Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey has sparked a fresh debate over IMAX format after the film's official website introduced a format selector that lets users compare the trailer in six different aspect ratios. The tool, found under "Explore Formats," shows the same footage from the nearly square IMAX 70mm to the widescreen 35mm most audiences will see. While intended to showcase Nolan's commitment to image quality, some fans wonder if it inadvertently highlights a problem: the vast majority of viewers will never experience the film as the director intended.
What the Format Selector Reveals About IMAX vs. 35mm
The selector demonstrates how aspect ratio changes what is visible on screen. In IMAX 70mm, the format in which The Odyssey was originally shot, a character appears centered with significant headroom and footroom—areas without critical information. In the 35mm version, that same shot is cropped top and bottom, removing what some might call "superfluous" space. The story remains identical, but the image is, literally, from two different films.
This is not a new issue for Nolan. He has long championed IMAX as the superior format, and his films often include scenes shot with IMAX cameras that expand to fill taller screens. However, the promotional tool for The Odyssey makes the discrepancy more explicit than ever, inviting viewers to see exactly what they will miss in a standard theater.
Why Aspect Ratio Matters in Nolan's Filmmaking
Aspect ratio is the relationship between the width and height of the image. It determines what the viewer sees and what the director leaves out of the frame. For Nolan, this is a fundamental compositional decision. Shooting in IMAX 70mm allows him to use the full height of the frame to convey scale and immerse the audience. But when that image is cropped for 35mm, the composition changes—sometimes dramatically.
The debate is whether the format selector is a celebration of cinematic choice or an admission that most people will get a compromised version. For Nolan enthusiasts, the tool is a fascinating look at his process. For skeptics, it raises questions about accessibility and whether the director's vision is being undermined by the very marketing meant to promote it.
Key Takeaways from the Format Debate
- IMAX 70mm offers a taller image with more vertical information, while 35mm crops that information for widescreen presentation.
- The official website's format selector lets users see the difference, but it also highlights how few will see the intended version.
- Nolan has a history of shooting key sequences in IMAX, but The Odyssey appears to be a full IMAX endeavor, making the gap more pronounced.
- The debate reflects a broader tension between artistic vision and commercial reality in modern cinema.
Comparing IMAX 70mm and 35mm Formats
| Feature | IMAX 70mm | 35mm |
|---|---|---|
| Aspect Ratio | 1.43:1 (taller) | 2.39:1 (wider) |
| Image Area | Full frame with more vertical detail | Cropped top and bottom |
| Availability | Limited to select IMAX theaters | Standard multiplexes worldwide |
| Nolan's Intent | Primary format for composition | Compromised version for mass distribution |
The table above illustrates why the format selector has struck a nerve. The IMAX version is not just bigger; it is compositionally different. Scenes that rely on verticality—such as towering landscapes or intimate character moments—may lose impact in 35mm. This is not to say the 35mm version is bad, but it is undeniably a different film. The background to this story is set out in Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey IMAX Format Cuts Scenes on Purpose. A related thread runs through The Odyssey in Spain: Best IMAX and 70mm Theaters to See. Earlier coverage in Nolan Fans Fly to London for The Odyssey at BFI Imax shows how the argument developed.
What This Means for Viewers and Theaters
For most moviegoers, the 35mm version will be the only option. IMAX 70mm screens are rare, and even IMAX digital does not match the full 70mm aspect ratio. The format selector thus serves as a reminder of the gap between Nolan's ideal and the average cinema experience. Some argue that this transparency is commendable—it educates audiences about aspect ratios and encourages them to seek out premium formats. Others see it as a marketing gimmick that underscores a frustrating reality. A closer look at the same subject appears in The Odyssey BFI Imax: Nolan Fans Fly to London for Epic Film. Anyone following the wider picture can start with The Odyssey at BFI IMAX: Nolan Fans Travel Thousands for Epic Fil. The same theme surfaces in Christopher Nolan's 'The Odyssey' Becomes Highest-Grossing IMAX Film Ever, which takes a different angle.
The conversation also touches on the future of film presentation. As streaming becomes dominant, the theatrical experience is increasingly defined by premium formats. Nolan's insistence on IMAX is part of a broader push to preserve large-format cinema. But if only a fraction of viewers can access it, does the strategy backfire? The answer may depend on whether the format selector drives audiences to seek out IMAX screenings or simply leaves them feeling shortchanged. Context on how this played out before sits in The Odyssey Review: Christopher Nolan's Epic Stuns Audiences. A companion piece, Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey: Box Office & Review, approaches the same subject from another angle.
FAQ
What is the aspect ratio difference between IMAX 70mm and 35mm in The Odyssey?
IMAX 70mm uses an aspect ratio of approximately 1.43:1, which is taller and shows more vertical information. 35mm typically uses a widescreen ratio like 2.39:1, which crops the top and bottom of the image. This means the IMAX version reveals more of the scene, while the 35mm version is more horizontally focused.
Why did Nolan choose to shoot The Odyssey in IMAX 70mm?
Nolan has long been an advocate for IMAX because of its superior resolution and immersive quality. Shooting in IMAX 70mm allows him to compose shots with greater vertical depth and detail, enhancing the cinematic experience. It is also a way to differentiate his films from standard digital productions.
Will most people see The Odyssey in IMAX 70mm?
No, IMAX 70mm screens are limited worldwide. Most audiences will see the film in standard 35mm or digital formats, which crop the image. This discrepancy is at the heart of the debate around the film's format selector.
Does the format selector on the official website help or confuse viewers?
It depends on the viewer. For film enthusiasts, it is an educational tool that highlights Nolan's compositional choices. For casual viewers, it may create confusion or disappointment by showing them what they will miss in a standard theater. Either way, it has sparked a conversation about aspect ratios and presentation formats.