Elaine Paige's Honest Playlist: Songs That Shaped Her Life 2026

Elaine Paige's honest playlist reveals the songs that have shaped her legendary career, from her first love of the Everly Brothers to her enduring passion for the Police. In this exclusive interview, the musical theatre icon shares the tracks that define her life, offering a rare glimpse into her personal musical journey.

The First Song I Fell in Love With

Elaine Paige recalls singing All I Have to Do Is Dream by the Everly Brothers with her schoolfriend when she was just 11 or 12. She sang the harmony while her friend took the melody, a memory that still brings a smile to her face.

This early experience set the stage for a lifetime of musical appreciation, from crooners like Perry Como to the rock edge of the Police.

Karaoke and Live Performances

When asked about karaoke, Paige admits to a memorable night in Nice with a friend. After too much rosé, she belted out Hymne à l'amour, a tribute to Édith Piaf, whom she was about to portray in the West End. Her friend countered with Fools Rush In.

It's a playful side of the star that fans rarely see, but it highlights her love for performing in any setting.

First Single and Musical Roots

Her first single purchase was Magic Moments by Perry Como, bought for her mother's birthday. Her mother adored crooners like Como, Andy Williams, and Matt Monro, and those influences are still part of Paige's musical DNA.

The Song That Changed My Life

Without hesitation, Paige names Don't Cry for Me Argentina as the song that changed her life. “Without it, I probably wouldn't be talking to you today,” she says, acknowledging the pivotal role it played in her career.

Behind the Scenes: Hair and The King and I

Paige shares a harrowing memory from her time in Hair in 1968. With the lead and understudies unavailable, she had to perform Air at a moment's notice, emerging through a trapdoor covered in beads. She somehow knew every word.

On the flip side, she can no longer listen to Shall We Dance? from The King and I due to the sudden departure of her co-star Jason Scott Lee, leaving her to dance with a series of different kings in a heavy crinoline dress.

Party Anthems and Romantic Tunes

For parties, Paige chooses Roxanne by the Police, declaring, “I've loved the Police from the get-go.” When it comes to romance, she has a penchant for Wicked Game by Chris Isaak, though she playfully adds, “I'm not saying I've tried it!”

Morning Rituals and Emotional Connections

Her mornings start with Radio 4, then switch to Radio 3, where she enjoys Mozart's Deh vieni, non tardar from The Marriage of Figaro. On the emotional side, Ev'ry Time We Say Goodbye by Cole Porter brings tears to her eyes, reminding her of her mother.

Key Takeaways from Elaine Paige's Playlist

• Her musical taste spans from 1950s crooners to rock bands like the Police.
• Early experiences with harmony singing shaped her vocal style.
• “Don't Cry for Me Argentina” was a career-defining moment.
• She has a playful side, enjoying karaoke and impromptu performances.
• Emotional connections to songs are often tied to family and memories.

Comparison: Elaine Paige's Musical Influences vs. Modern Pop

FAQ