Julian Leeser has called for an audit of university courses covering the Israel-Palestine conflict to address rising antisemitism on Australian campuses. The shadow education minister made the comments before the royal commission into antisemitism and social cohesion on Friday, expressing deep concern over the lack of action from vice-chancellors since the 7 October 2023 Hamas terrorist attack.
Leeser stated he was “not satisfied” with how university leaders had responded, noting a failure to ensure course materials present both sides of the conflict. He urged the government to mandate the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism across all universities, a move that has sparked debate over academic freedom.
Key Recommendations from Julian Leeser
Leeser laid out several proposals for the royal commissioner, including a legislative requirement for universities to adopt the IHRA definition. He also called for a comprehensive audit of all courses teaching about Jews, Israel, or Palestine to remove any antisemitic materials.
What the IHRA Definition Means
The IHRA definition of antisemitism is widely used internationally but remains controversial in Australia. Critics, including the Group of Eight’s chief executive Vicki Thomson, argue it could stifle legitimate criticism of Israel. Thomson has previously stated the definition is “not workable” in an Australian context, as it may limit academic freedom.
Balanced Course Materials
Leeser emphasized that universities teaching about the Israel-Palestine conflict must use “credible sources” that present a balanced perspective. He questioned how institutions currently define balance, noting that many believe they show both sides if they simply include contrasting views without ensuring rigor.
| Recommendation | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Adopt IHRA definition | Standardize antisemitism policy across universities |
| Audit course content | Identify and remove antisemitic materials |
| Ensure balanced sources | Provide students with credible, multi-perspective education |
Context of the Royal Commission
The royal commission into antisemitism and social cohesion has focused this week on security for the Jewish community, with witnesses agreeing that the risk has increased sharply since October 7. Leeser’s appearance comes amid growing pressure on universities to address campus antisemitism.
Opponents of the IHRA definition argue it could be weaponized to suppress pro-Palestinian speech. However, Leeser maintained that adopting a consistent definition is essential for protecting Jewish students and faculty.
Key Takeaways
- Julian Leeser wants a mandatory audit of all courses related to Israel, Palestine, and Jews.
- He advocates for the IHRA definition of antisemitism to be legislated for all Australian universities.
- Universities must use credible, balanced sources in teaching the Israel-Palestine conflict.
- The royal commission continues to examine antisemitism and social cohesion in Australia.
FAQ
What is the IHRA definition of antisemitism?
The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition describes antisemitism as a certain perception of Jews which may be expressed as hatred toward them. It includes examples such as calling for the killing of Jews, denying the Holocaust, and applying double standards to Israel.
Why is the IHRA definition controversial in Australia?
Critics argue that the IHRA definition can be used to silence legitimate criticism of Israeli government policies, potentially infringing on academic freedom and free speech. The Group of Eight universities have said it is “not workable” in the Australian context.
What does the royal commission into antisemitism aim to achieve?
The royal commission is investigating the prevalence of antisemitism in Australia and its impact on social cohesion. It is examining responses from institutions including universities, and making recommendations to combat hatred and discrimination.
As the royal commission continues, Leeser’s call for an audit of university courses on the Israel-Palestine conflict will likely fuel ongoing debates about academic freedom, balanced education, and the fight against antisemitism in Australia.