A Michigan high school is under fire for a controversial gym class policy that requires female students to disclose details about their menstrual cycles if they want to make up missed swimming days. The policy, which appears in a Lakeview High School gym syllabus, has sparked outrage among parents and raised concerns about student privacy.
Details of the Menstrual Cycle Policy
According to the syllabus, female students who miss swimming due to their periods must have a parent submit a written note or email specifying the length of their menstrual cycle before they can make up the missed days. The policy states: “Female students will be given the opportunity to make up days, which are missed only because of their menstrual cycle. A written/email note from a parent stating the length of the menstrual duration is required, so the student can make up the days.” Students are then required to complete dry land workouts to make up the missed days. Failure to make up these days results in a non-participation day, which can lead to a grade reduction.
Parental Reaction and Privacy Concerns
Andy Amsdill, a parent whose daughter attends Lakeview High School, was shocked when he saw the requirements. He told WXYZ Detroit, “The teacher wants us to either send a note or an email with the suspected length of the cycle which, by itself, is ridiculous.” Many parents share his concern, arguing that such a policy invades students' privacy and places an unnecessary burden on families. The requirement to disclose menstrual details is seen by some as intrusive and potentially embarrassing for young girls.
School's Response and Broader Implications
The school has not yet issued a formal statement, but the controversy highlights broader issues about how schools handle menstrual health and student privacy. Similar policies in other districts have faced backlash, leading to revisions. Experts emphasize the importance of creating supportive environments for students, rather than penalizing them for natural biological processes.
Comparison of School Policies on Menstrual Leave
| School/District | Policy on Menstrual Leave | Parental Involvement |
|---|---|---|
| Lakeview High School, MI | Requires parental note with cycle length to make up missed days | High (written note required) |
| Portland Public Schools, OR | Excused absence without detailed disclosure | Low (no note required) |
| Chicago Public Schools, IL | Allows make-up work without menstrual details | Moderate (parental notification optional) |
Key Takeaways
- The policy requires female students to provide a parental note detailing their menstrual cycle length to make up missed swimming days.
- Parents are concerned about privacy and the unnecessary disclosure of personal health information.
- Students who do not make up missed days face grade reductions.
- The controversy raises questions about how schools balance participation requirements with student privacy.
FAQ
What exactly does the Michigan high school policy require?
The policy requires female students who miss swimming due to their menstrual cycle to have a parent submit a written note or email stating the length of their menstrual duration. They must then complete dry land workouts to make up the missed days.
Why are parents upset about this policy?
Parents are upset because the policy invades students' privacy by requiring disclosure of sensitive menstrual information. They believe it is unnecessary and embarrassing for young girls.
What are the consequences for students who do not make up missed days?
Students who do not make up missed days are marked as having a non-participation day, which can lead to a reduction in their grade.