Bartók's The Miraculous Mandarin Suite and The Wooden Prince receive a compelling new recording from conductor Edward Gardner and the London Philharmonic Orchestra. This album review explores how Gardner brings vivid colours and astute pacing to these two contrasting ballets, offering a fresh perspective on Bartók's orchestral genius.
A Rare Pairing of Bartók Ballets
Recordings of The Miraculous Mandarin used to outnumber The Wooden Prince ten to one, so it's refreshing to see Bartók's earlier ballet getting equal billing here. The two works, though composed within a decade of each other, inhabit vastly different worlds. The Mandarin is gritty and urban, while The Wooden Prince is rooted in folk idioms.
This album gives listeners a chance to appreciate both sides of Bartók's theatrical imagination. Gardner and the London Philharmonic Orchestra deliver performances that are both technically secure and emotionally engaging.
The Wooden Prince: Folk Roots and Vivid Colours
Unlike the Mandarin with its grimy, urban, modernist vibe, The Wooden Prince is steeped in pungent Hungarian folk music, filtered through the composer's unique 20th-century lens. The ballet tells the story of a princess who falls in love with a decoy prince rather than the real thing, and Gardner revels in the vivid colours of its nature-inflected score.
The London Philharmonic Orchestra is taut and dramatically alert throughout. There's an unnerving sense of foreboding underpinning the Dance of the Trees; the Dance of the Waves churns with kinetic energy; and the foot-stamping Dance of the Princess with the Wooden Doll cuts a rustic dash. Gardner's astute pacing is more theatrically involving than recent accounts by Cristian Măcelaru or Susanna Mälkki.
Live Recording vs. Studio
The live recording is less clinical than Boulez's crystalline 1991 studio performance (still essential listening), but it gains in warmth and immediacy. The audience's presence is felt without being intrusive, adding a sense of occasion to the proceedings.
The Miraculous Mandarin Suite: Sleek and Sinister
As for The Miraculous Mandarin Suite, this is as fine a performance as any. Gardner's reading is sleek and sinister, vividly evoking the honeytrap antics of the sex worker and her thuggish pimps. The music swaggers or turns shy in her encounters with the old rake and the young man, and prickles with jagged pentatonic scales once the mandarin arrives on the scene.
To open, Gardner paints a brutally vivid picture of the city's underbelly, setting the stage for the drama that unfolds. The orchestra responds with precision and bite, capturing the score's raw energy and exoticism.
Performance Highlights
- Dance of the Trees: Unnerving foreboding sets a mysterious tone.
- Dance of the Waves: Kinetic energy and churning motion.
- Dance of the Princess with the Wooden Doll: Rustic, foot-stamping rhythm.
- Mandarin Suite: Sleek, sinister, and dramatically charged.
- Orchestral playing: Taut, alert, and colourful throughout.
Comparative Analysis
| Conductor/Recording | Year | Strengths | Considerations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Edward Gardner (LPO) | 2023 (live) | Vivid colours, astute pacing, theatrical involvement | Less clinical than studio versions |
| Pierre Boulez (studio) | 1991 | Crystalline clarity, precision | Can feel detached |
| Cristian Măcelaru | Recent | Solid interpretation | Less theatrically involving |
| Susanna Mälkki | Recent | Good orchestral playing | Pacing less compelling |
This table highlights how Gardner's interpretation stands out for its theatricality and vivid orchestral colours, even if it sacrifices some of the clinical precision of Boulez's classic account. The background to this story is set out in Celebrity: latest articles. A related thread runs through Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra Review: Wigglesworth's Curious.
Why This Album Matters
For Bartók enthusiasts, this recording offers a valuable opportunity to hear The Wooden Prince in a performance that rivals the best. It also presents a Miraculous Mandarin Suite that holds its own against fierce competition. Earlier coverage in The Magnificent Seven TV Series: 65 Years Later, a New Adaptation shows how the argument developed. A closer look at the same subject appears in Judi Dench Says Sight Loss Ends Her Acting Career at 91.
Gardner's ability to balance the folk-inflected lyricism of the Prince with the modernist grit of the Mandarin demonstrates his versatility and deep understanding of Bartók's language. The London Philharmonic Orchestra, in top form, responds with playing that is both refined and passionate. Anyone following the wider picture can start with France's 1857 Pine Forest: A Million Hectares Now Unmanageable. The same theme surfaces in Claude Opus 5.5: Faster, Cheaper AI With New Safety Limits, which takes a different angle.
FAQ
What works are included on this album?
The album features Bartók's The Miraculous Mandarin Suite and The Wooden Prince, performed by the London Philharmonic Orchestra under Edward Gardner.
How does this recording compare to Boulez's 1991 version?
Gardner's live recording is less clinical than Boulez's crystalline studio performance, but it offers more theatrical involvement and warmth.
Is this a live recording?
Yes, the album was recorded live, capturing the energy and immediacy of a concert performance.
Who is the conductor?
The conductor is Edward Gardner, who leads the London Philharmonic Orchestra.
Overall, this album is a must-have for fans of Bartók and 20th-century ballet music. Gardner's vivid colours and astute pacing make it a standout release.