The Bath Children's Literature Festival is facing heavy criticism after its founder emailed authors asking them to delete social media posts about the festival's lack of diversity in its 2026 programme. This controversy has sparked a wider conversation about representation in children's literature and the power dynamics within the publishing industry.
What Happened at the Festival?
The festival, which bills itself as the UK's largest children's literature event, featured almost 100 events in its 2026 programme. However, several authors publicly criticized the lineup for lacking authors of colour. In response, festival founder John McLay sent emails to authors demanding they remove their comments, citing seven authors of colour, including one UK-Cypriot, as evidence that the complaints were inaccurate.
Get the #1 Wireless Door Camera
REOLINK Bestseller: 2K Weatherproof Video Doorbell, No Monthly Fees.
Authors Speak Out
Children's author Sophie Anderson described the emails as "quite threatening and bullying." Another author, Alexandra Sheppard, whose video about the incident has amassed over 20,000 views, said "the fear of being blacklisted for critiquing powerful organisations feels very real." Sheppard is now organizing an open letter to the festival.
| Claim by Critics | Festival's Response |
|---|---|
| No authors of colour in the 2026 programme | Identified seven authors of colour, including one UK-Cypriot |
| Social media comments were deleted | Festival wanted to remove posts with incorrect information |
| Emails felt like bullying | Founder apologized, saying intent was not to silence anyone |
Key Takeaways from the Controversy
- Diversity gaps remain a sensitive issue in children's literature events.
- Authors fear professional retaliation when speaking out against powerful organizations.
- The festival's attempt to control the narrative may have backfired, amplifying the criticism.
- An open letter is being organized to demand more transparency and inclusivity.
Why This Matters
The incident highlights the ongoing struggle for representation in the literary world. While the festival claims to have included authors of colour, the perception of a lack of diversity—and the heavy-handed response—has damaged trust. Many in the industry are calling for more proactive inclusion rather than reactive defenses.
FAQ
Why did the festival ask authors to delete their comments?
The festival said the posts contained incorrect information about the 2026 lineup and wanted to ensure accurate representation. However, critics argue the approach was silencing and intimidating.
How did the authors react to the emails?
Many authors expressed shock and fear, describing the emails as threatening. Sophie Anderson called them "horrible," and Alexandra Sheppard started an open letter campaign to address the issue.
What steps is the festival taking to address diversity concerns?
The festival has apologized for the email approach and stated its intent was not to silence anyone. However, no concrete diversity initiatives have been announced beyond defending the current lineup.
The Bath Children's Literature Festival controversy serves as a case study in how organizations handle criticism about diversity. For authors and attendees, the incident underscores the importance of transparent communication and genuine efforts at inclusivity. As the open letter gains traction, the festival may need to re-evaluate its policies to rebuild trust within the literary community.