Dog Owner Refuses To Give A Dog She Found Six Years Ago To His Previous Owner 2026

OP (26F) found her Newfy, Bear, under the stairs at three months old. Despite searching for his family, none was found. The landlord suggested OP keep him, and she agreed. Recently, OP posted about Bear on a Newfy group, discovering a man claiming Bear as his lost puppy. They exchanged photos, confirming Bear’s identity. The man, living two hours away, expressed the intention to pick Bear up, surprising OP. Realizing the man wanted Bear back, OP explained the strong bond developed over six years. The man insisted, mentioning the money spent and his kids’ expectations. OP sought advice, questioning if she’s wrong for wanting to keep Bear. She believes it’s not a scam and that the man genuinely lost Bear six years ago.

Scroll down till the end to read the full story.

OP found Bear, a Newfy, at 3 months old under her apartment stairs. Landlord couldn’t care for him. OP kept Bear after no matching missing puppy signs were found.

via Reddit

Landlord allowed OP to keep Bear, and OP later shared Bear’s story on a Newfy Facebook group. A man messaged OP claiming Bear as his lost puppy.

via Reddit

OP received a picture and video from the man, confirming Bear’s identity. The man, living two hours away, lost Bear a month after adoption, presuming he died.

via Reddit

The man has two kids, now in middle and high school. OP expected a meeting to see Bear but was surprised when the man wanted to take Bear right away.

via Reddit

OP panicked upon realizing the man wanted Bear back. OP sought clarification, and when confirmed, explained the strong bond developed over 6 years.

via Reddit

The man got angry, claiming his kids paid $3,000 for Bear and insisting on taking him back. OP questioned if she was wrong based on a similar story.

via Reddit

TLDR says OP found a guy’s lost dog, raised it for 6 years. Now he wants it back. OP verified with proof, no suspicion of a scam.

via Reddit

Bear has a unique behavior; he sits like a kangaroo. OP received a video proving this. Doubts arise as they care for high-maintenance dogs and posted about Bear in 2015.

via Reddit

Now that you have read the story, it’s time for you to see what Redditors had to say about this. Read till the end to see what are other people’s opinions on this. Don’t forget to share your own opinion at the end of this article.

The man’s claim after such a long time seems unjust, considering your commitment and the dog’s established home with you.

You’ve been a responsible caregiver to Bear for six years. Your connection with the dog should be respected.

The dog’s well-being should be the priority.

It’s true.

It’s not OP’s fault.

What are your thoughts on this story? What would you do, or how would you react if you were in OP’s position? You know that your feedback means a lot to us; therefore, we want you to share your thoughts in the comment section below. For more such articles, keep visiting Defused. Have a nice day!

Cat tax

“Cat saved my life.”

via Reddit