The TUC is urging a robust review of the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), claiming its current approach holds back economic growth and public investment. This call comes as the new chancellor, John Healey, prepares his first budget, with unions demanding a modernized fiscal framework.
Why the OBR Faces Scrutiny Over Economic Growth
The TUC argues that the OBR's models are stuck in outdated austerity-era assumptions, particularly the belief that public investment crowds out private capital. This approach, they say, undervalues the long-term benefits of government spending on infrastructure and social programs, which are essential for sustainable economic growth.
Paul Nowak, TUC's general secretary, stated: "For too long, the OBR has been a millstone preventing good growth across the country. The world has moved on from the self-defeating logic of austerity, but the OBR models still bake in its false assumptions."
Support from Think Tanks and Campaign Groups
The TUC's critique is echoed by various organizations, including Progress (from the Labour right) and the New Economics Foundation (left-wing). Louisa Dollimore of the Good Growth Foundation previously described the OBR as "a backseat driver with out-of-date maps" that obstructs long-term planning and investment.
This growing consensus suggests that the OBR's methodology may need significant updates to align with modern economic thinking and support ambitious public investment strategies.
Comparing OBR's Approach to Alternative Economic Models
| Factor | Current OBR Approach | Proposed Alternative |
|---|---|---|
| Public Investment Impact | Assumes crowding out of private capital | Recognizes crowding in and multiplier effects |
| Growth Forecasts | Conservative, often pessimistic | Optimistic, based on long-term potential |
| Policy Evaluation | Short-term fiscal rules | Long-term social and economic returns |
Key Takeaways from the Call for OBR Review
- The TUC wants a "root and branch" review to modernize OBR assumptions.
- There is cross-party support from think tanks for reforming the forecaster.
- New OBR chair Jonathan Haskel has expressed more pessimistic forecasts than peers.
- The review could lead to higher public investment and stronger growth.
What a Review Could Mean for UK Fiscal Policy
If Healey orders a review, it could reshape how the OBR evaluates public spending, potentially unlocking billions for infrastructure, green energy, and social care. This aligns with Labour's promise of "good growth in every postcode" and could boost confidence among investors and the public.
However, any changes must maintain the OBR's credibility as an independent watchdog. Balancing fiscal responsibility with growth-friendly policies will be key to the review's success.
FAQ
What is the OBR and why does it matter?
Why does the TUC want a review of the OBR?
How could an OBR review affect the UK economy?
Best Products We’ve Tested and Rated

Our testing team has hands-on reviews of anti sway hitch camper, heater, trunk, dehumidifier camper, and water pump. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.
Our testing team has hands-on reviews of covers, wind break, outdoor rugs, water jug, and tent motorcycle. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.