In the new film Tenzing review, director Jennifer Peedom and screenwriter Luke Davies reconstruct the first summit of Everest with Sherpa Tenzing Norgay at the centre of the story. This well-intentioned, watchable drama offers NatGeo-level production values and greenscreen jeopardy on high peaks, but sometimes feels soft-edged. Yet its mission is clear: to restore Tenzing’s achievement to the narrative heart, challenging the long-held assumption that Edmund Hillary was the sole hero of 1953.
Plot and Historical Context
The film chronicles the triumphant Mount Everest expedition of 1953, in which Nepalese-Indian mountaineer Tenzing Norgay and New Zealander Edmund Hillary reached the ultimate ascent. Tenzing, a former Sherpa guide whose unparalleled knowledge of the mountain and exemplary climbing skills earned him promotion to full team member, is played by Tibetan actor Genden Phuntsok. Hillary is robustly portrayed by Tom Hiddleston. The narrative intersperses the great climb with flashbacks to Tenzing’s early life—not Hillary’s—starting with his awestruck childhood encounter with the legendary mountain.
At the time, the conquest was resoundingly claimed for Hillary and the British empire: a glorious redemption of Scott’s Antarctic ordeal 41 years earlier and a sign of divine approval for the imminent coronation of Queen Elizabeth II. For years, many assumed Tenzing was somehow Hillary’s servant or military-style batman, a Sancho Panza figure to whom Hillary had just been sentimentally loyal. This film corrects that misperception.
Cast and Characters
Genden Phuntsok delivers a dignified, understated performance as Tenzing, capturing both his physical prowess and quiet determination. Tom Hiddleston brings charisma and a touch of imperial swagger to Hillary, while Willem Dafoe is solid as expedition leader John Hunt. The supporting cast, including Sherpa team members, adds authenticity, though some characters remain underdeveloped.
Direction and Visuals
Jennifer Peedom, known for her documentary Sherpa, brings a keen eye for mountain landscapes. The film’s cinematography captures the awe-inspiring scale of Everest, though some greenscreen work is noticeable. The pacing occasionally drags in the flashback sequences, but the climbing scenes are tense and well-edited.
Strengths and Weaknesses
Strengths: The film’s commitment to centering Tenzing’s perspective is commendable. It highlights his expertise and the crucial role he played, challenging the colonial narrative. The performances, especially Phuntsok’s, are compelling.
Weaknesses: The screenplay sometimes oversimplifies complex historical dynamics. The British expedition’s imperial context is touched upon but not deeply explored. Some emotional beats feel manipulative, and the greenscreen effects can take you out of the moment.
Comparison with Other Everest Films
| Film | Year | Focus | Tenzing’s Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tenzing | 2024 | Tenzing Norgay | Central hero |
| Everest | 2015 | 1996 disaster | Not featured |
| The Wildest Dream | 2010 | George Mallory | Minor mention |
| Beyond the Edge | 2013 | 1953 expedition | Co-lead |
Key Takeaways
- Tenzing Norgay is finally portrayed as the hero of the 1953 Everest expedition.
- The film challenges the traditional narrative that credited Edmund Hillary exclusively.
- Strong performances, especially from Genden Phuntsok, elevate the material.
- Visuals are impressive but occasionally undermined by obvious greenscreen.
- The screenplay could delve deeper into the imperial context of the climb.
FAQ
Is Tenzing historically accurate?
Is Tenzing historically accurate?
The film is largely accurate in its portrayal of Tenzing’s role, though it takes some dramatic liberties with dialogue and minor events. It correctly highlights his expertise and equal partnership with Hillary.
Who plays Tenzing Norgay?
Who plays Tenzing Norgay?
Tibetan actor Genden Phuntsok portrays Tenzing Norgay. Tom Hiddleston plays Edmund Hillary, and Willem Dafoe appears as John Hunt.
Where was Tenzing filmed?
Where was Tenzing filmed?
The film was shot in New Zealand and Nepal, with studio work for high-altitude scenes. Some greenscreen was used to simulate Everest’s peaks.
Final Verdict
Tenzing is a worthy attempt to correct a historical injustice. While it sometimes falters in execution, its heart is in the right place. For those interested in Everest’s history or Sherpa culture, it’s a compelling watch that sheds light on a forgotten hero.