Healthy ultra-processed foods might sound like a contradiction, but dietitian Noah Praamsma argues that some can genuinely benefit your health. Praamsma, who works with the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine, is challenging the idea that all ultra-processed foods are bad—a stance that has become almost taboo among advocates of "real food."
His message is nuanced: while he supports limiting ultra-processed foods overall, he also calls for recognition of "healthy ultra-processed foods." This distinction matters as more people seek clear guidance on what to eat.
What Are Ultra-Processed Foods and Why the Concern?
Ultra-processed foods (UPFs) are industrial formulations typically high in added sugars, salt, and saturated fats. They often contain additives and little whole food content. According to a recent HER report from Duke University for the US, UPFs make up 53–58% of adults' calories and 62% of children's and adolescents' calories.
This high consumption is linked to health risks, which is why Praamsma and others propose measures to limit exposure and intake. But he also adds a crucial caveat: the acceptance of healthy ultra-processed foods.
What Makes an Ultra-Processed Food 'Healthy'?
The criteria for exception are strict. A healthy ultra-processed food must provide adequate amounts of recommended food groups, keep sugars, salt, and saturated fat below recommended thresholds, and contain no non-caloric sweeteners.
By these standards, many breads and cereals marketed as healthy or "realfooder" would not qualify. This highlights how rigorous the definition is—and why few products meet it.
The Strict Criteria for Healthy UPFs
To be considered healthy, an ultra-processed food must meet all these conditions:
- Provides appropriate amounts of recommended food groups (like whole grains, fruits, vegetables, or lean proteins).
- Keeps added sugars below recommended limits.
- Keeps sodium (salt) below recommended limits.
- Keeps saturated fat below recommended limits.
- Contains no non-caloric sweeteners (like aspartame or stevia).
These criteria ensure that only genuinely nutritious products earn the label, preventing misleading health claims.
Why This Matters for Public Health
The debate over UPFs is noisy, with conflicting messages confusing consumers. Praamsma's stance cuts through by acknowledging that processing isn't inherently bad—it's about the nutritional profile.
For example, fortified whole-grain cereals, unsweetened plant-based milks, and some packaged whole-grain breads can be part of a healthy diet if they meet the criteria. This matters for people who rely on convenience foods due to time, budget, or access.
Who Is Affected?
Everyone eats processed foods to some degree, but the impact is greatest for children and adolescents, who get 62% of their calories from UPFs. Improving the quality of these foods could significantly benefit their health.
Also, low-income families often depend on affordable processed options. Recognizing healthy UPFs gives them better choices without requiring a complete diet overhaul.
How to Identify Healthy Ultra-Processed Foods
Use the criteria above to evaluate products. Check the nutrition facts panel for added sugars, sodium, and saturated fat. Look for whole grains as a first ingredient and avoid products with non-caloric sweeteners.
Be skeptical of health claims on packaging—many "healthy" breads and cereals fail the test. Opt for minimally processed versions when possible, but don't dismiss all processed foods. The background to this story is set out in 8 Family Tips to Cut Ultra-Processed Foods for Better Health. A related thread runs through Ultra-Processed Foods: FSA Must Update Guidance and Regulate. Earlier coverage in Cutting Ultra-Processed Foods Could Prevent Heart Disease Deaths shows how the argument developed.
Comparison of Ultra-Processed Food Examples
| Product | Added Sugar | Sodium | Saturated Fat | Non-Caloric Sweeteners | Meets Healthy UPF Criteria? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whole-grain cereal (unsweetened) | Low | Low | Low | No | Yes |
| White bread (packaged) | Moderate | Moderate | Low | No | No (refined grains) |
| Sweetened granola | High | Low | Moderate | No | No (high sugar) |
| Diet soda | None | Low | None | Yes | No (sweeteners) |
| Fortified plant-based milk (unsweetened) | None | Low | Low | No | Yes |
The Bottom Line
Noah Praamsma's perspective offers a balanced approach: limit ultra-processed foods overall, but recognize that some can be healthy. This nuanced view can help consumers make better choices without fear. A closer look at the same subject appears in Reducing Ultra-Processed Foods Could Cut Heart Disease Deaths. Anyone following the wider picture can start with Ozempic Reshapes Eating Habits as Ultra-Processed Foods Cash. The same theme surfaces in Ultra-Processed Foods: Why the Food Standards Agency Must Act, which takes a different angle.
As the debate continues, look for products that meet the strict criteria and prioritize whole foods most of the time. Small swaps can add up to meaningful health benefits. Context on how this played out before sits in How to Eat Well in Your 50s: A Realistic Guide for Men's Health. A companion piece, Ultra-Processed Foods Are Kneecapping Mediterranean Cooking, approaches the same subject from another angle.
FAQ
What is a healthy ultra-processed food?
A healthy ultra-processed food meets strict criteria: it provides recommended food groups, has low added sugar, salt, and saturated fat, and contains no non-caloric sweeteners. Examples include unsweetened whole-grain cereals and fortified plant-based milks.
Why does Noah Praamsma say some ultra-processed foods are healthy?
Praamsma argues that processing itself isn't harmful; the nutritional content matters. Some ultra-processed foods can be part of a healthy diet if they meet strict nutrient criteria, offering convenience and affordability.
How much ultra-processed food do people eat?
According to a Duke University report, ultra-processed foods make up 53–58% of adults' calories and 62% of children's and adolescents' calories in the US.
Should I avoid all ultra-processed foods?
Not necessarily. While limiting ultra-processed foods is wise, some can be healthy. Focus on whole foods most of the time and choose ultra-processed options that meet the healthy criteria.