Psychologists are noticing a drop in patients as more people turn to AI chatbots for mental health support. The rise of artificial intelligence has disrupted many industries, and therapy is no exception. Therapists in Spain report that patients are increasingly using chatbots like ChatGPT instead of seeking professional help, leading to concerns about the quality of care and the future of the profession.
The Rise of AI Chatbots as 'Pocket Therapists'
The arrival of AI has changed how people search for information and interact online. According to Aurora Gómez Delgado, a therapist at Corio Psicología, "We notice a drop in patients because they no longer enter our blogs." This shift is partly due to the way AI chatbots provide instant answers, making traditional therapy websites less trafficked. Gómez Delgado also highlights a deeper issue: "There is an epidemic of loneliness, and some people don't enter therapy because they use chatbots to talk instead of with people."
This trend is not universal. Andrea Enseñat Buades, another psychologist consulted, has not seen a change in patient volume. However, she has observed cases where chatbot use worsens problems. "ChatGPT has said I have anxious attachment or that I am right and you are not," she explains, referring to patients who come in with diagnoses or validation from AI that may not be accurate.

Why This Matters: Risks and Benefits of AI in Mental Health
The key issue is how AI is used. Lola de Müller, a health psychologist and integrative therapist, notes, "There is a growing risk in the rise of generalist chatbots used as 'pocket therapists.' But I also believe that AI, well integrated and under human supervision, can be a useful tool. It all depends on the role given to it."

For some, AI offers a convenient and anonymous way to talk about problems. But for others, it can lead to misdiagnosis, dependency, and a loss of human connection. The loss of identity is another concern: "When a machine does the same as you but faster, people lose the identity they had associated with work," says Enseñat.

- Patient drop: Some therapists report fewer patients as people use chatbots instead of browsing therapy blogs.
- Worsened problems: Chatbots may validate incorrect beliefs or give misleading diagnoses, aggravating issues.
- Loss of identity: As AI replicates human tasks, professionals may struggle with their sense of purpose.
- Potential benefits: With human supervision, AI can be a useful supplement to therapy, not a replacement.
- Loneliness epidemic: People may substitute AI conversations for real human connection, missing the benefits of therapy.
What the Experts Say
Enseñat is part of the Working Group on Psychology and Artificial Intelligence at the Official College of Psychologists. She and others are calling for careful consideration of AI's role in mental health. While AI can provide immediate support, it lacks the nuance and empathy of a trained professional. The consensus is that AI should not replace therapy but can be a tool when used responsibly.

Therapists are also adapting by integrating AI into their practices where appropriate, such as using it for administrative tasks or as a supplement to therapy. However, they emphasize the importance of human oversight and the irreplaceable value of the therapeutic relationship. The background to this story is set out in Teens Are Using AI as Their Therapist: A New Mental Health Challenge. A related thread runs through Rave Health Benefits for Middle-Aged Women: A Mental Health Secre. Earlier coverage in Female Footballers Retirement Crisis: Financial and Mental Health shows how the argument developed.
What to Watch Next
As AI continues to evolve, its impact on mental health care will likely grow. Key developments to watch include regulations on AI in healthcare, the integration of AI into therapeutic settings, and public awareness of its limitations. The conversation is shifting from whether AI will replace therapists to how it can best support them. A closer look at the same subject appears in Joe Harkness: Bird Therapy and Mental Health Advocate. Anyone following the wider picture can start with International Student Mental Health: The Luna Wong Tragedy. The same theme surfaces in AI Chatbots Give Inaccurate Election Voting Advice, Study Finds, which takes a different angle.
For now, psychologists advise caution. If you're considering using a chatbot for mental health support, remember that it is not a substitute for professional help. If you're struggling, reach out to a licensed therapist who can provide personalized care. Context on how this played out before sits in AI Chatbots Give Inaccurate Voting Advice in Elections. A companion piece, Spain Rejects EU Plan to End Iberian Rail Gauge Exception, approaches the same subject from another angle.
FAQ
Are AI chatbots replacing therapists?
No, AI chatbots are not replacing therapists, but some people are using them as a first resort or supplement. Experts emphasize that chatbots lack the empathy and training of human therapists and should not be used as a substitute for professional care.
Can AI chatbots worsen mental health?
Yes, in some cases. Chatbots may validate incorrect beliefs or provide misleading diagnoses, which can aggravate existing problems. They are not equipped to handle complex mental health issues and may give harmful advice if not supervised.
What is the loss of identity in the context of AI?
The loss of identity refers to professionals feeling a diminished sense of self-worth when AI performs tasks they were once valued for. As AI replicates human work, some individuals struggle with their professional identity and purpose.
How can AI be used positively in mental health?
AI can be a useful tool when integrated under human supervision, such as for administrative tasks, providing psychoeducation, or offering initial support. It should always complement, not replace, the therapeutic relationship with a licensed professional.