepted as food. Once they were, they quickly became a staple in many European cuisines.
In Spain, the potato was integrated into the tortilla, creating the dish we know today. The addition of potato made the tortilla more filling and nutritious, and it became a popular dish across all social classes.
The onion, however, remained a contentious ingredient. Some cooks argued that onion overpowered the delicate flavor of the eggs and potatoes, while others believed it added necessary moisture and sweetness. The debate continues to this day.
Regional Variations
Today, the Spanish tortilla varies widely from region to region. In some areas, it is made with just eggs, potatoes, and olive oil, while in others, onion, peppers, or even chorizo are added. The 1599 recipe is a reminder that the dish has always been flexible and subject to local interpretation.
Despite the variations, the core identity of the tortilla remains: a simple, hearty dish made with eggs and whatever vegetables are on hand. The 1599 recipe captures that spirit, even if the ingredients have changed.
What This Means for Modern Cooks
For modern cooks, the 1599 recipe is a fun historical curiosity but also a practical guide. It encourages experimentation and reminds us that recipes are not set in stone. The next time you make a tortilla, you might consider adding onion, knowing that you are following a tradition that dates back over 400 years.
Of course, if you are a sincebollista, you might choose to ignore history and stick to your convictions. After all, the debate is as much about personal taste as it is about tradition.
The Takeaway
The 1599 cookbook offers a glimpse into the past and provides ammunition for the onion debate. Whether you are a concebollista or a sincebollista, the history of the Spanish tortilla is rich and complex, and it continues to evolve. The background to this story is set out in Tortilla de Patatas Debate: 71% of Spaniards Agree on Onion. A related thread runs through Mercadona and María Pombo Want to Make Tortilla the Spanish Pizza. Earlier coverage in Tortilla de Arroz Recipe: Spanish Rice Omelette Classic shows how the argument developed.
- The 1599 Libro del arte de cozina includes a recipe for tortilla with eggs and onions, no potatoes.
- Potatoes did not reach Europe until the 16th century and were not widely used until later.
- The debate between concebollistas and sincebollistas continues, but history favors onion.
- Modern tortilla variations reflect regional preferences and personal taste.
- Historical recipes remind us that cuisine is always changing.
Comparing Historical and Modern Tortilla Recipes
| Ingredient | 1599 Recipe | Modern Recipe (Con Onion) | Modern Recipe (Sin Onion) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Eggs | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Onion | Yes | Yes | No |
| Potato | No | Yes | Yes |
| Olive Oil | Likely | Yes | Yes |
| Salt | Likely | Yes | Yes |
The table above highlights the key differences between the historical and modern versions of the Spanish tortilla. The 1599 recipe is simpler, relying on just eggs and onions, while modern recipes include potatoes and often olive oil and salt. A closer look at the same subject appears in Tortilla de Guisantes Recipe: Spanish Pea Omelette Classic. Anyone following the wider picture can start with Pincho de Tortilla Recipe: Classic Spanish Potato Tapa. The same theme surfaces in Potato Omelet in Thermomix: Easy Spanish Tortilla Recipe, which takes a different angle.
It's worth noting that the 1599 recipe does not specify olive oil or salt, but these were common ingredients in Spanish cooking at the time. The recipe likely assumed the cook would use them as needed. Context on how this played out before sits in Eggplant Tortilla: Easy Spanish Skillet Classic, Silky & Sweet (65). A companion piece, Egg Prices Soar: José Andrés' No-Egg Tortilla Solution, approaches the same subject from another angle.
FAQ
What is the 1599 Spanish tortilla recipe?
The 1599 recipe from Libro del arte de cozina is a simple dish made with eggs and onions, cooked like an omelet. It does not include potatoes, as they were not yet common in Europe.
Did the original Spanish tortilla have onion?
Yes, according to the 1599 cookbook, the original Spanish tortilla included onion. Potatoes were added later, and the onion debate began.
Why is there a debate about onion in tortilla?
The debate stems from regional and personal preferences. Some argue onion adds flavor and moisture, while others believe it overpowers the dish. The 1599 recipe supports the inclusion of onion.
When did potatoes become part of the Spanish tortilla?
Potatoes were introduced to Europe in the 16th century but were not widely accepted until the 18th century. They gradually became part of the tortilla, leading to the modern version.
The 1599 recipe is a fascinating piece of culinary history that sheds light on the origins of the Spanish tortilla. Whether you are a concebollista or a sincebollista, it's clear that the dish has always been a canvas for creativity and tradition.