A New South Wales inquest has heard that a self-described birth keeper advised a pregnant woman to “go home and rest” after she received urgent medical advice to present to an emergency department. The baby later died, and the case has raised serious questions about the regulation of unregistered birth support workers.
The inquest, which began in the Lismore local court on Monday, is examining the deaths of four babies born in free births or home births in the northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024. Sita Tara Kali was involved in the care of two of those babies, including Baby R, whose mother had a deep distrust of hospitals.
What Happened to Baby R?
Baby R’s mother was 43 weeks pregnant when an ultrasound confirmed that the baby was “extremely compromised.” The obstetric advice was urgent: she was urged to attend the emergency department and strongly advised against a home birth. Instead, she called Kali, who in a police statement said she told the mother to “go home and rest. Calm yourself down and consider what you want to do.”
Baby R was subsequently born outside, and died. The inquest will examine whether the care provided was reasonable in the circumstances, and whether the care by an unregistered support worker was reasonable and appropriate before, during and after the birth.
Why This Inquest Matters
This case highlights the potential risks when families choose home births outside the regulated health system, especially when complications arise. The mother’s distrust of hospitals, the court heard, led her to trust Kali and feel that a home birth would give her a stronger connection to her baby. But that trust may have come at a cost.
The inquest will also consider the role of birth keepers—individuals who are not registered health professionals but who provide support during pregnancy and birth. Their lack of regulation means there is no oversight of their advice or practice, which can have fatal consequences.
- Unregistered birth keepers operate without professional oversight, raising concerns about the safety of their advice.
- Home births can be safe for low-risk pregnancies, but urgent medical advice should never be ignored.
- Inquests like this one aim to identify systemic failures and recommend changes to prevent future deaths.
- Trust in caregivers is crucial, but it must be balanced with evidence-based medical guidance.
- Four babies died in the northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024, prompting this broader inquiry.
What the Inquest Will Examine
The coroner’s court will hear evidence about the circumstances of each death, including the care provided by Kali and others. The families of the four babies were not present at the opening, but their statements and police interviews will form part of the evidence.
The inquest will also explore whether the care given by unregistered support workers was appropriate, and whether any regulatory gaps allowed unsafe practices to continue. Recommendations may follow, aimed at improving safety in home birth settings.
Comparison of Regulated vs. Unregistered Care
The table below outlines key differences between care provided by registered health professionals and unregistered birth keepers, based on the issues raised in this inquest.
| Aspect | Registered Health Professional | Unregistered Birth Keeper |
|---|---|---|
| Oversight | Regulated by AHPRA and professional boards | No formal oversight or registration |
| Accountability | Subject to complaints and disciplinary processes | Limited accountability mechanisms |
| Advice on emergencies | Required to follow clinical guidelines and escalate care | May offer advice outside clinical guidelines |
| Training | Mandatory accredited qualifications and ongoing education | Variable, often unaccredited |
What to Watch Next
The inquest is expected to run for several days, with testimony from medical experts, police, and possibly Kali herself. The coroner will ultimately determine whether the deaths were preventable and whether any systemic issues need addressing.
For families considering home birth, this case underscores the importance of qualified care and clear emergency plans. It also raises questions about how unregistered practitioners are allowed to operate.
Similar inquests have examined missed opportunities in other cases, such as the baby meningitis death inquest that found missed chances to test, highlighting recurring themes in healthcare failures.
The broader context of unregulated care and its impact on vulnerable families is also relevant. As with the inquest into a baby delivered after a mother's fall, these proceedings aim to provide answers and prevent future tragedies.
In the northern rivers region, the close-knit community may struggle with the outcomes. The Elizabeth Struhs inquest revealed missed curiosity about religious beliefs, a reminder that professionals must sometimes challenge personal convictions to protect life.
Regulatory bodies and lawmakers will be watching closely. The ICAC has heard testimony about private investigators surveilling a liberal minister, showing that oversight extends to many sectors, but unregistered birth workers often fall through the cracks.
Public awareness of these risks is growing. Just as the gambling inquiry heard how companies supplied cocaine and alcohol, this inquest may expose practices that prioritise personal beliefs over safety.
Ultimately, the coroner’s findings could lead to recommendations for better regulation of birth keepers and improved support for families. For now, the community awaits answers.
FAQ
What is a birth keeper?
A birth keeper is an unregistered support person who provides emotional and practical support during pregnancy and birth. They are not regulated health professionals and may not have formal medical training.
Why did the mother trust the birth keeper over hospital advice?
The court heard that Baby R’s mother had a distrust of hospitals and felt threatened by her experiences there. She was aligned with and trusted Kali, believing a home birth would give her a stronger connection to her baby.
What will the inquest examine?
The inquest will examine whether the care provided was reasonable in the circumstances and whether care by an unregistered support worker was reasonable and appropriate before, during, and after the birth.
How many babies are involved in this inquest?
The inquest is examining the deaths of four babies born in free births or home births in the northern rivers region between 2022 and 2024. Sita Tara Kali was involved in the care of two of them.