Labour's Brexit red lines, crafted in 2020 to close down debate and neutralise the issue, are now facing a "dignified retirement" as the party's EU reset takes shape. A former adviser and Cabinet Office minister involved in drafting those very lines argues it's time to scrap them.
The red lines ruled out rejoining the EU, the single market, the customs union, and restoring freedom of movement. They were designed to narrow the target that Brexit had become for Labour and enabled the party to fight the 2024 election on a manifesto that was pro-EU but stopped short of rejoining.
Now, with a UK-EU summit approaching and a reset deal on the horizon, the author argues that the political space created by the budget's "breathing space" on the cost of living crisis may prove more defining. The discussions, he says, have not really moved on since the UK left on 31 January 2020.
Why Labour's Brexit Red Lines Were Created
After the 2019 election defeat, Labour needed to rebuild trust with voters who had backed Brexit. The red lines were a strategic tool to demonstrate that the party had listened and would not relitigate the 2016 referendum.
They allowed Labour to advocate a closer relationship with the EU while reassuring leavers that their vote would be respected. This positioning was crucial for the 2024 election, where Labour sought to win back former red wall seats.
The author still believes this was the right course strategically. The reset deal expected at this month's UK-EU summit will demonstrate the real benefits of a closer relationship, he says.
The Case for Scrapping the Red Lines
The red lines have served their purpose, but they now risk becoming a barrier to deeper cooperation. As the cost of living crisis persists and economic growth stalls, the case for a more ambitious EU relationship grows stronger.
Scrapping the red lines would not mean rejoining the EU overnight, but it would open the door to sectoral deals, regulatory alignment, and youth mobility schemes. These could deliver tangible benefits for businesses and citizens.
The author suggests that the political space for this shift is opening up. The budget's focus on "breathing space" has created room for a broader conversation about the UK's place in Europe.
What the EU Reset Could Deliver
The reset deal is expected to cover areas such as defence, security, and trade facilitation. It may also include a veterinary agreement to reduce border checks on food and agricultural products.
Such measures could ease friction for exporters and help lower prices for consumers. The author argues that this is just the beginning of what could be achieved if the red lines were relaxed.
A more ambitious reset could include mutual recognition of professional qualifications, making it easier for UK professionals to work in the EU and vice versa. This would address labour shortages in key sectors.
Key Takeaways
- Labour's Brexit red lines were a strategic tool to neutralise the issue and win the 2024 election.
- They ruled out rejoining the EU, single market, customs union, and freedom of movement.
- The author argues they have served their purpose and should be scrapped.
- A reset deal at the upcoming UK-EU summit could demonstrate the benefits of closer ties.
- Scrapping red lines could open the door to sectoral deals and regulatory alignment.
Comparing the Options
| Option | Description | Potential Benefits | Political Feasibility |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maintain red lines | Keep current policy of no rejoining EU, single market, customs union, or freedom of movement. | Reassures leavers, avoids reopening Brexit debate. | High – current Labour policy. |
| Scrap red lines | Remove restrictions, allowing consideration of closer alignment. | Enables sectoral deals, regulatory alignment, youth mobility. | Medium – requires political shift. |
| Rejoin single market | Full participation in the EU single market. | Frictionless trade, free movement. | Low – politically sensitive. |
| Customs union | Join a customs union with the EU. | No tariffs, reduced border checks. | Low – seen as betrayal of Brexit. |
The Political Reality
Despite the author's call to scrap the red lines, the political reality is complex. Both major parties remain cautious about reopening the Brexit debate, fearing a backlash from voters. The background to this story is set out in UK Labour Seeks Deeper EU Relationship Under Burnham. A related thread runs through Andy Burnham EU Review: Options for UK-EU Relations.
However, the author suggests that the public mood may be shifting. As the economic costs of Brexit become clearer, there is growing appetite for a closer relationship with the EU. Earlier coverage in Andy Burnham's EU Reset: UK-Europe Relations After Brexit shows how the argument developed. A closer look at the same subject appears in Andy Burnham's EU Reset: What It Means for UK Trade.
The reset deal is a first step. But the author argues that to truly unlock the benefits, Labour must be willing to go further and retire the red lines for good. Anyone following the wider picture can start with UK-EU Relations: Voters Reward Greater Ambition in Brexit Reset. The same theme surfaces in Andy Burnham Refuses to Rule Out Brexit Reversal in Labour Manifesto, which takes a different angle.
FAQ
What are Labour's Brexit red lines?
Labour's Brexit red lines are the policy commitments ruling out rejoining the EU, the single market, the customs union, and restoring freedom of movement. They were drawn up after the 2020 leadership contest to close down the Brexit debate and narrow the target for the party.
Why does the author want to scrap them?
The author argues that the red lines have served their purpose by helping Labour win the 2024 election, but they now risk holding back a more ambitious reset with the EU. Scrapping them could enable sectoral deals and regulatory alignment that would benefit the UK economy.
What is the EU reset deal?
The EU reset deal is an agreement being negotiated between the UK and the EU to improve their post-Brexit relationship. It is expected to cover areas such as defence, security, and trade facilitation, and may include a veterinary agreement to reduce border checks.
Will Labour actually scrap the red lines?
It is uncertain. While the author advocates scrapping them, Labour's leadership remains cautious about reopening the Brexit debate. The reset deal may be the first step towards a closer relationship, but full removal of the red lines would require a significant political shift.
The debate over Labour's Brexit red lines is far from over. As the UK-EU summit approaches, the author's intervention will add to the pressure for a more ambitious reset. The article on Labour's Brexit red lines facing 'dignified retirement' as EU reset provides further context on this evolving story.
For those following the energy sector, the piece on red balls on power lines: why they save lives might seem unrelated, but it underscores the importance of safety in infrastructure—a theme that resonates with the need for clear red lines in politics.
Ultimately, the decision on whether to scrap the red lines will have profound implications for the UK's future relationship with Europe. As the author concludes, the time may have come for a dignified retirement of these constraints.