Tony Blair has reportedly offered advice to Andy Burnham on rejoining the EU, raising the question: should the Labour leader listen? The revelation comes amid Burnham's recent ascent to party leadership, sparking debate over the wisdom of taking counsel from the former prime minister.
The Blair-Burnham Connection: A Historical Perspective
Tony Blair and Andy Burnham share a complex history. Their relationship dates back to 2010, when a young Burnham, then a cabinet member under Gordon Brown, secretly sought Blair's advice on a potential leadership bid. That clandestine meeting underscores Blair's enduring, if sometimes controversial, influence on Labour hopefuls.
Since leaving Downing Street in 2007, Blair has remained a polarizing figure. His advocacy for EU rejoin and his critiques of Brexit have kept him in the political spotlight, but also at arm's length from current Labour leadership. Burnham, like his predecessors, must weigh the benefits of Blair's experience against the baggage it carries.
Why Blair's EU Advice Matters
Blair's insights on the EU are not trivial. As prime minister, he navigated complex European negotiations and understands the bloc's intricacies. His advice could provide Burnham with a roadmap for rejoin, a topic gaining traction as Brexit's economic costs become clearer.
However, Burnham's public stance on Brexit has been cautious. He has advocated for closer ties with the EU but stopped short of full-throated support for rejoin, mindful of the political sensitivities in Labour's heartlands. Blair's advice might push Burnham toward a bolder position, but at what cost?
The Risks of Embracing Blair's Counsel
Blair remains a divisive figure within Labour. Many members view his legacy—particularly the Iraq War—as a stain. Associating too closely with Blair could alienate the party's left wing and revive internal divisions. Burnham, who has worked to distance himself from New Labour, risks undermining that effort by openly embracing Blair's advice.
Moreover, rejoin is not a simple proposition. The EU has changed, and the UK's re-entry would involve complex negotiations, potential loss of opt-outs, and significant political capital. Burnham must consider whether the public appetite for rejoin justifies the risk.
Comparing the Pros and Cons of Blair's EU Advice
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Blair's deep EU expertise | Blair's unpopularity among Labour left |
| Strategic guidance on rejoin | Potential party division |
| Enhanced economic credibility | Risk of alienating Brexit voters |
| International connections | Perception of returning to New Labour |
Key Takeaways for Andy Burnham
- Weigh the expertise: Blair's knowledge of EU mechanics is unmatched, but it comes with political baggage.
- Consider the base: Labour's left wing may revolt if Blair's influence becomes too visible.
- Timing is crucial: Pushing for rejoin too soon could backfire if public opinion isn't ready.
- Maintain independence: Burnham should adopt advice selectively, not appear as Blair's proxy.
FAQ
What advice did Tony Blair give Andy Burnham on the EU?
While details remain private, Blair has publicly advocated for the UK to rejoin the EU, suggesting a long-term strategy to rebuild ties. His advice likely involves gradual steps toward closer alignment and eventual rejoin.
Is Andy Burnham likely to follow Blair's advice?
Burnham has shown cautious openness to EU rejoin but must balance it against party unity and electoral risks. He may take Blair's advice under advisement without fully embracing it publicly.
Why is Tony Blair so controversial within Labour?
Blair's legacy includes the Iraq War and New Labour's centrist policies, which many in the party's left wing oppose. His continued involvement in politics is seen by some as undermining current leadership.
What are the chances of the UK rejoining the EU?
Currently low in the short term, as both major parties avoid the topic. However, shifting economic realities and public opinion could make rejoin a viable issue in the next decade.
Conclusion: A Calculated Risk
Andy Burnham faces a dilemma: embrace Blair's EU advice and risk party fractures, or ignore it and miss strategic insights. Ultimately, the decision hinges on Burnham's political instincts and his vision for Labour's future. Blair's counsel may be valuable, but the messenger remains as contentious as the message.