The Columbus Crew have navigated a turbulent 2025 season, switching paths en route to the MLS playoffs after a surprising midseason coaching change. The club, known for its holistic operation and patient approach, faced a test of its conventions when new head coach Henrik Rydström departed after just 16 games.
In January, chief soccer officer Issa Tall welcomed the club’s eighth head coach, Henrik Rydström. The 50-year-old Swede, who had only previously coached in his native Sweden, used his introductory presser to laud the values of relationism, praise his predecessor, and plot a bold course for a new Crew. It was assumed he’d be around a while – the Crew have historically been patient with coaches, needing only seven bosses to navigate their first 30 seasons.
By mid-May, after just 16 games in charge, Rydström was on his way back to Sweden. His five wins were the lowest of the eight full-time Crew coaches. And yet, Saturday sees the Crew begin the MLS Cup Playoffs in a best-of-three matchup with Lionel Messi and Inter Miami. Columbus are one of four teams to make the postseason following a midseason coaching change. Two of the other three could pin their turnarounds on player moves, but the Crew’s story is one of resilience and adaptation.
Why the Coaching Change Happened
Rydström’s departure was abrupt but not entirely unexpected given the results. The Crew had high hopes for the Swedish coach, who brought a philosophy centered on relationism—a style that emphasizes fluid movement and positional interchanges. However, the transition from theory to MLS reality proved difficult. The team struggled to adapt, and the wins did not come as hoped.
The front office, led by Issa Tall, made the tough decision to part ways early, signaling a shift back to more familiar territory. The move was a departure from the club’s traditionally patient approach, but with playoff aspirations on the line, action was deemed necessary.

How the Crew Turned Their Season Around
Following Rydström’s exit, the Crew appointed an interim coach and simplified their approach. The focus shifted to leveraging the squad’s strengths: a mix of experienced MLS veterans and promising academy talent. The under-19s won the national cup in June, while the developmental Crew 2 made a fourth semi-final berth in five seasons in MLS Next Pro, highlighting the club’s depth.
The first team responded with improved results, climbing the Eastern Conference table to secure a playoff spot. Key players stepped up, and the defense tightened. The Crew’s ability to punch above its weight—winning the third-most major titles (nine) among MLS originals—resurfaced at the right time.
Key Factors in the Playoff Push
- Coaching stability: The interim staff provided a steady hand and simplified tactics.
- Academy integration: Young players from the club’s successful youth setup contributed vital minutes.
- Veteran leadership: Experienced players guided the team through the transition.
- Fan support: The fervent fanbase, which once helped block relocation, continued to fuel the team.
- Timely wins: Crucial victories in the summer months built momentum.
Comparing the Crew’s Season to Other Midseason Changes
Columbus is one of four teams to make the postseason after a midseason coaching change. Two of the other three could attribute their turnarounds to player acquisitions, but the Crew relied on internal solutions. The table below compares the four teams’ regular-season records after the change.
| Team | Midseason Coach Change | Record After Change | Playoff Seed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Columbus Crew | Yes (Rydström out) | Improved | TBD |
| Team A | Yes | Strong | TBD |
| Team B | Yes | Moderate | TBD |
| Team C | Yes | Mixed | TBD |
While specific records are not provided, the Crew’s resilience stands out. Their ability to adapt without major signings speaks to the club’s depth and culture.
What to Watch in the Playoffs
The Crew face a daunting task against Inter Miami and Lionel Messi in a best-of-three series. The team’s defensive organization and midfield control will be crucial to containing Miami’s star power. Set pieces and counterattacks could be the Crew’s best weapons. The background to this story is set out in MLS Playoff Overhaul: Double-Elimination, 20 Teams, Reseeding. A related thread runs through DC United's Playoff Drought Hits Historic Lows. Earlier coverage in MLS Decision Day 2025: Wooden Spoon, Golden Boot and Playoff Spots shows how the argument developed.
Additionally, the experience gained from this season’s adversity could forge a stronger unit. The players have bought into the interim staff’s system, and the academy graduates are hungry to prove themselves on the big stage. A closer look at the same subject appears in MLS Playoffs Overhaul: Double-Elimination, Reseeding, and 20 Teams. Anyone following the wider picture can start with Wakefield Trinity Reach Super League Playoff Semi-Finals After Leigh. The same theme surfaces in St Helens Playoff Hopes End After Leeds Thrashing, which takes a different angle.
The Crew’s playoff run will also be a test of the club’s holistic model. If they can overcome Miami, it would validate their approach and perhaps set a new precedent for handling midseason changes. Context on how this played out before sits in France 4-6 England: World Cup Third-Place Playoff Analysis.
FAQ
Why did Henrik Rydström leave the Columbus Crew?
Rydström was dismissed after just 16 games due to poor results. His five wins were the lowest of any full-time Crew coach, prompting the front office to make a change to salvage the season.
How did the Crew make the playoffs after a coaching change?
The team simplified its tactics under interim leadership, leaned on veteran players, and integrated academy talent. Improved defensive organization and timely wins helped them climb the table.
Who are the Crew playing in the first round?
Columbus faces Inter Miami, led by Lionel Messi, in a best-of-three series. The matchup pits the Crew’s resilience against Miami’s star power.
What is relationism, and why did it fail at the Crew?
Relationism is a tactical philosophy emphasizing fluid positional interchanges. It struggled to translate to MLS due to the league’s physicality and the team’s lack of familiarity with the system.
The Crew’s journey this season has been anything but conventional. From the shock of Rydström’s exit to the rise of academy players, the club has shown adaptability. As they enter the playoffs, they carry the hopes of a fanbase that has stood by them through relocation threats and coaching upheavals.
For a deeper look at how scandals can impact football clubs, see our analysis of the Spygate scandal: Southampton's pointless football transgression. Off-field controversies often shape on-field performance, and the Crew’s ability to focus amidst their own transition is commendable.
As the playoffs unfold, all eyes will be on whether the Crew can continue to punch above their weight. Their story is a reminder that in MLS, adaptability and resilience can sometimes trump star power.