Older Australians want house prices to fall for their kids' sake, challenging the long-held notion that rising property values are universally beneficial. Pete Muskens, a 71-year-old retired architect from Melbourne, is among those calling for change. He bought his first home in the early 1980s for about $30,000—less than three times the average annual wage. Today, such affordability is unimaginable for his two adult children.
The Housing Affordability Crisis in Australia
Australia's housing market has transformed from places to live into money-making assets, pushing younger generations to the brink. The decades-long crisis has reshaped family life, delaying milestones like independent living and starting a family. Many Australians in their 30s still live at home, a situation Muskens describes as an unhealthy social effect.
Generational Divide on Property Prices
While some older homeowners benefit from skyrocketing prices, others like Muskens are concerned about intergenerational equity. They believe that housing should be a home first, not an investment vehicle. This perspective is gaining traction as the government introduces property tax reforms to negative gearing and capital gains tax.
Government Reforms and Their Impact
The government's recent budget reforms aim to make real estate less lucrative for new investors by reducing incentives. These changes have faced fierce criticism from political opponents, conservative commentators, and parts of the property sector. However, supporters argue that the reforms are a crucial step in transforming houses back into homes.
Negative Gearing and Capital Gains Tax Changes
Negative gearing allows investors to offset losses against taxable income, while capital gains tax concessions reduce tax on profits from property sales. Reforming these policies could cool investor demand and make housing more affordable for first-home buyers.

| Year | Median House Price | Average Annual Wage | Price-to-Income Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1980s | $30,000 | $10,000 | 3x |
| 2020s | $800,000 | $90,000 | 8.9x |
Why Older Australians Support Falling Prices
Many older Australians prioritize their children's future over their own wealth. They recognize that inflated property values create barriers for younger generations, leading to social and economic consequences. By supporting policies that lower prices, they hope to restore fairness and opportunity.
- Intergenerational equity: Ensuring younger generations can afford homes.
- Social health: Reducing the number of adults living with parents.
- Economic balance: Shifting investment from speculative property to productive assets.
Challenges and Criticisms
Opponents argue that falling house prices could hurt homeowners and the economy. However, proponents believe that a gradual correction is necessary to prevent a larger crisis. The debate continues as Australia grapples with housing affordability.
FAQ
Why do older Australians want house prices to fall?
Many older Australians are concerned about their children's ability to afford homes. They believe that falling prices will restore intergenerational equity and allow younger people to achieve milestones like homeownership and starting a family.
What are negative gearing and capital gains tax reforms?
Negative gearing allows investors to deduct property losses from taxable income. Capital gains tax reforms reduce concessions on profits from property sales. Together, these changes aim to discourage speculative investment and improve housing affordability.
How will falling house prices affect the Australian economy?
While falling prices may reduce wealth for some homeowners, they can make housing more accessible and redirect investment into productive sectors. A gradual correction is seen by supporters as necessary for long-term economic health.