Tech firms should pay the creators whose work they use, argues a recent letter responding to Anthropic's proposal to commit 5% of shares to a public good fund. The debate raises a fundamental question: who benefits from technological progress? Before pledging money for the public good, AI companies should first compensate the creators whose work fuels their systems.
Device manufacturers have a separate but related responsibility. Smartphones, computers, and other devices enable creative work to be copied and stored, yet UK creators receive no private-copying payments, unlike their counterparts in more than 40 other countries.
Why AI Firms Should Pay Creators First
Anthropic's plan to allocate 5% of shares to a public good fund has been met with calls to prioritize direct payments to creators. The argument is simple: AI models are trained on vast amounts of creative work, often without permission or compensation. Before distributing profits to broader societal causes, firms should address the immediate inequity faced by the creators whose work made these models possible.
This principle extends beyond AI. Device manufacturers profit from selling hardware that enables copying and storing creative content. In many countries, levies on blank media and devices compensate creators for private copying. The UK is a notable exception.
The Smart Fund: A Solution for UK Creators
The proposed Smart Fund would require manufacturers and importers to make modest contributions on devices used to copy or store creative work. According to advocates, it could raise up to £300 million annually. These funds would provide creators with additional income and support skills development, cultural programs, and affordable workspaces.
For creators on persistently low and falling incomes, such payments would make a tangible difference. Visual artists' median annual earnings are just £12,500—47% lower in real terms than in 2010. Authors earn a median of only £7,000 from writing, down from £11,300, according to surveys published in 2022 and 2018 respectively. Audiovisual performers report median annual earnings from performing of £17,500.
- UK creators receive no private-copying payments, unlike counterparts in 40+ countries.
- The Smart Fund could raise up to £300m annually from device manufacturers and importers.
- Visual artists' median earnings are £12,500, a 47% real-terms drop since 2010.
- Authors' median writing income fell from £11,300 to £7,000.
- Audiovisual performers earn a median of £17,500 from performing.
How the Smart Fund Would Work
The Smart Fund would impose a modest levy on devices capable of copying or storing creative work, such as smartphones, tablets, and computers. Manufacturers and importers would pay into the fund, which would then distribute revenues to creators and cultural programs. This model mirrors systems in over 40 countries where private-copying levies are already in place.
Critics might argue that such a levy would raise device prices, but proponents counter that the contribution would be modest and proportionate to the value creators add to these devices. After all, it is creators' work that attracts people to technology.
| Country | Private-Copying Levy | Annual Revenue (est.) |
|---|---|---|
| UK | No | £0 |
| Germany | Yes | €50m+ |
| France | Yes | €30m+ |
| Canada | Yes | CAD 40m+ |
| Australia | No | — |
The Broader Debate: AI and Creator Rights
The Smart Fund is part of a larger conversation about AI and creator rights. As AI companies like Anthropic propose public good funds, questions arise about whether such initiatives are sufficient or merely a PR move. The UK's creative industries contribute significantly to the economy, yet creators struggle financially.
Ensuring creators share in the value their work generates is not just fair—it's essential for sustaining a vibrant creative ecosystem. Without adequate compensation, many creators may be forced to abandon their craft, reducing the diversity and quality of content available to society.
What's Next for Creator Compensation?
The proposal for the Smart Fund is gaining traction, but legislative action is needed. Advocates are calling on the UK government to introduce the fund and ensure AI companies compensate creators directly. Meanwhile, the debate over AI training data and copyright continues. The background to this story is set out in CEO Pay Ratio Hits 614:1 at Top US Low-Wage Firms. A related thread runs through OnlyFans Reality Show: Inside Top 1% Creators' Earnings.
As AI firms face increasing scrutiny over their use of creative work, the pressure to pay creators will only grow. The Smart Fund offers a concrete way to ensure creators benefit from the technology that relies on their work. Earlier coverage in Plan to Make Firms Pay More to Train Older Workers Than Youth shows how the argument developed. A closer look at the same subject appears in Australia Tax Shake-Up: ATO Reveals 27% of Big Firms Pay Zero Tax.
FAQ
What is the Smart Fund?
The Smart Fund is a proposed UK levy on devices that can copy or store creative work, such as smartphones and computers. It would require manufacturers and importers to contribute, raising up to £300m annually for creators.
Why do UK creators need compensation?
UK creators earn low and declining incomes, with visual artists' median annual earnings at £12,500—47% lower in real terms than in 2010. Unlike creators in over 40 countries, they receive no private-copying payments.
How does AI relate to creator compensation?
AI models are trained on creative work, often without permission or payment. Companies like Anthropic propose public good funds, but advocates argue creators should be paid directly first.
What can creators do to support the Smart Fund?
Creators can advocate for the Smart Fund by contacting policymakers, raising awareness, and supporting organizations that campaign for creator rights.
The debate over AI and creator compensation is far from over. As Anthropic and other firms consider public good funds, they must not overlook the immediate needs of creators. The Smart Fund represents a practical step toward fairness. For a deeper look at how AI is reshaping industries, see our analysis of AI push puts banks at mercy of tech firms. Meanwhile, anti-AI protesters take direct action, highlighting growing public concern. And as AI firms pace the frontier, the risk of collusion grows. These issues underscore why creators must be compensated fairly.