Midnight at the Never Get Review: Ben Platt Shines in 60s... 2026

Midnight at the Never Get review: Ben Platt soars in a honey-hearted cabaret-musical of 1960s sweethearts, a love story set against the vibrant but closeted world of New York's underground gay scene. This production at the Menier Chocolate Factory captures the essence of a bygone era with breathtaking performances.

The Story Behind the Songs

Mark Sonnenblick's out-of-time love story follows Trevor Copeland (Ben Platt), a crooning bar-singer, as he reminisces about his years with songwriter Arthur Brightman (Gregor Milne). The pair's relationship is woven through American Songbook-style music, from jaunty knee-bouncing numbers to big-band ballads. Platt's sky-gliding voice is perfectly suited for these period pieces, while Milne anchors the show with plate-spinning brilliance.

The narrative alternates between the 1960s and the present, with Trevor revisiting memories that reveal gaps in time and memory. As politics intrudes on their underground gay club, the couple faces a fundamental choice: to protest or assimilate. This dilemma gives grit to their otherwise jazz-smooth lives.

Ben Platt's Captivating Performance

Platt, a Tony, Emmy and Grammy award-winning actor known for Dear Evan Hansen and The Last Five Years, brings his signature intensity to the role. His vocal prowess is on full display, making every number feel like a revelation. However, it is Gregor Milne who serves as the show's anchor, believable as the troubled genius delivering new songs like cups of tea.

Musical Highlights and Direction

Director David Cromer retains intimacy by keeping the staging simple. The set by Scott Pask transforms the Menier Chocolate Factory into a lamplit cabaret. The live band provides flawless accompaniment, and a minor magic trick wraps up the story's loose threads. While the gut-punch would hit even harder with a trim, the show's emotional resonance lingers.

Comparison Table: Ben Platt's Theatre Roles

Key Takeaways from This Production

• Powerful vocal performances from Ben Platt and Gregor Milne.
• Authentic 1960s atmosphere with period-perfect music and set design.
• Emotional depth exploring love, loss, and political resistance.
• Intimate staging that keeps the audience engaged throughout.
• A must-see for musical theater fans and admirers of Platt's work.

FAQ

In conclusion, Midnight at the Never Get is a honey-hearted tribute to love and music, anchored by Ben Platt's soaring vocals and Gregor Milne's steady presence. Whether you're a longtime fan of Platt or new to his work, this cabaret-musical offers an unforgettable evening of theatre.