NextDC, one of Australia's largest datacentre companies, has been accused of using artificial intelligence while lobbying Victorian minister Melissa Horne for support of its hyperscale AI factory expansion in Footscray. The controversy highlights growing tensions over datacentre developments as the state election approaches.
The Lobbying Controversy Unfolds
Correspondence between Victorian cabinet minister Melissa Horne and NextDC CEO Craig Scroggie has revealed an unusual lobbying effort. Scroggie personally emailed the minister, urging her to intercede on behalf of NextDC's application for fast-tracked approval of its M3 datacentre expansion. Multiple lobbying sources described this direct approach as unusual, especially given the project's sensitivity.
The expansion would see the datacentre cover 10 hectares, draw 225MW of power, and operate 24/7. While NextDC argues the project is vital for Victoria's digital infrastructure, local residents have raised serious concerns about its impact.
Community Concerns and Government Scrutiny
Residents in Footscray have complained that the government has been too quick to approve developments without considering long-term impacts. Some homes are within 15 metres of the datacentre's boundary, which is zoned industrial. The proximity has led to noise, environmental, and health concerns.
The timing is particularly sensitive, with the state election looming. The government faces pressure to balance economic development with community welfare, and the accusation of AI-assisted lobbying adds another layer of controversy.
Key Takeaways
- NextDC is accused of using AI while lobbying for minister's support.
- The M3 datacentre expansion would cover 10 hectares and draw 225MW of power.
- Local residents oppose the project due to proximity and lack of consultation.
- The controversy could impact the upcoming Victorian state election.
Comparing Datacentre Expansion Impacts
To understand the scale of the proposed M3 expansion, consider the following comparison with typical datacentres:
| Metric | M3 Expansion (Proposed) | Typical Datacentre |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 10 hectares | 1-2 hectares |
| Power Draw | 225 MW | 10-50 MW |
| Operation | 24/7 | 24/7 |
| Proximity to Homes | 15 metres | Usually >100 metres |
The Role of AI in Lobbying
The accusation that NextDC used AI in its lobbying efforts raises ethical questions. While AI can draft persuasive communications, its use in government lobbying must be transparent. Minister Horne's office has not commented on the specific AI allegations, but the correspondence suggests a sophisticated campaign.
NextDC has defended its actions, stating that the expansion is critical for meeting growing demand for cloud services and AI infrastructure. However, the company's approach may backfire if it is seen as circumventing proper planning processes.
What's Next for the M3 Datacentre?
The planning minister is currently assessing the application. With community opposition mounting and the election approaching, the decision will be closely watched. It could set a precedent for how datacentre developments are handled in Victoria and beyond.
Residents are calling for greater transparency and community consultation. Whether the government listens may depend on political calculations in the lead-up to the election.
FAQ
What is NextDC accused of?
NextDC is accused of using artificial intelligence while lobbying Victorian minister Melissa Horne to support its hyperscale datacentre expansion in Footscray.
Why are residents concerned about the M3 datacentre?
Residents are concerned because the datacentre is within 15 metres of some homes, drawing 225MW of power and running 24/7, which could lead to noise, environmental, and health issues.
What happens next with the M3 datacentre application?
The planning minister is assessing the application. The decision could be influenced by the upcoming state election and ongoing community opposition.
Best Products We’ve Tested and Rated

Our testing team has hands-on reviews of treeless saddle, spine protector skiing, padded shorts snowboarding, low volume ski boots, and gifts outdoorsy girlfriend. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.
Our testing team has hands-on reviews of cooler rafting, composting toilet van life, chest pack hunting, backcountry ski gloves, and touring stand up paddle board. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.