Andy Burnham has made lowering the cost of living his first major policy announcement in government, with an immediate tax cut to remove VAT on energy bills. As he begins to flesh out his agenda for government, the prime minister said the measure would provide “breathing space” for households. But Burnham is under close scrutiny over how his plans will be funded.
The Fiscal Challenge Behind Andy Burnham's Spending Pledges
While official figures show the UK borrowed less than expected in June, bond investors are on high alert – wary of Britain’s elevated borrowing and debt levels, the impact of the Iran war, and rising spending pressures. Burnham has pledged to stick to Labour’s fiscal rules, as well as the party’s manifesto promise not to raise taxes on working people. According to the Resolution Foundation, the headroom against the fiscal rule – £23.6bn at the time of the spring statement – is expected to have been cut to about £10bn today. “There is no spare cash lying around,” the thinktank said.
Key Spending Pledges and Their Funding Sources
VAT Cut on Energy Bills
On his first full day, Burnham announced the rate of VAT charged on energy bills in Great Britain would be cut from 5% to zero for the six months from 1 October – the day the regulator Ofgem’s new price cap on energy comes in. Using figures based on a typical household’s energy use, the government said the saving will effectively reduce the annual price cap by £45. The policy will also help by reducing headline inflation by about 0.1 percentage points. However, critics say the measure is poorly targeted, because it will benefit rich households as well as poor, while also subsidising consumption that might have been cut back by those who were able to. Helen Miller, the director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, said: “If the goal is to help low income households, a VAT cut is a poor lever since the biggest cash gains will go towards richer households.”
How Is It Paid For?
Downing Street has not yet fully detailed the funding mechanism, but analysts suggest the government may rely on a combination of increased borrowing, reallocation of existing budgets, and potential windfall taxes on energy companies. The fiscal headroom is shrinking, making it harder to finance new initiatives without breaking fiscal rules.
Comparison of Fiscal Scenarios
| Scenario | Fiscal Headroom | Impact on Borrowing |
|---|---|---|
| Spring Statement 2023 | £23.6bn | Low |
| Current Estimate | ~£10bn | Moderate |
| Post-VAT Cut (Projected) | ~£7bn | High |
Key Takeaways
- Andy Burnham's spending pledges face significant funding challenges due to reduced fiscal headroom.
- The VAT cut on energy bills is a populist measure but criticized for being poorly targeted.
- Bond investors remain wary of UK debt levels and global economic pressures.
- Labour's fiscal rules and tax promises limit options for raising revenue.