Malcolm Roberts, an Australian senator from One Nation, has sparked controversy after saying he is "in two minds" about whether gay people should have equal rights. The comments, made at a conservative Christian conference in June, have ignited a debate about equality and political leadership in Australia.
Context of the Remarks
Footage from the Church and State conference, released on Sunday, shows Roberts responding to a question about James Ashby, the party's director, who is gay. Roberts described Ashby as "bright, honest and straight," then joked, "Well, straight in one way." An audience member then asked what Christians should think about Ashby.
Roberts' Reference to John Shelby Spong
Roberts cited the late American bishop and gay rights advocate John Shelby Spong, who argued that after women and black people were no longer seen as "inferior," gay people would be next. Roberts said, "Now I'm in two minds about that. So I haven't got a firm position on it myself other than I don't, I'm not homosexual and I can't, I can't understand it." He added that while many homosexuals have been prominent in history, he believes "in this environment, James is not morally sound," but acknowledged Ashby's honesty and integrity.
Reactions and Implications
The remarks have drawn criticism from LGBTQ advocates and political opponents, who argue that a senator's uncertainty on fundamental equality is concerning. The controversy also puts One Nation under scrutiny, as the party has faced questions about its stance on LGBTQ issues.
Comparison of Views on Gay Equality
| Stance | Description |
|---|---|
| Supportive | Full legal equality, protection against discrimination |
| Uncertain | Open to debate, no firm position |
| Opposed | Against equal rights, often based on religious beliefs |
Key Takeaways
- Roberts' comments reflect ongoing societal debates about LGBTQ rights in Australia.
- Political leaders' views can influence public opinion and policy.
- Equality issues remain a sensitive topic in conservative circles.
FAQ
What did Malcolm Roberts say about gay people?
When did Roberts make these comments?
How has the public reacted?
Best Products We’ve Tested and Rated

Our testing team has hands-on reviews of iem mic, inch monitor, chair short person, motherboard ryzen 7800x3d, and motherboard am5. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.
Our testing team has hands-on reviews of headset logitech, audio card, pc, wireless adapter, and mice under. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.