UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer has told his cabinet he will not resign unless a formal leadership challenge is triggered, pushing back against growing calls from within his own Labour Party to step down. During a tense cabinet meeting on Tuesday, Starmer insisted that the threshold for a leadership contest had not been met, and he urged ministers to focus on governing rather than internal turmoil. The move comes after a series of poor local election results and mounting dissatisfaction among Labour MPs.
Cabinet Meeting Turns Defiant
According to sources inside the meeting, Starmer did not allow cabinet critics to respond before swiftly moving the discussion to foreign policy, specifically the situation in the Middle East. No minister directly called on him to resign during the session, although several had previously suggested he should consider his position. The prime minister notably avoided one-on-one meetings before or after cabinet, except with his close ally Richard Hermer.
Starmer’s defiance was seen as a direct challenge to Health Secretary Wes Streeting, who has been widely speculated to be considering a leadership bid. Starmer told ministers he intended to get on with governing, effectively daring Streeting to launch a formal challenge. One source said Streeting tried to speak privately with Starmer after the meeting but was rebuffed.
Resignation Adds Fuel to Speculation
Shortly after cabinet, Home Office minister Jess Phillips resigned from the government, citing the prime minister’s failure to “grasp this rare opportunity with gusto.” Phillips, a close ally of Streeting, wrote that she wanted a Labour government to succeed but could not continue under the current leadership. Her resignation has fueled speculation of an orchestrated move to pressure Starmer.
“I want a Labour government to work and I will strive as I always have for its success and popularity, but I’m not seeing the change I think I, and the country expect, and so cannot continue to serve as a minister under the current leadership,” Phillips wrote in her resignation letter.
Internal Anger and Loyalty Divides
There was visible anger within cabinet ranks over what ministers described as Streeting’s attempts to destabilize the prime minister. One minister said Streeting entered the room “as though nothing had happened” and faced “evil looks” from colleagues. Another added that Streeting’s behavior showed he had “no plan” and lacked cabinet support for a challenge.
Starmer’s allies have pointed to the fact that at least 10 more MPs called on him to set a timetable to depart, but no formal mechanism has been triggered. Under Labour Party rules, a leadership challenge requires the support of 20% of the parliamentary party, a threshold that has not yet been reached.
What Happens Next?
Political analysts suggest that Starmer’s survival depends on whether discontent spreads beyond the backbenches. The prime minister is relying on the lack of a clear alternative and the party’s fear of a snap general election. However, the ongoing instability has already had an economic cost, as Starmer acknowledged to cabinet.
“The past 48 hours have been destabilising for government and that has a real economic cost for our country and for families,” Starmer said. “The Labour party has a process for challenging a leader and that has not been triggered. The country expects us to get on with governing.”
Key Points at a Glance
- Starmer told cabinet he will not resign without a formal leadership challenge.
- Health Secretary Wes Streeting is seen as the most likely challenger but has not yet triggered a contest.
- Jess Phillips resigned from government, citing lack of change under Starmer.
- At least 10 MPs have called for Starmer to set a departure timetable.
- No formal challenge has been launched, as the 20% threshold remains unmet.
FAQ: Starmer Leadership Crisis
Can Keir Starmer be forced to resign?
No, under Labour Party rules, a leader can only be removed through a formal leadership challenge. This requires 20% of Labour MPs (around 50 signatures) to trigger a vote. Currently, that threshold has not been met.
Who could replace Starmer if he steps down?
The most frequently mentioned names are Health Secretary Wes Streeting and Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham. Both have been critical of Starmer’s leadership but have not officially declared a challenge.
What happens if a leadership challenge is triggered?
If 20% of Labour MPs sign a letter of no confidence, a leadership election is held. All Labour MPs and party members can vote. The winner becomes the new leader and, if Labour is in government, the new prime minister.