Air Fryer vs Toaster: Why We Retired Our Toaster for Good 2026

When our toaster finally died, we never replaced it. Instead, we started making toast in the air fryer—and it turned out so well that we haven't looked back. What began as a temporary fix has become our go-to method for breakfast bread, and here's why you might want to try it too.

How Air Fryer Toast Works: Forced Convection vs Radiant Heat

A traditional toaster uses radiant heat from nearby elements, which can dry out bread unevenly. An air fryer, on the other hand, circulates hot air at high speed—a process called forced convection. This rapid air movement surrounds the bread completely, sealing the surface quickly while keeping the inside tender.

The result? Toast that's crispy on the outside and soft in the middle, without the dreaded dried-out center. It's a game-changer for anyone who loves artisanal loaves with irregular slices.

No More Slot Limits: Why Thick or Odd-Shaped Bread Wins

If you've ever tried to fit a thick slice of sourdough into a toaster slot, you know the struggle. The air fryer basket has no such restrictions. Whether it's a chunky slice from a rustic boule or a delicate piece of brioche, the air fryer handles it with ease.

We're big fans of tall, uneven slices—and since switching to the air fryer, that problem is gone. You can toast multiple slices at once without cramming them into narrow slots.

Speed and Efficiency: Does a 1,500W Air Fryer Beat a Toaster?

At first glance, using a 1,500-watt appliance for two slices of bread might seem overkill compared to a small toaster. But the key is preheating time—or lack thereof. The air fryer reaches toasting temperature almost instantly, so there's no waiting around.

That said, don't expect to save on your electricity bill by using the air fryer for toast. The higher wattage means it consumes more power during use, but the speed often balances it out. For us, the convenience and quality outweigh the minor energy cost. The background to this story is set out in Best Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combos: Top Models Reviewed. A related thread runs through Lidl Pastel Kitchen Appliances: Air Fryer and Espresso Deals. Earlier coverage in Philips 4000 Air Fryer Review: Dual Basket for Small Kitchens shows how the argument developed.

Air Fryer vs Toaster: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Key Takeaways for Your Kitchen

• Even crisping: Air fryer's forced convection seals the surface without drying the center.
• No slot constraints: Thick, irregular, or large slices fit easily in the basket.
• Fast results: Little to no preheating means toast is ready in minutes.
• Versatility: One appliance can toast, roast, and reheat—saving counter space.
• Energy trade-off: Higher wattage but quicker toasting; not a major cost saver.

What to Watch Next: Tips for Perfect Air Fryer Toast

To get the best results, preheat your air fryer for a couple of minutes at 350°F (175°C). Place slices in a single layer, and check after 2-3 minutes—toast can go from golden to burnt quickly. For even browning, flip halfway through. A closer look at the same subject appears in Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven 1800W 8-in-1 Review. Anyone following the wider picture can start with Breville Eye Q Toaster Review: Perfect Toast Every Time. The same theme surfaces in Lidl Silvercrest Retro Toaster: 6 Browning Levels and Defrost Function, which takes a different angle.

If you're feeding a crowd, you can toast several slices at once, but avoid overcrowding the basket. And remember, the air fryer excels at more than toast—try reheating leftovers or crisping up snacks. Context on how this played out before sits in Essential Cheap Air Fryer Accessories to Avoid Constant Cleaning. A companion piece, Lidl's Connected Air Fryer: Smart Cooking Under 55 Euros, approaches the same subject from another angle.