Renfe has launched a tender for 30 new AVE trains (expandable to 40) to renew its high-speed fleet in Spain, but the operator is determined not to repeat the costly mistakes it made with Talgo. The new competition prioritizes quality over price, with technical proposals carrying 70% of the final score and price only 30%.
The move comes after the troubled rollout of Talgo's Avril trains, which arrived more than two years late and suffered a string of incidents when they finally entered service. Renfe hopes the new scoring system will prevent a similar debacle.
Why Renfe Is Changing Its Approach
Renfe's experience with Talgo's Avril trains (series 106) was a wake-up call. The operator ordered 30 units in two batches between 2015 and 2016, expecting them to modernize routes like the Galicia-Madrid high-speed line. Instead, the trains were delivered over two years behind schedule, costing Talgo a €116 million penalty.
Even after entering service, the Avrils faced a series of technical issues across multiple lines. That combination of delays and reliability problems has pushed Renfe to rethink how it evaluates train manufacturers.
"We don't want to repeat the same chaos," a Renfe source said, acknowledging that the operator will prioritize quality over price in the new tender. The goal is to avoid the pitfalls of awarding contracts primarily on cost.
How the New Tender Works
The new competition, which Renfe approved last month, is structured to reward technical excellence. The technical proposal accounts for 70% of the final score, while price makes up the remaining 30%. This is a significant shift from previous tenders where price often played a larger role.
Within the technical criteria, Renfe is expected to evaluate factors such as reliability, delivery timelines, and after-sales support. The operator has not disclosed all the details, but the emphasis on quality is clear.
Renfe expects to announce the winning bidders in September. The new trains will be used to replace older units and expand capacity on Spain's high-speed network.
What Happened with Talgo
The Talgo Avril saga is a cautionary tale. Renfe ordered the trains in 2015 and 2016, but the first units didn't enter service until 2024—more than two years late. The delay was blamed on technical complexities and production issues.
When the trains finally arrived, they were plagued by malfunctions, including problems with doors, air conditioning, and onboard systems. Passengers and crew reported numerous incidents, forcing Renfe to temporarily withdraw some units for repairs.
The €116 million penalty imposed on Talgo was one of the largest in Spanish railway history, but it couldn't compensate for the disruption caused to passengers and the operator's reputation.
Key Takeaways for the New AVE Train Tender
- Quality over price: Technical proposal worth 70% of the score; price only 30%.
- 30 firm trains, up to 40: Renfe aims to renew its high-speed fleet and expand capacity.
- September decision: Winning bidders expected to be announced in September.
- Avoiding past mistakes: Renfe wants to prevent delays and reliability issues like those with Talgo Avril.
- Penalty precedent: Talgo was fined €116 million for late delivery, a record for Renfe.
Comparison: Old vs. New Tender Criteria
| Criterion | Previous Tenders (e.g., Talgo Avril) | New Tender (2025) |
|---|---|---|
| Price weighting | Higher (often 50% or more) | 30% |
| Technical weighting | Lower (often 50% or less) | 70% |
| Delivery timeline emphasis | Moderate | High (to avoid delays) |
| Penalty for delays | Yes, but applied after the fact | Stricter upfront requirements |
What This Means for the Rail Industry
Renfe's new approach could set a precedent for other European rail operators. By prioritizing quality, the operator hopes to attract manufacturers with proven track records and avoid the race to the bottom that often leads to cut corners. The background to this story is set out in Renfe Cuts 100,000 Seats on Madrid-Valencia as Talgo Avril Trains Face Cracks. A related thread runs through Talgo Avril Trains Face Repeated Cracking Issues in Spain. Earlier coverage in Talgo Avril Cracks Cost Renfe €132 Million in New Deal shows how the argument developed.
For manufacturers like Talgo, Alstom, Siemens, and CAF, the new criteria mean they'll need to demonstrate not just competitive pricing but also robust reliability and adherence to deadlines. The competition is expected to be fierce, with several major players likely to bid. A closer look at the same subject appears in Renfe Expands to Portugal, Not France, in Strategic Shift. Anyone following the wider picture can start with SNCF High-Speed Rail Italy: France Beats Renfe in 2027. The same theme surfaces in Renfe vs Iryo: CNMC Orders Workshop Access in Rail War, which takes a different angle.
The outcome will also affect passengers, who have endured delays and cancellations due to the Avril issues. A smoother procurement process could lead to more reliable service and newer trains on key routes. Context on how this played out before sits in AVE and Iryo Train Collision in Urda: What We Know So Far. A companion piece, Renfe Blocks Iryo from Workshops in Rail Maintenance Dispute, approaches the same subject from another angle.
FAQ
Why is Renfe buying new AVE trains?
Renfe is purchasing 30 new AVE trains (with an option for 40) to renew its high-speed fleet and replace older units. The new trains will help expand capacity and improve reliability on routes like Galicia-Madrid.
What went wrong with Talgo's Avril trains?
The Talgo Avril trains were delivered more than two years late and suffered numerous technical issues when they entered service. Renfe fined Talgo €116 million for the delays, but the problems disrupted passengers and damaged the operator's reputation.
How will the new tender prevent similar problems?
The new tender gives technical proposals a 70% weighting, compared to 30% for price. This means Renfe will prioritize factors like reliability, delivery timelines, and after-sales support over simply choosing the cheapest option.
When will the winning bidders be announced?
Renfe expects to announce the winning bidders in September. The selected manufacturers will then begin production of the new trains, with delivery schedules to be determined.