Three exonerated former death row prisoners in Florida have publicly called on incoming governor Byron Donalds to halt the state's record run of executions and review the cases of all 235 prisoners currently under condemnation. The men made their appeal at a press conference in Tallahassee on Thursday, hosted by the advocacy group Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty (FADP). They are seeking a roundtable discussion with Donalds, a Republican, as well as the state's new legislative leaders, in pursuit of a moratorium.
Florida leads the country in both executions and exonerations, a paradox that has intensified scrutiny of the state's capital punishment system. Next Thursday's scheduled execution of convicted murderer Thomas Overton will be the state's 20th this year, surpassing the record of 19 set in 2025. The exonerated men argue that the pace of executions demands immediate review.
Who Are the Exonerated Prisoners Making the Call?
The press conference featured Herman Lindsey, who was exonerated in 2009 after spending three years on death row following a wrongful conviction for the 1994 killing of a pawn shop owner. Lindsey is also executive director of Witness to Innocence, an organization that supports death row exonerees. He was joined by two other exonerated former death row prisoners, though their names were not immediately released.
Lindsey expressed hope that Donalds would be more sympathetic than termed-out governor Ron DeSantis, who will have signed 50 death warrants by the time he leaves office in January. All but two of those death sentences were carried out during DeSantis' second term. "Mr Byron, you don't look like you are a person that is barbaric," Lindsey said. "I hope that you consider re-evaluating the death penalty before..."
Why Florida's Execution Record Matters
Florida's aggressive execution schedule under Governor DeSantis has drawn national attention. The state has carried out 19 executions in 2025 and is set to exceed that number with Overton's scheduled execution. This pace is unprecedented in modern Florida history and has raised questions about the fairness and accuracy of capital convictions.
The state also leads the nation in exonerations from death row, with 30 cases since 1973, according to the Death Penalty Information Center. This statistic underscores the risk of wrongful executions and the importance of thorough case review. The exonerated men argue that the state's rush to execute increases the likelihood of irreversible mistakes.
- Florida has scheduled its 20th execution of the year, breaking the previous record of 19 set in 2025.
- Governor DeSantis will have signed 50 death warrants by the end of his term, with 48 carried out in his second term.
- Florida leads the country in both executions and exonerations, with 30 death row exonerations since 1973.
- Exonerated former prisoners are seeking a moratorium and a review of all 235 condemned cases.
- The group hopes incoming governor Byron Donalds will take a more sympathetic approach.
What a Moratorium Would Mean for Florida
A moratorium would temporarily halt executions while the state reviews its capital punishment system. The exonerated men are not calling for abolition but for a pause and a comprehensive review of all 235 death row cases. They argue that such a review is necessary to identify potential wrongful convictions and ensure that only the guilty are executed.
Such a move would be a significant departure from the current administration's approach. DeSantis has been a staunch supporter of the death penalty and has expedited executions. A moratorium would require cooperation from the legislature, which is why the group is also reaching out to new legislative leaders.
Political Implications for Byron Donalds
Byron Donalds, a Republican congressman, won the Florida governor race in a closely watched election. He has previously positioned himself as a strong supporter of law and order, but his stance on the death penalty has not been fully detailed. The exonerated men's appeal puts pressure on him to clarify his position.Donalds has also distanced himself from former President Donald Trump in some instances, suggesting a willingness to chart his own course. This could open the door to a more measured approach on executions. However, any moratorium would likely face opposition from conservative lawmakers and victims' families.
What to Watch Next
The group plans to request meetings with Donalds and legislative leaders in the coming weeks. They hope to present their case and push for a moratorium. Meanwhile, the scheduled execution of Thomas Overton next Thursday will proceed unless intervened. The outcome of this execution and the response from Donalds will signal the direction of Florida's death penalty policy.
For context on Donalds' political rise, see our coverage of Byron Donalds winning the Florida governor race, which made history. His relationship with Trump has been complex, as detailed in our report on Florida Republican Byron Donalds distancing himself from Trump. These dynamics could influence his approach to the death penalty.
The exonerated prisoners' appeal comes amid a broader national conversation about capital punishment. Florida's actions are being watched closely, especially given the state's high number of exonerations. Our article on Florida's double execution under DeSantis highlights the rarity of such events and the state's aggressive stance. The call for a moratorium is a direct challenge to that stance.
As Donalds prepares to take office, he faces a decision that will define his legacy. The exonerated men's plea is a test of his leadership and compassion. For a deeper look at Donalds' political strategy, read about Byron Donalds' mega-MAGA bid and why he avoids Trump in Florida. The death penalty debate will likely intersect with his broader policy agenda.
Finally, the national debate on executions continues to evolve. Recent events like the halt of Christa Pike's execution in Tennessee show that states are reconsidering their approaches. Florida's path under Donalds will be a key indicator of the future of capital punishment in the U.S.
FAQ
Who are the exonerated prisoners calling for a moratorium?
The press conference was led by Herman Lindsey, who was exonerated in 2009 after three years on death row. He was joined by two other exonerated former death row prisoners. Lindsey is also the executive director of Witness to Innocence.
How many executions has Florida carried out this year?
Florida has carried out 19 executions so far this year, and the scheduled execution of Thomas Overton next Thursday would be the 20th, breaking the previous record of 19 set in 2025.
What is Byron Donalds' stance on the death penalty?
Byron Donalds has not fully detailed his stance on the death penalty. He has positioned himself as a law-and-order Republican, but the exonerated prisoners hope he will be more sympathetic than Governor DeSantis.
What is the goal of the exonerated prisoners' appeal?
They are seeking a moratorium on executions and a review of all 235 death row cases. They want a roundtable discussion with Governor Donalds and legislative leaders to push for this review.