The Plot Review: Gunpowder, Treason and Myth Exploded 2026

The Plot review reveals a compelling stage production that explodes the myths surrounding the gunpowder plot of 1605. In this two-hander, Thomas and Robert Wintour test each other's tolerance for flame, setting the tone for a story about risk, betrayal, and the spin of history. As they navigate purgatory, they reflect on their failed conspiracy and the fate of Guy Fawkes, who has become England's scapegoat.

The Gunpowder Plot: Beyond the Myth

Writer-director Emma Howlett digs beneath the simplified story of 5 November fireworks to uncover a web of power play and political manipulation. The play suggests that almost everyone except Fawkes was complicit in the intrigue, from the Catholic conspirators to the court of James I. Shakespeare himself may have channelled these events into Macbeth, warning of the dangers of usurping a king.

Performances and Direction

Sophie Kean and Abby McCann bring immense energy to their roles, donning doublet and hose to tell this very male story. However, the formal, period-style text often weighs them down, and their declamatory delivery misses the subtlety the dialogue demands. The physical invention is less polished than last year's Aether, but the raw passion still shines through.

Historical Context and Themes

The play explores how history is written by the victors, and how myths are created to serve political ends. It questions the public memory of Guy Fawkes, who is often vilified while the more powerful conspirators escape scrutiny. The production at Summerhall, Edinburgh, runs until 31 August, offering festival-goers a thought-provoking alternative to typical history lessons.

Comparison: The Plot vs. Traditional History Lessons

Key Takeaways from The Plot Review

• The play deconstructs the Gunpowder Plot myth, revealing political spin.
• Strong performances from Kean and McCann, though dialogue feels stiff.
• Shakespeare's Macbeth is linked to the 1605 events.
• Recommended for those seeking a critical look at history.
• Runs at Summerhall, Edinburgh, until 31 August.

FAQ

Overall, The Plot review suggests a play with a strong concept but uneven execution. It's a must-see for history buffs who appreciate a critical lens, but those seeking a light-hearted drama may find it heavy. The production's ambition to explode myths is commendable, even if it occasionally gets lost in its own formality.