Australia should remove religion from its legal definition of terrorism, according to a new report by the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM). The recommendation aims to prevent giving accused terrorists “false credibility” and to avoid stigmatizing religious minorities.
The highly anticipated review, released Thursday, examined how terrorism has been defined in Australia over the past 25 years, following laws introduced after the September 11 attacks. It also proposes that making bomb threats should not automatically result in life imprisonment.
Why Remove Religion from the Terrorism Definition?
INSLM head Jake Blight said that including religion in the definition gives terrorists “false credibility” and reinforces their narrative of holy war. The report argues that referring to religion in the legal definition can also have a detrimental impact on religious minorities.
“Having a law that requires proof that terrorists were advancing a ‘religious’ cause gives these terrorists false credibility and reinforces their narrative that they are doing holy work,” the report states. “The same individuals will still be able to be prosecuted, but should be described as violent ideologues.”
The recommendation comes as the Australian Federal Police (AFP) and the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO) warn that the rise of extremist, violent nationalism has changed the threat landscape. The motivations behind some terrorist attacks can no longer be neatly categorized into single ideologies.
What the Report Recommends
The INSLM report makes several key recommendations to modernize Australia’s terrorism laws. These include:
- Removing references to religion from the definition of terrorism.
- Ensuring that making bomb threats does not automatically lead to life imprisonment.
- Replacing the term “religion” with “violent ideologues” to describe offenders.
- Adjusting the legal framework to better reflect the diverse motivations behind contemporary terrorist acts.
These changes are intended to make the law more precise and to avoid unintended consequences for religious groups.
Impact on Religious Minorities and Legal Practice
The report highlights that the current definition can inadvertently stigmatize entire religious communities. By requiring proof that an act was committed in the name of religion, the law may reinforce negative stereotypes and fuel discrimination.
Legal experts suggest that removing religion from the definition could lead to more accurate prosecutions. It would allow authorities to focus on the violent actions themselves rather than the ideological labels. However, some critics argue that religion can be a relevant factor in understanding motive and should not be entirely excluded.
Bomb Threats and Sentencing Reform
Another significant recommendation is to reconsider the penalty for making bomb threats. Currently, such offenses can carry a maximum sentence of life imprisonment. The INSLM argues that this is disproportionate and that the law should be amended to allow for more appropriate sentencing.
This change would align with the principle that punishments should fit the crime, while still recognizing the serious nature of bomb threats and their potential to cause public panic.
Comparing Australia’s Terrorism Definition with Other Countries
Australia is not alone in grappling with how to define terrorism. The table below compares key aspects of terrorism definitions in Australia, the United Kingdom, Canada, and the United States.
| Country | Includes Religion? | Key Feature | Maximum Penalty for Bomb Threats |
|---|---|---|---|
| Australia | Yes (currently) | Definition includes religious, ideological, or political motives | Life imprisonment |
| United Kingdom | No (since 2000) | Definition focuses on political, religious, or ideological purpose | Up to life imprisonment |
| Canada | Yes | Definition includes religious, political, or ideological purpose | Up to life imprisonment |
| United States | No (federal definition) | Definition focuses on coercing government or civilians | Varies by state |
As the table shows, Australia’s inclusion of religion is not unique, but the recommendation to remove it would align the country with nations like the UK and the US that have already taken such steps. The background to this story is set out in Fake Customer Reviews in Australia: Legal or Not?. A related thread runs through UK Bans Support for Iran's IRGC: National Security Impact. Earlier coverage in Australia Flag Burning Laws and Australia Day Proposal shows how the argument developed.
What to Watch Next
The government will now consider the INSLM’s recommendations. Given the changing threat landscape and the warnings from security agencies, there is pressure to update the laws. However, any changes will need to balance civil liberties, national security, and the rights of religious minorities. A closer look at the same subject appears in Business: latest articles. Anyone following the wider picture can start with US Soldier Arrested in UK on Spying for Russia Allegations. The same theme surfaces in US Army Member Arrested in UK Over Alleged Russia Links, which takes a different angle.
Stakeholders, including legal experts, religious groups, and security agencies, are expected to debate the proposals in the coming months. The outcome will shape how Australia prosecutes and prevents terrorism for years to come. Context on how this played out before sits in Royal Navy Serviceman Arrested Under National Security Act.
FAQ
Why does the INSLM recommend removing religion from the terrorism definition?
The INSLM argues that including religion gives terrorists false credibility and reinforces their narrative of holy war. It also has a detrimental impact on religious minorities by stigmatizing entire communities.
Will terrorists still be prosecuted if religion is removed?
Yes. The report states that the same individuals will still be able to be prosecuted, but they should be described as violent ideologues rather than religious terrorists.
What is the recommendation regarding bomb threats?
The INSLM recommends that making bomb threats should not automatically result in life imprisonment. The penalty should be proportionate to the offense.
How does Australia’s definition compare to other countries?
Australia currently includes religion in its definition, similar to Canada. The UK and the US do not include religion in their definitions, focusing instead on political or ideological motives.