The COP31 climate summit in Turkey is facing a major controversy as all mentions of fossil fuels have been removed from the draft outcome text, leading campaigners to warn of a "ghost COP." The second draft, released on Thursday afternoon, dropped a pledge to phase out fossil fuels and weakened goals on electrification, raising fears that the summit will fail to deliver meaningful action.
What Happened at COP31?
The draft text, known as the "cover decision," sets out the main commitments from the summit. In a surprising move, the second draft removed any reference to phasing out fossil fuels, a key demand from many countries and activists. The text also weakened language on electrification and failed to outline how developing countries would receive financial support to tackle the climate crisis.
Panama made an unusual intervention, writing to the Turkish and Australian presidents of the talks to announce that it would block any outcome unless all its demands were met. Panama's environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, signed the letter, which stated: "They are beautiful speeches. But while we listen to endless oratory, the planet is being destroyed … Outside this room and this conference, the world needs and expects radical change from us, and we are not delivering it."
Why the Removal of Fossil Fuels Matters
The omission of fossil fuels from the draft is significant because burning fossil fuels is the primary driver of climate change. A pledge to phase out fossil fuels was a central expectation for COP31, especially following previous summits where the issue was hotly debated. Without it, the summit risks producing a weak outcome that fails to address the root cause of global warming.
Campaigners have labeled the draft a "ghost COP," suggesting that the summit is hollow and lacking substance. The removal also signals a potential backtracking on commitments made at earlier COPs, such as the pledge to transition away from fossil fuels made at COP28 in Dubai.

The Role of Consensus and Panama's Stand
COP negotiations operate by consensus, meaning that any single country can block an agreement. Panama's threat to block the outcome is therefore a powerful move, especially if other nations join its stance. The letter from Panama reflects growing frustration among vulnerable countries that are already experiencing the impacts of climate change.
If Panama follows through, it could upend the talks in their final hours, forcing additional negotiations or leading to a collapse. This highlights the tension between countries pushing for ambitious climate action and those reluctant to commit to fossil fuel phase-out.
What's at Stake for Developing Countries
Developing countries are particularly vulnerable to climate impacts and require financial support to adapt and transition to clean energy. The draft texts failed to specify how this support would be delivered, leaving many nations dissatisfied. Without clear commitments on finance, trust in the process may erode further.
The lack of financial details also undermines the credibility of developed countries' promises, as developing nations struggle to cope with extreme weather events and rising sea levels.
Key Takeaways from the Draft Controversy
- All mentions of fossil fuels were removed from the COP31 draft outcome, including a phase-out pledge.
- Panama has threatened to block any outcome unless its demands are met, citing insufficient action.
- Goals on electrification were weakened, and financial support for developing countries remains unclear.
- Campaigners warn of a "ghost COP" if the summit fails to deliver meaningful commitments.
- Consensus-based negotiations give any country the power to block agreements, raising the stakes.
Comparison of Draft Texts
| Element | First Draft | Second Draft |
|---|---|---|
| Fossil fuel phase-out | Included pledge | Removed entirely |
| Electrification goals | Strong language | Weakened |
| Financial support for developing countries | Mentioned but vague | Still vague, no specifics |
| Overall ambition | Moderate | Significantly reduced |
What to Watch Next
As the summit approaches its final hours, all eyes are on whether Panama and other countries will follow through on blocking the outcome. The Turkish and Australian presidents of the talks face pressure to broker a compromise that keeps the process alive while addressing the concerns of vulnerable nations.
If the draft stands, COP31 may be remembered as a missed opportunity, further eroding faith in international climate negotiations. The world is watching, and the decisions made in these final hours will have lasting implications for global climate action. The background to this story is set out in Energy Utilities: latest articles.
FAQ
What is COP31?
COP31 is the 31st Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, currently being held in Turkey. It brings together countries to negotiate global climate action.
Why was the fossil fuel phase-out removed from the draft?
The removal likely reflects opposition from some countries that are reluctant to commit to phasing out fossil fuels. The draft text is subject to negotiations, and language can be changed to accommodate various interests.
What does Panama's threat mean for the summit?
Panama's threat to block any outcome could derail the talks, as COP decisions require consensus. If other countries support Panama, it could force changes to the draft or lead to a stalemate.
What are the implications of a 'ghost COP'?
A 'ghost COP' would mean the summit fails to produce meaningful commitments, undermining trust in the UN climate process and delaying urgent action needed to address the climate crisis.