The Lucy Letby trial has been rocked by revelations that Prof Peter Hindmarsh, a key expert witness for the prosecution, was barred from treating patients during the trial and later served as an expert in another case. This development raises serious questions about the reliability of expert testimony in high-profile prosecutions.
The Guardian reported this week that Hindmarsh, a consultant paediatric endocrinologist, was excluded from clinical practice in March 2023 by his employer, University College London Hospitals Trust (UCLH). The jury in the Letby trial, which convicted the nurse of murdering seven babies five months later, was never informed of this restriction.
Who Is Prof Peter Hindmarsh?
Prof Hindmarsh is a distinguished paediatric endocrinologist who provided expert evidence on insulin and diabetes in the Letby trial. His testimony was instrumental in securing convictions, particularly regarding the insulin poisoning of two infants.
However, UCLH's decision to bar him from clinical practice was based on concerns that his advice to child patients regarding insulin was not considered safe. This restriction was imposed in March 2023, while the Letby trial was ongoing.
The Impact on the Letby Convictions
The fact that Hindmarsh was barred from treating patients during the trial, and that this information was withheld from the jury, casts further doubt on the prosecution's case. Letby is currently serving 15 whole-life sentences for the murder of seven babies and the attempted murder of six others.

Legal experts suggest that had the jury known about Hindmarsh's restrictions, they might have viewed his testimony with more skepticism. This could potentially affect the outcome of any appeals.
- Prof Hindmarsh was barred from clinical practice by UCLH in March 2023.
- The jury in the Letby trial was not informed of this restriction.
- Hindmarsh's advice on insulin was deemed unsafe.
- He later provided expert testimony in another prosecution.
- The revelation adds to growing concerns about the Letby convictions.
Hindmarsh's Role in the Thomas Case
In August 2023, Hindmarsh produced a crucial expert report for the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) in the case against Damion and Tamara Thomas. The couple were accused of neglecting their 12-year-old son, Joshua, who died from complications of undiagnosed diabetes on 10 December 2022.
Hindmarsh, instructed as an expert in insulin and diabetes, concluded that Joshua's symptoms would have been clear and that medical help should have been sought earlier. This report was used to support the prosecution's case. In March this year, Tamara Thomas was convicted.

Comparison of Expert Witness Restrictions
| Case | Expert Witness | Restriction Date | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lucy Letby Trial | Prof Peter Hindmarsh | March 2023 | Jury not informed; convictions under scrutiny |
| Thomas Case | Prof Peter Hindmarsh | After restriction | Expert report used in prosecution |
The juxtaposition of these two cases highlights a troubling pattern: an expert whose clinical judgment was deemed unsafe by his employer continued to be used by the CPS in other high-stakes prosecutions.
What This Means for the Justice System
This revelation underscores the need for greater transparency in the use of expert witnesses. Defence teams must be informed of any restrictions on an expert's practice, as these could materially affect their credibility.
Moreover, the CPS should review its procedures for vetting expert witnesses. The fact that Hindmarsh was used in another case after being barred from clinical practice suggests a systemic failure.

The Letby case has already been referred to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC). This new information could strengthen the case for an appeal. The Lucy Letby trial expert witness barred from treating patients story is likely to have significant ramifications.
FAQ
Why was Prof Hindmarsh barred from treating patients?
Prof Hindmarsh was barred by UCLH because his advice to child patients regarding insulin was not considered safe. The restriction was imposed in March 2023 during the Letby trial.
Was the jury in the Letby trial informed about Hindmarsh's restriction?
No, the jury was never told about the restriction on Hindmarsh's clinical practice. This lack of transparency could have affected their assessment of his testimony.
What was Hindmarsh's role in the Thomas case?
Hindmarsh provided an expert report for the CPS in the case against Damion and Tamara Thomas, concluding that their son Joshua's diabetes symptoms should have been recognized earlier. Tamara Thomas was convicted in March this year.

Could this affect Lucy Letby's convictions?
Legal experts believe this revelation could strengthen the case for appeal, as it undermines the credibility of a key prosecution witness. The CCRC is already reviewing the case.
The implications of this story extend beyond the Letby case. It raises questions about how expert witnesses are vetted and whether defence teams have access to all relevant information. As the Letby convictions under fire after expert witness restrictions continue to be debated, the justice system must address these systemic issues.
In the meantime, the families of the victims in both cases are left to grapple with the uncertainty. For the Letby case, the Lucy Letby conviction: final Thirlwall report impact on case will be crucial in determining the next steps. The Thirlwall Inquiry, which is examining the circumstances surrounding the deaths, may also consider these new revelations.

The Lucy Letby case review: Thirlwall Inquiry should have waited argument gains new weight, as the inquiry might have benefited from knowing about Hindmarsh's restrictions before concluding. Additionally, the use of AI in healthcare, such as AI in rural healthcare: how Ant Afu helps one doctor treat 2,000 patients, highlights the importance of reliable medical expertise. As the legal proceedings unfold, the focus must remain on ensuring justice for all involved.