The introduction of zero-hours custody officers in private prisons has sparked significant controversy, as HMP Millsike near York seeks to recruit staff on a flexible, task-based basis. The outsourcing company Mitie has proposed this model to the Prison Service, raising concerns about workers' rights and prison safety. Andy Burnham, the Prime Minister, is under pressure to intervene, especially given the government's pledge to curb zero-hours contracts.
The Controversy Over Zero-Hours Contracts in Prisons
Zero-hours contracts have long been criticized for undermining job security and stability. In the prison sector, they are particularly alarming because custody officers perform a highly pressured and often hostile role. The POA, the prison officers' union, has condemned the move as an attempt to introduce casualised labour into the prison system.
What Are Zero-Hours Contracts?
Zero-hours contracts do not guarantee a minimum number of working hours. Employees are called in as needed, which can lead to unpredictable income and a lack of benefits. For prison officers, this could mean inconsistent staffing levels, potentially compromising safety.
The Situation at HMP Millsike
HMP Millsike, a category C prison with 1,500 prisoners, has about 350 empty cells due to a staff shortfall. Mitie has advertised £25-an-hour prisoner escort roles on a zero-hours basis, but the POA argues this is a dangerous precedent. The union's deputy general secretary, Mick Pimblett, stated that prison officers are committed professionals and treating them like zero-hours contractors is disgraceful.
| Aspect | Zero-Hours Contract | Permanent Contract |
|---|---|---|
| Guaranteed hours | None | Fixed schedule |
| Income stability | Variable | Predictable |
| Job security | Low | High |
| Impact on prison safety | Risk of understaffing | Consistent coverage |
Key Takeaways
- Mitie's proposal to use zero-hours contracts at HMP Millsike is under government consideration.
- The prison has 350 empty cells due to recruitment failures, exacerbating the capacity crisis.
- The POA calls on the Prime Minister to intervene, citing the government's own pledge against zero-hours contracts.
- Early prisoner release schemes are already controversial, and this move adds to the pressure on Burnham.
FAQ
Why are zero-hours contracts problematic in prisons?
What is the government's stance on zero-hours contracts?
How does this affect prison safety?
The controversy highlights the broader challenges facing the prison system, including staffing shortages and the ethical implications of casualised labour. As the government reviews the proposal, the decision will set a precedent for the entire prison estate.
Best Products We’ve Tested and Rated

Our testing team has hands-on reviews of winter gloves letter carriers, stash bags, snow boots walkers, shoes pacific crest trail, and over helmet ski hood. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.
Our testing team has hands-on reviews of ice climbing rope, low cut shoes, heated boots, cooler sup seat, and backpack philmont. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.