Everton vs Newcastle Carabao Cup Preview: Can Everton End 31-Year 2026

Everton vs Newcastle in the Carabao Cup fourth round promises a fascinating clash between two clubs with rich histories but contrasting recent fortunes. Everton, a trophy-hoovering behemoth whose spree started in Victorian times, have not lifted silverware since 1995. Newcastle, meanwhile, ended their own 56-year wait by winning the 2025 League Cup and now seek a second pot in three years.

Team News: Changes for Both Sides

Everton make two changes to their starting XI following last weekend's 2-0 defeat at Arsenal. Hayden Hackney and Tyler Dibling come in for Brennan Johnson and Harrison Armstrong, who both drop to the bench.

Newcastle United make one change to their starting line-up following last weekend's 2-0 win at Crystal Palace. Jacob Ramsey takes the place of Joelinton, who starts as a sub.

Starting Line-ups

Context: A Trophy Drought Waiting to End

It wasn't so long ago that Newcastle United were the watchword for underperforming silverware-repelling giants. But lifting the 2025 League Cup did for that. Now it's over to Everton, a club whose trophy cabinet has gathered dust since their 1995 FA Cup triumph.

This campaign represents the first stirring of a cup run in a while, and people are beginning to talk. With Fleetwood Town awaiting the winners in the quarter-finals, a pathway is opening up for either side.

What's at Stake?

For Everton, ending a 31-year wait for a major trophy would be a monumental achievement and a sign of progress under their current management. For Newcastle, a second cup in three years would further cement their return to the elite and validate their recent investments.

The match also offers a chance for squad players to shine. With both teams making changes, the depth of each squad will be tested.

Key Players to Watch

• Jordan Pickford – Everton's goalkeeper and captain, crucial for organizing the defense.
• Jacob Ramsey – Newcastle's midfielder, starting in place of Joelinton, looking to make an impact.
• Tyler Dibling – Everton's young attacker, handed a start and eager to impress.
• Harvey Barnes – Newcastle's winger, always a threat in the final third.
• Jarrad Branthwaite – Not in the squad? Actually, not mentioned; but Tarkowski leads the line.

Analysis: Can Everton Break the Hoodoo?

Everton's recent form has been inconsistent, but cup competitions offer a respite from league pressures. The Toffees have shown flashes of quality, and the inclusion of Hackney and Dibling suggests a willingness to rotate and give opportunities to fringe players.

Newcastle, on the other hand, are riding high after their League Cup success and a solid win at Crystal Palace. However, the absence of Joelinton from the start might reduce their physical presence in midfield. Ramsey is a capable deputy, but the Brazilian's energy is often key to Newcastle's press.

The tactical battle will be intriguing. Everton may look to exploit set-pieces with Tarkowski and O'Brien, while Newcastle's pace on the wings could trouble Everton's full-backs.

What to Watch Next

The winner will face Fleetwood Town in the quarter-finals, a tie that both clubs would fancy. But first, they must navigate this tricky encounter. With kick-off at 7.45pm GMT, expect a tense, closely-fought affair.

For Everton, a victory could kickstart a memorable cup run and ease the pressure on the manager. For Newcastle, it's a chance to keep their trophy defense alive.

As the match unfolds, keep an eye on Fleetwood Town vs Arsenal: Carabao Cup Fourth Round Preview to see potential quarter-final opponents. Meanwhile, Carabao Cup Live: Newcastle vs West Brom, Tottenham vs Charlton provides live updates from other ties. For a deeper look at Newcastle's recent cup heroics, Newcastle United Edge Millwall in Carabao Cup Thriller recounts their dramatic win.

Off the pitch, Everton's ownership situation continues to evolve. Moyes Faces Everton Trophy Drought With Limited Time and Funds examines the challenges faced by the manager. Additionally, Chelsea Sign Martínez, Everton Pull Plug on Armstrong Sale highlights the club's transfer stance.

Finally, Everton Owner Friedkin Group Explores Sale of Club reports on potential changes at the top. As the cup run progresses, Live Football Updates: Bolton, Middlesbrough offers real-time scores from around the grounds.