The claim that rejoining the EU would cost Britain £750m a week has resurfaced in a new analysis by campaign group Stay Out. But is this figure reliable, or is it simply a rehash of the infamous Brexit bus myth? We break down the numbers and the motives behind them.
The debate over Britain's relationship with the EU has reignited with a new analysis from campaign group Stay Out, which claims that rejoining the EU would cost the UK £750m a week. The figure, rounded down from £756m, echoes the controversial £350m a week figure used by Vote Leave during the 2016 referendum. But how did Stay Out arrive at this number, and does it hold up to scrutiny?
How Stay Out Calculated the £750m a Week Figure
Stay Out's analysis is based on the European Commission's proposed long-term EU budget, worth €2tn (£1.66tn) over the 2028-34 period. The group assumes that if Britain were to rejoin, the EU budget would increase, and the UK would contribute a sum commensurate with its size and wealth. The £750m is a gross figure, excluding funds that would return to Britain, such as farm subsidies and scientific grants.
This methodology mirrors that of Vote Leave, which was criticised by the UK Statistics Authority in 2016 for its misleading claim that Britain's EU membership cost £350m a week. That statistic, famously emblazoned on the side of a campaign bus, did not account for the British rebate or EU funds that flowed back to the UK. Stay Out's headline figure could be seen as repeating the same trick: while its workings document states the £750m is a gross figure, that caveat is not made clear in a campaign video likely to reach a far wider audience.
Why the £750m Figure Is Misleading
The use of a gross figure without context is problematic. By excluding returning funds, Stay Out presents an inflated cost that does not reflect the net financial impact of EU membership. This is precisely the criticism levelled at the Brexit bus claim. The UK Statistics Authority's rebuke in 2016 highlighted how such figures can mislead the public when presented without proper explanation.
Moreover, the £750m figure is based on assumptions about future budget increases and the UK's contribution rate. It does not account for the economic benefits of EU membership, such as access to the single market, which many economists argue outweigh the costs. Nor does it consider the potential rebate that the UK might negotiate upon rejoining.
The Political Context: Stay Out and the Rejoin Debate
Stay Out is a campaign group founded by architects of the Vote Leave campaign, and its latest intervention is clearly designed to influence the growing debate about whether Britain should rejoin the EU. The group's message is simple: rejoining would be costly. But the timing and the method raise questions about whether this is a genuine attempt to inform the public or a strategic move to scare voters away from the idea.
The rejoin debate has gained momentum in recent months, with high-profile figures like Andy Burnham shifting their positions. As we reported in UK Rejoining EU: Andy Burnham's Bold Brexit Shift Explained, the Mayor of Greater Manchester has moved towards supporting a closer relationship with the EU, arguing that it is essential for addressing regional inequalities. This shift has prompted reactions from across the political spectrum, including French President Emmanuel Macron, who welcomed Burnham's stance, as detailed in UK Rejoining EU: Macron Welcomes Burnham's Bold Brexit Reversal.
What the Public Thinks About Rejoining the EU
Public opinion on rejoining the EU remains divided, but recent polling suggests a gradual shift towards supporting a closer relationship. However, the question of whether voters are ready to rejoin is complex, as explored in Brexit Reversal: Are British Voters Ready to Rejoin the EU. The £750m claim could influence those who are undecided, particularly if it is perceived as a credible economic argument.
Yet, the use of misleading figures may backfire. The public has become more sceptical of statistics presented by campaign groups, especially after the 2016 referendum. As Lisa Nandy warned, circular arguments about the cost of the EU can distract from the real issues, a point we covered in Lisa Nandy Warns Against Circular EU Rejoin Arguments. Nandy's intervention highlights the need for a more nuanced debate that focuses on the tangible benefits and drawbacks of EU membership.
The Broader Economic Picture
While the £750m figure grabs headlines, it is important to consider the wider economic context. The UK's departure from the EU has had significant economic consequences, from reduced trade to labour shortages. Rejoining would not be a simple reversal; it would involve negotiations and compromises. Think tanks such as UK Think Tank have argued that rejoining the EU is key to handling geopolitical crises, as we reported in UK Think Tank: Rejoining EU Is Key to Handling Geopolitical Crises. This perspective suggests that the costs of membership should be weighed against the benefits of cooperation on issues like climate change, security, and trade.
Moreover, the government appears to be quietly gathering evidence on public support for rejoining the EU, as revealed in No 10 Gathers Evidence on Public Support for Rejoining the EU. This suggests that the debate is far from over and that the £750m claim may be just one piece of a larger puzzle.
Key Takeaways
- Stay Out's £750m a week figure is a gross cost, excluding returning funds, and mirrors the methodology of the controversial Brexit bus claim.
- The figure is based on assumptions about the EU's future budget and the UK's contribution, not on current membership terms.
- Campaign groups on both sides have a history of using misleading statistics to sway public opinion.
- The rejoin debate is intensifying, with high-profile figures like Andy Burnham shifting their positions.
- Voters should scrutinise headline figures and consider the broader economic and geopolitical context.
Comparison of Brexit Bus and Rejoin Cost Claims
| Claim | Figure | Gross or Net? | Includes Rebate? | Includes Returning Funds? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vote Leave (2016) | £350m/week | Gross | No | No |
| Stay Out (2024) | £750m/week | Gross | Not specified | No |
FAQ
Is the £750m a week figure accurate?
The £750m figure is a gross estimate based on assumptions about the EU's future budget and the UK's contribution. It does not account for returning funds or a potential rebate, making it an incomplete picture of the net cost.
Why did Vote Leave's £350m claim cause controversy?
The UK Statistics Authority criticised the £350m figure because it was a gross cost that ignored the UK's rebate and the EU funds that flowed back to Britain. It was deemed misleading.
What would be the real cost of rejoining the EU?
The real cost would depend on the terms of membership, including any rebate and the UK's economic circumstances. It would also need to be weighed against the economic benefits of single market access and other advantages.
How does public opinion factor into the rejoin debate?
Public opinion is gradually shifting, but it remains divided. Campaigns like Stay Out's may influence undecided voters, but misleading figures could also undermine trust.