Manchester United's poor start to the Premier League season has left them 13th in the table after four games, but are they truly as poor as their position suggests? With just four points from a possible 12, the Red Devils have already suffered defeats to Hull City and Manchester City, while managing a win against Ipswich Town and a draw at Everton. The early standings paint a bleak picture, but context is crucial when evaluating their performances.
Analysing Manchester United's Poor Start
United's four-point haul is their worst start to a Premier League season since 2014-15 under Louis van Gaal. However, the fixture list has been challenging, with trips to Hull and Everton sandwiching a home clash against rivals Manchester City. The 1-0 derby defeat came just three days after a Champions League victory over Sabah, while City enjoyed 48 hours more rest following their win at Porto. Such scheduling disparities can significantly impact performance, especially early in the season.
Moreover, new manager Michael Carrick is still implementing his tactical philosophy. The former midfielder, who took over permanently after a successful interim spell last season, has had to integrate new signings and adjust to the rigours of top-flight management. Patience is required, but results must improve quickly to avoid a crisis.
Carrick vs Solskjær: A Worrying Parallel?
Comparisons with Ole Gunnar Solskjær are inevitable. Like Carrick, Solskjær initially thrived as an interim boss, winning 14 of his first 19 games before being appointed permanently. However, his tenure unravelled, and United finished sixth—the same position they occupied when he took over. Carrick's permanent reign has begun less impressively, with just one win in four league games. But history doesn't have to repeat itself; Carrick has a different squad and backroom team, and the club's structure has evolved.
Nevertheless, the pressure is mounting. Sporting director Jason Wilcox will be monitoring results closely, and a few more poor performances could see Carrick facing uncomfortable questions. The upcoming fixtures against Brighton in the Carabao Cup and Fulham in the league are opportunities to steady the ship.

Key Statistics: Manchester United's Start vs Previous Seasons
| Season | Points after 4 games | Final position |
|---|---|---|
| 2023-24 | 4 | ? |
| 2022-23 | 6 | 3rd |
| 2021-22 | 7 | 6th |
| 2020-21 | 6 | 2nd |
As the table shows, a slow start doesn't necessarily dictate the final outcome. In 2020-21, United had six points after four games and finished second. Conversely, in 2021-22, they had seven points but ended sixth. The key is how the team responds.
Key Takeaways
- Fixture congestion and tough opponents have contributed to United's poor start.
- Carrick's tactical setup is still a work in progress, but signs of improvement are needed.
- Historical parallels with Solskjær exist, but Carrick has a different squad and support structure.
- Upcoming matches against Brighton and Fulham are crucial for building momentum.
FAQ
Are Manchester United really as poor as the table suggests?
Are Manchester United really as poor as the table suggests?
Not necessarily. While four points from four games is disappointing, mitigating factors include a tough fixture list, fixture congestion, and a new manager implementing his style. The table is a snapshot, not a final verdict.
Is Michael Carrick under pressure?
Is Michael Carrick under pressure?
Yes, but it's early days. The club hierarchy is likely to give him time, but a few more poor results could increase scrutiny, especially with Jason Wilcox monitoring performance.
How does Carrick compare to Solskjær?
How does Carrick compare to Solskjær?
Both started well as interim managers, but Carrick's permanent tenure has begun poorly. However, Carrick has a more modern squad and support structure, so the situations aren't identical.
In conclusion, while Manchester United's poor start is concerning, it's too early to write off their season. Carrick must quickly find solutions to avoid a downward spiral, starting with the upcoming cup and league fixtures. The next few weeks will reveal whether this is a blip or a deeper issue.
Best Products We’ve Tested and Rated

Our testing team has hands-on reviews of residential 5g wifi night vision, sd card, button spy, purse bag, and usb spy audio. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.
Our testing team has hands-on reviews of 4k spy, trail camera cellular, budget trail camera, non cellular trail camera, and cheap trail camera. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.