Tom Willis, the dynamic No 8, is making waves in France and highlighting what England rugby is missing. His exceptional performances for Bordeaux have sparked discussions about England's selection policies and the depth of their back-row options. As Steve Borthwick's squad prepares for upcoming challenges, Willis's form in the Top 14 serves as a poignant reminder of the talent beyond England's shores.
Tom Willis's Journey to France
After receiving an enhanced contract offer, Tom Willis made the bold decision to move to France, following in the footsteps of his brother Jack. This move was unprecedented for a player of his caliber, signaling a shift in how English players view overseas opportunities. Willis has embraced the challenge, quickly becoming a key player for Bordeaux in the Top 14.
Performance in Top 14
Willis has been instrumental in Bordeaux's campaign, showcasing his powerful carrying, breakdown skills, and aerial prowess. His ability to dominate games has drawn praise from coaches and fans alike. Bordeaux's attack coach, Noel McNamara, lauded Willis's desire and competitiveness, highlighting a specific aerial battle that exemplified his determination.
England's No 8 Dilemma
England's back-row depth is a concern, with few players matching Willis's physicality and skill set. Borthwick has faced criticism for not utilizing Willis, especially given the team's struggles in the Six Nations. The debate intensifies as Willis continues to excel in France, raising questions about whether England can afford to overlook such talent.
Comparison with Other England Contenders
When comparing Willis to other England No 8 options, his stats stand out. His ball-carrying meters, tackles, and turnovers are among the best in the Top 14. The table below illustrates how Willis stacks up against current England squad members.

| Player | Club | Carries per Game | Tackles per Game | Turnovers Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tom Willis | Bordeaux | 15 | 12 | 8 |
| Billy Vunipola | Saracens | 12 | 10 | 5 |
| Alex Dombrandt | Harlequins | 14 | 11 | 6 |
- Willis leads in carries and turnovers, demonstrating his impact.
- His tackle count is comparable to England's top defenders.
- His form in the Top 14 suggests he could be a game-changer for England.
Why Borthwick Might Reconsider
With the Rugby World Cup on the horizon, Borthwick may need to reassess his options. Willis's ability to perform under pressure and his consistent excellence in a highly competitive league make a strong case for his inclusion. While the current policy favors players based in England, exceptional talents like Willis might warrant an exception.
FAQ
Why did Tom Willis move to France?
Tom Willis moved to France after receiving an enhanced contract offer, seeking new challenges and opportunities in the Top 14 with Bordeaux.
How is Tom Willis performing in the Top 14?
Willis has been outstanding, leading Bordeaux in carries and turnovers, and earning praise for his competitiveness and skill.
Could Tom Willis play for England again?
While current selection policies favor England-based players, Willis's exceptional form could prompt a reconsideration, especially given England's lack of depth at No 8.