Queensland's hate speech laws have thrust two retirees into the spotlight after their arrest for displaying a Palestine banner at a permitted rally in Brisbane. Sandra Keller, 75, and Marlene Grace, 72, were surrounded by police and arrested for "distribution, publication or display of a prohibited symbol" under the Fighting Antisemitism and Keeping Guns out of the Hands of Terrorists and Criminals Amendment Act 2026.
The women, along with Grace's 76-year-old husband Paul, were carrying a banner reading "from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free" through the streets of Brisbane last Sunday. Police allege the slogan caused a person to feel "menaced, harassed or offended." It was the first arrest for both women, who have no criminal records.
Who Are Sandra Keller and Marlene Grace?
Sandra Keller is a retired mental health counsellor, and Marlene Grace is a retired cardiac nurse. Both are grandmothers who lead quiet, law-abiding lives. Grace told reporters, "I'm the most law-abiding person. I've never had a speeding ticket. I've never had a parking fine." She added, "I'm not a dangerous woman. I look after my grandchildren."
Their arrests have sparked debate about the scope of Queensland's hate speech laws and whether they disproportionately target peaceful protesters. The women say they were exercising their right to protest against the destruction in Gaza and the mutilation of children.
What Are Queensland's Hate Speech Laws?
The Fighting Antisemitism and Keeping Guns out of the Hands of Terrorists and Criminals Amendment Act 2026 was introduced by the Crisafulli government to combat antisemitism and keep weapons out of the wrong hands. However, critics argue that the law's broad language has been used to suppress legitimate political expression.

Under the Act, it is an offence to distribute, publish, or display a prohibited symbol if it causes a person to feel menaced, harassed, or offended. The law does not require proof of intent to intimidate; the perception of the alleged victim is sufficient. This has led to concerns that the law could be weaponised against unpopular viewpoints.
The Arrest and Its Implications
Keller and Grace were among more than 40 people arrested under the new law. Their case has drawn national attention because of their age and background. Both women vow to continue protesting, saying they are compelled by the humanitarian crisis in Gaza.
The arrests raise important questions about the balance between protecting communities from hate speech and upholding freedom of expression. Legal experts suggest that the law may face challenges in court if it is seen to infringe on the implied freedom of political communication in the Australian Constitution. The background to this story is set out in Led By Donkeys Wins £27K Compensation Over Banner Seizure. A related thread runs through Led By Donkeys Wins £27K Compensation for Seized Gaza Banner.
What Happens Next?
The women are due to appear in court, where they plan to contest the charges. Their legal team is expected to argue that the slogan is a political statement, not a symbol of hate. The outcome could set a precedent for how hate speech laws are applied across Australia. Earlier coverage in Australia Concedes Teen Social Media Ban Burden on Free Speech shows how the argument developed. A closer look at the same subject appears in Trump's UN Speech: A Dangerous Display of Delusion.
Meanwhile, civil liberties groups are calling for a review of the legislation. They argue that laws designed to protect vulnerable communities should not be used to silence peaceful activists. The Queensland government has defended the law, stating it is necessary to address rising antisemitism. Anyone following the wider picture can start with Australia: latest articles. The same theme surfaces in Independent MPs Slam Labor's Election Funding Law Changes, which takes a different angle.
Key Takeaways
- Two retirees were arrested under Queensland's hate speech laws for carrying a Palestine banner at a permitted rally.
- The law prohibits displaying symbols that cause a person to feel menaced, harassed, or offended.
- Over 40 people have been arrested under the Act, raising concerns about free speech.
- The women plan to fight the charges, arguing their action was peaceful political expression.
- The case could test the balance between hate speech laws and freedom of political communication in Australia.
Comparing Hate Speech Laws Across Australian States
| State | Law | Key Provisions | Penalties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Queensland | Fighting Antisemitism and Keeping Guns out of the Hands of Terrorists and Criminals Amendment Act 2026 | Prohibits display of symbols causing menaced, harassed, or offended feelings | Up to 3 years imprisonment |
| New South Wales | Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 | Prohibits racial vilification | Civil remedies |
| Victoria | Racial and Religious Tolerance Act 2001 | Prohibits religious vilification | Civil remedies |
| Western Australia | Criminal Code Amendment (Racial Vilification) Act 2004 | Prohibits racial vilification | Up to 3 years imprisonment |
FAQ
What exactly is the "prohibited symbol" in this case?
The banner carried by the retirees read "from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free." Queensland police allege this slogan is a prohibited symbol under the new law because it caused a person to feel menaced, harassed, or offended.
Why were the women arrested at a permitted rally?
Although the rally itself was permitted, police acted on a complaint that the slogan constituted a prohibited symbol under the Act. The law allows for arrest if the display is deemed to cause offence, regardless of the rally's permitted status.
What penalties do the women face?
Under the Act, the offence of displaying a prohibited symbol carries a maximum penalty of three years imprisonment. However, given their age and lack of prior record, it is unlikely they will receive a custodial sentence if convicted.
How does this affect freedom of speech in Australia?
The case highlights the tension between laws designed to protect communities from hate speech and the right to political expression. Legal experts suggest the law may be challenged as an infringement of the implied freedom of political communication in the Constitution.
The arrests of Sandra Keller and Marlene Grace have become a flashpoint in the national conversation about hate speech laws. As the case moves through the courts, it will be watched closely by civil libertarians and legislators alike. For those following similar legal battles, the case of Sandra Day O'Connor, the first woman on the US Supreme Court, offers a reminder of how judicial decisions shape rights.
In the meantime, the women remain defiant. They plan to continue protesting, saying they are driven by a moral obligation to speak out against violence. Their story has resonated with many Australians who see them as unlikely activists standing up for free speech. As with other grassroots movements, such as retirees restoring nature with chainsaws and 45,000 trees in Australia, ordinary people are increasingly taking bold stands on issues they care about.
The Queensland government has not commented on the specific case but maintains that the law is a necessary tool to combat antisemitism. Opponents argue that the law's broad wording could lead to further arrests of peaceful protesters. The outcome of this case will likely influence how similar laws are drafted and enforced across the country. For now, Sandra and Marlene remain determined to have their day in court.