Andy Burnham will declare that Brexit “has not worked” and pledge to sign a new deal with the EU, in a major speech that sharpens the government’s critique of the UK’s departure from the bloc. Speaking at the lord mayor’s banquet in the City of London on Monday, the prime minister will argue that the country was left with a needlessly hard Brexit that created barriers for businesses and damaged economic potential.
The intervention follows his comments at the Welsh Labour conference on Saturday, where he said the UK had “lost more than we gained” through leaving the EU. Burnham is due to meet European leaders at a summit this week to secure agreements he says could raise GDP by 0.4% – about £17bn – covering food and farming, emissions trading, and a youth mobility scheme.
What Burnham Said About Brexit
In a blunt assessment, Burnham is expected to argue that Boris Johnson’s promise to “take back control” was not delivered. He will use the metaphor of the Emperor’s New Clothes to describe the reluctance of others to state the obvious truth about Brexit’s economic impact.
“It’s like the Emperor’s New Clothes – where no one is prepared to say the obvious truth. Well, I say it as I see it. And to be frank, the emperor has nothing on,” Burnham will say. “The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained.”
These remarks represent the latest in a string of comments by the prime minister criticising Brexit, signalling a willingness to confront a politically sensitive issue head-on. The speech is aimed at business leaders in the City of London, a constituency that has been particularly vocal about the negative effects of leaving the EU.
Why This Matters for UK Business
Burnham’s comments matter because they move the debate from whether Brexit was a good idea to how to fix its economic damage. For businesses, the promise of a new deal with the EU could mean reduced friction in trade, lower costs, and improved access to European markets.
The prime minister’s plan focuses on three areas: food and farming, emissions trading, and youth mobility. These are seen as relatively low-hanging fruit that could deliver tangible benefits without reopening the entire withdrawal agreement. The potential 0.4% GDP boost – about £17bn – is a significant sum that could help offset some of the estimated economic losses from Brexit.
However, the path to a new deal is not straightforward. Burnham has set three conditions for any agreement: it must be consistent with the Labour manifesto and the government’s red lines; it must improve the Brexit deal and bring it closer to what people thought they were voting for in 2016; and it must pass the so-called “Makerfield test” by delivering real, tangible improvements to people’s lives.
The Three Conditions for a New EU Deal
The prime minister’s conditions are designed to reassure both the EU and domestic audiences. Consistency with the Labour manifesto and government red lines means no return to freedom of movement or the single market. Improving the deal to match 2016 expectations suggests a softer Brexit than the current hard version. And the Makerfield test – named after a constituency in the north of England – emphasises tangible outcomes over ideological purity.
These conditions reflect a pragmatic approach that seeks to rebuild trust with voters who feel let down by the promises of Brexit. By focusing on concrete deliverables, Burnham hopes to avoid the abstract debates that have characterised Brexit discussions for years.
Key Takeaways from Burnham’s Speech
- Andy Burnham will say Brexit “has not worked” and that the UK has “lost more than we gained.”
- He plans to sign a new deal with the EU covering food and farming, emissions trading, and youth mobility.
- The deal could raise GDP by 0.4% – about £17bn – according to Burnham.
- Any agreement must meet three conditions: consistency with Labour’s manifesto, improvement on the current deal, and the “Makerfield test” of tangible benefits.
- The speech is aimed at business leaders in the City of London and signals a shift in the government’s approach to Brexit.
Comparing the Current Brexit Deal with Burnham’s Proposed Changes
The table below summarises the key differences between the current Brexit arrangements and the changes Burnham is seeking to negotiate.
| Area | Current Brexit Deal | Burnham’s Proposed Changes |
|---|---|---|
| Food and Farming | High tariffs and non-tariff barriers | Reduced barriers, improved market access |
| Emissions Trading | Separate UK scheme, limited linkage | Closer alignment with EU ETS |
| Youth Mobility | Restrictive visa rules | New youth mobility scheme |
| GDP Impact | Estimated negative effect | Potential +0.4% (£17bn) boost |
What to Watch Next
The coming weeks will be crucial as Burnham meets European leaders at the summit. The reaction from the EU will indicate whether a new deal is feasible, while domestic political reaction will show how much room Burnham has to manoeuvre. Business groups are likely to welcome the pragmatism, but hardline Brexiteers may accuse him of betraying the 2016 vote.
For businesses, the key will be whether any new agreement delivers tangible reductions in red tape and costs. The prime minister’s focus on the “Makerfield test” suggests that he understands the need for visible improvements. As the debate over Brexit’s economic damage continues, Burnham’s speech marks a significant moment in the UK’s attempt to repair its relationship with the EU.
The prime minister’s remarks have already sparked debate about the future of Brexit. As Burnham’s Kremlin interference remarks shake the Brexit debate, questions arise about the broader narrative surrounding the referendum. This latest intervention adds another layer to the complex legacy of Brexit.
Critics argue that Burnham’s approach is too timid, and some suggest that Andy Burnham should lead on Brexit like Pericles, drawing on historical leadership lessons. Others point to the need for a clear stance on Russia’s interference in the Brexit referendum vote as part of a broader reckoning.
As the government seeks to repair Brexit economic damage as Burnham’s top business priority, the prime minister’s speech will be scrutinised for its substance. The meeting with EU leaders this week will be an early test of whether his words translate into action. In the meantime, the debate over Brexit’s costs continues to evolve, with new data and analyses emerging regularly. The background to this story is set out in Burnham Pledges Radical Change Amid Economic Headwinds. A related thread runs through Burnham: EU Deal Could Be 'Win-Win' for Britain and Europe.
Looking ahead, the outcome of Burnham’s efforts could shape the UK’s economic trajectory for years. Whether he can secure a deal that passes the Makerfield test remains to be seen, but his willingness to confront the failures of Brexit is a notable shift in political discourse. Earlier coverage in Burnham Pledges Big Welfare Changes to Tackle NEET Crisis shows how the argument developed. A closer look at the same subject appears in Ukraine's 40-Day Campaign Against Russia: Has It Worked?.
FAQ
What did Andy Burnham say about Brexit?
What did Andy Burnham say about Brexit?
Andy Burnham said that Brexit “has not worked” and that the UK has “lost more than we gained” through leaving the EU. He argued that the country was left with a needlessly hard Brexit that created barriers for businesses and damaged economic potential.
What new deal does Burnham propose with the EU?
What new deal does Burnham propose with the EU?
Burnham proposes a new deal covering food and farming, emissions trading, and a youth mobility scheme. He claims these agreements could raise GDP by 0.4% – about £17bn.
What are Burnham’s conditions for signing a new EU deal?
What are Burnham’s conditions for signing a new EU deal?
Burnham has set three conditions: the deal must be consistent with the Labour manifesto and government red lines; it must improve the Brexit deal and bring it closer to what people thought they were voting for in 2016; and it must pass the “Makerfield test” by delivering real, tangible improvements.
How could a new EU deal affect UK businesses?
How could a new EU deal affect UK businesses?
A new EU deal could reduce trade barriers, lower costs, and improve market access for UK businesses, particularly in food and farming. It could also lead to closer alignment on emissions trading and new opportunities for youth mobility.