Best Supermarket Chocolate Ice Cream: Tasted and Rated 2026

In this taste test, we rated the best supermarket chocolate ice cream available, finding rich and creamy options that rival artisanal brands. Our expert panel sampled several products, scoring on taste, texture, and ingredient quality. The results reveal a clear shift toward less-processed, higher-quality ice creams with fewer gums and emulsifiers.

Top Supermarket Chocolate Ice Cream Picks

We evaluated each ice cream for smoothness, mouthfeel, cream content, and overall flavor complexity. Dense, custard-based French-style ice creams earned extra points, as did those with short, recognizable ingredient lists. Below are the standout performers.

Best Overall: Waitrose No.1 Santo Domingo Chocolate Ice Cream

Waitrose No.1 Santo Domingo impressed with its voluminous, super-rich texture and deep chocolate flavor. Made with 35% West Country whipping cream, Rainforest Alliance-certified Dominican Republic chocolate, and free-range eggs, this ice cream is remarkably smooth and creamy. It carries a Great Taste one-star award and contains no stabilizers. Priced at £4.50 for 480ml (94p/100ml), it earned 4 out of 4 stars.

Best Bargain: Sainsbury's Taste the Difference Belgian Chocolate Ice Cream

Sainsbury's Taste the Difference offers excellent value at £3.50 for 480ml (73p/100ml). It combines British cow's milk with 27% double cream and Rainforest Alliance-certified cocoa for a medium-intensity chocolate custard with a sugary toffee note. This ice cream is free from stabilizers and emulsifiers beyond the soya lecithin in the chocolate, earning 4 stars.

Premium Choice: Brickell's All-Natural Craft Chocolate Ice Cream

For those seeking an indulgent splurge, Brickell's all-natural craft chocolate ice cream (£7.50 for 475ml, £1.58/100ml) delivers a fudgy, rich, and satiating experience. Its bittersweet, nutty flavor comes from dark brown sugar and British milk from a family farm. This 4-star contender is intensely characterful and complex.

Comparison Table: Top Chocolate Ice Creams

Key Takeaways

• Look for ice creams with high cream content and short ingredient lists.
• French-style custard bases typically yield a smoother, denser texture.
• Avoid products with multiple gums and emulsifiers; they often indicate lower quality.
• Provenance matters: Rainforest Alliance certification ensures sustainable sourcing.
• Supermarket brands now compete with artisan makers on flavor and quality.

FAQ

Choosing the right chocolate ice cream comes down to your preference for richness, sweetness, and price. Whether you opt for the luxurious Waitrose, the budget-friendly Sainsbury's, or the artisan Brickell's, you can enjoy a premium dessert without leaving the supermarket aisle.

Best Products We’ve Tested and Rated

Our testing team has hands-on reviews of residential 5g wifi night vision, sd card, button spy, purse bag, and usb spy audio. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.

Our testing team has hands-on reviews of 4k spy, trail camera cellular, budget trail camera, non cellular trail camera, and cheap trail camera. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.