A senior surgeon has called for a criminal investigation into a Scottish hospital after it emerged that at least 19 patients died from avoidable complications due to surgery. Dr Mohammed Habib, a consultant at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, alleges that senior officials at NHS Grampian failed to act on his repeated warnings about liver and pancreatic surgery from 2021 onwards.
Whistleblower Alleges Cover-Up at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary
Dr Habib, a consultant at the hospital, said he had repeatedly reported concerns about the hospital's liver and pancreatic surgery from 2021 onwards. He believes dozens of patients may have died unnecessarily there.
Calling for a police investigation into corporate homicide at the hospital, Habib alleged that senior officials at NHS Grampian, the crisis-hit health board which runs it, failed to take the correct action quickly enough. His claims were discussed in Holyrood on Thursday.
Internal Report Confirms 19 Surgery-Related Deaths
Habib said NHS Grampian eventually commissioned an expert report to investigate his allegations, and those from a second whistleblower. That report confirmed his allegations that 19 patients had died due to serious adverse events caused by surgery between 2015 and 2021.
The internal report was published on Thursday by Habib's solicitor, Aamer Anwar. It has not been independently verified, but its release has intensified calls for accountability.
First Minister Responds to 'Gravest Concern'
John Swinney, Scotland's first minister, said Habib's disclosures were of the gravest concern. He acknowledged that the NHS had legal duties to give patients the best possible care and to quickly investigate allegations about safety failures.
However, Swinney rebuffed demands from Michael Marra, the Scottish Labour leader, for a criminal investigation. The first minister instead emphasised that the health board must act on the findings.
Why This Matters for Patient Safety
The allegations raise serious questions about how NHS Grampian handled whistleblower concerns. If true, they suggest a systemic failure to protect patients from avoidable harm.
For families affected, the report may provide long-sought answers. For the wider public, it underscores the importance of robust clinical governance and transparent investigation of safety incidents.
Key Takeaways
- 19 deaths linked to serious adverse events in surgery between 2015 and 2021 at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.
- Dr Mohammed Habib alleges NHS Grampian failed to act on his warnings from 2021 onwards.
- Internal report commissioned by NHS Grampian confirmed the allegations, according to Habib.
- First Minister John Swinney called the disclosures 'of the gravest concern' but resisted calls for a criminal probe.
- Police investigation into corporate homicide is being demanded by Habib and solicitor Aamer Anwar.
Comparison of Positions
| Stakeholder | Position |
|---|---|
| Dr Mohammed Habib | Calls for police investigation into corporate homicide; alleges NHS Grampian failed to act quickly. |
| NHS Grampian | Commissioned expert report; has not publicly commented on the allegations. |
| John Swinney (First Minister) | Expresses grave concern; rebuffs demands for criminal investigation. |
| Michael Marra (Scottish Labour) | Demands criminal investigation into the deaths. |
What to Watch Next
Pressure is mounting on NHS Grampian to explain how it responded to whistleblower concerns. The Scottish government may face further questions about oversight of health boards.
Families of the deceased may seek legal advice on potential claims. The possibility of a public inquiry or independent review remains open. The background to this story is set out in Elderly: latest articles.
FAQ
What happened at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary?
What happened at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary?
An internal report confirmed that 19 patients died due to serious adverse events caused by surgery between 2015 and 2021. A consultant surgeon, Dr Mohammed Habib, alleges that NHS Grampian failed to act on his warnings.
Why is a police investigation being demanded?
Why is a police investigation being demanded?
Dr Habib and his solicitor, Aamer Anwar, are calling for a police investigation into corporate homicide, alleging that senior NHS Grampian officials failed to take timely action to prevent avoidable deaths.
How has the Scottish government responded?
How has the Scottish government responded?
First Minister John Swinney said the disclosures were 'of the gravest concern' but rebuffed calls for a criminal investigation, emphasizing that health boards must investigate safety failures quickly.
What should patients or families do if they have concerns?
What should patients or families do if they have concerns?
They should seek independent legal advice and consider contacting the health board's complaints team or the Scottish Public Services Ombudsman. Support groups and solicitors specializing in clinical negligence can provide guidance.