NSW underquoting laws have been paused, with the state government mothballing reforms just hours before they were due to take effect. The decision leaves buyers exposed to misleading price guides, while Victoria's underquoting ban offers a contrasting approach.
Underquoting is the practice of advertising a property at a price below the seller's actual reserve, luring in buyers who then face higher auction prices. It's a persistent problem in Australian real estate, particularly in Sydney and Melbourne where auctions dominate.
What Happened in NSW?
On Monday, the New South Wales government announced it would not proceed with underquoting reforms scheduled to start that day. Premier Chris Minns said he made the call after real estate agents in his electorate argued the rules would make it harder for sellers.
The reforms aimed to force advertised price guides to match the seller's true asking price. Similar rules were proposed in Victoria, where a ban on underquoting came into effect last month.
Why Underquoting Matters for Buyers
Underquoting distorts the market and wastes buyers' time and money. Linda Assaf, a Sydney buyer, spent six months searching before attending an auction where the home sold $100,000 above the guide price. She had already paid for due diligence.

A second auction saw a property sell $200,000 over the advertised range. "The last auction that we went to was a little bit soul destroying," Assaf said. "We thought that we had a chance."
Such experiences are common, especially in a downturn when buyers are more price-sensitive. Underquoting artificially inflates competition and final sale prices, worsening affordability.
Victoria's Underquoting Ban: Does It Work?
Victoria introduced its underquoting ban last month, requiring agents to provide a reasonable estimated selling price and update it if it changes. Agents must also keep records of their price estimates.
Early reports suggest the ban has had some effect, but enforcement remains a challenge. The Victorian government has committed to monitoring compliance and penalising offenders.
However, the ban's success depends on rigorous oversight and buyer awareness. Without proper enforcement, underquoting can persist in subtler forms.
Key Takeaways for Buyers
- NSW reforms paused: Underquoting rules are on hold, so buyers must remain vigilant.
- Victoria's ban active: The state now requires accurate price guides, but enforcement is key.
- Due diligence costs: Buyers often pay for inspections before auctions, only to be outbid.
- Market impact: Underquoting inflates prices and undermines trust in the auction system.
- Advocacy needed: Consumer groups call for stronger protections and transparency.
Comparing Underquoting Rules: NSW vs. Victoria
| Aspect | NSW | Victoria |
|---|---|---|
| Status of reforms | Paused | In effect |
| Price guide requirement | No change | Must be reasonable estimate |
| Enforcement | Existing laws only | New penalties for breaches |
| Buyer protection | Limited | Stronger, but monitoring needed |
What This Means for the Housing Market
The pause in NSW sends a signal that real estate agents' concerns outweigh buyer protections. This could embolden underquoting practices, especially in a cooling market where sellers are anxious. The background to this story is set out in Australian Gambling Industry Scandals Exposed: Reforms Needed. A related thread runs through Sydney Toll Hikes Continue as Transurban Blocks Reforms.
In Victoria, the ban may set a precedent for other states, but its effectiveness will be watched closely. If successful, it could pressure NSW to reconsider. Earlier coverage in Jacinta Allan Resigns: A Legacy of Women's Health Reforms shows how the argument developed. A closer look at the same subject appears in AI Copyright Reforms: Australians' Online Content Scraping.
For now, buyers in NSW must rely on their own research and caution. Working with a buyer's agent or conducting independent valuations can help mitigate the risk of underquoting. Anyone following the wider picture can start with Australia: latest articles. The same theme surfaces in Victoria Election 2026: Key Promises from Labor, Coalition, Greens, which takes a different angle.
FAQ
What is underquoting in real estate?
Underquoting is when a property is advertised at a price below the seller's actual reserve or expected selling price, often to attract more buyers and create competitive tension.
Why did NSW pause underquoting reforms?
Premier Chris Minns said real estate agents in his electorate argued the rules would make it harder for sellers, prompting the decision to halt the reforms.
Has Victoria's underquoting ban been effective?
It's too early to tell, but the ban requires agents to provide reasonable price estimates and keep records. Enforcement will determine its success.
How can buyers protect themselves from underquoting?
Buyers should research recent sales, get independent valuations, and be prepared to walk away if the price guide seems unrealistic.
The pause in NSW underquoting reforms highlights the political power of real estate agents. For buyers, it's a reminder to stay informed and cautious. As Victoria's ban unfolds, its impact could influence future policy across Australia.
For a deeper look at how the pause affects buyers, see our analysis of NSW underquoting laws paused. Meanwhile, Victoria's approach may serve as a test case for other states.
In related news, Australia's gun buyback program shows how government intervention can shape markets. Our report on the Australia gun buyback 2026 examines NSW's leading role.
As the housing affordability crisis deepens, underquoting remains a contentious issue. Stay tuned for updates on Victoria's ban and any potential NSW reversal.