Howard Webb Calls Accidental Handball Law a Nonsense 2026

Howard Webb, the chief refereeing officer for English football, has described the law around accidental handball as "a bit of a nonsense" and called for its reform to stop referees being drawn into "ridiculous situations." His comments came on Tuesday during his appearance on Match Officials Mic'd Up, where he reviewed several controversial incidents from the Premier League season.

Why Howard Webb Believes the Handball Law Is a Nonsense

Webb pointed to a specific incident in the buildup to an Ipswich own goal at Manchester United. The ball hit Harry Maguire's hand before he took a shot that deflected off Jacob Greaves and into the net. Under the current law, if Maguire had scored directly, the goal would have been disallowed. But because the ball deflected off another player, the goal stood.

"It's a bit of a nonsense, isn't it?" Webb said. "If [Maguire] strikes the ball beautifully into the top corner, then the goal gets disallowed. [But] he skews his shot, it becomes an own goal, and it's awarded."

The handball law states that it is an offence if a player scores in the opponent's goal directly from their hand or arm, or immediately after the ball has touched their hand or arm, even if accidental. However, if another player touches the ball before it goes in, only a deliberate handball would lead to a disallowed goal. This inconsistency is what Webb wants to see changed.

The Impact on Referees and the Game

Webb's frustration is not just about the letter of the law but about how it forces referees into impossible positions. "We want to avoid getting referees into ridiculous situations," he said. The current rule creates a scenario where the outcome of a goal can depend on whether a deflection occurs, which often has nothing to do with the handball itself.

This inconsistency not only confuses fans and players but also puts immense pressure on referees and VAR officials. Webb's call for reform is a recognition that the law, as written, is not fit for purpose in the modern game.

VAR Controversy: Manchester Derby Error

Webb also addressed the error that allowed Manchester City to win Sunday's Manchester derby. He said he was "really disappointed" with the VAR call that failed to spot Enzo Fernández interfering with play from an offside position before Erling Haaland scored the only goal. This incident further highlights the challenges facing VAR and the need for clearer rules.

What Could Change?

Webb did not propose a specific alternative, but his comments suggest a desire for a simpler, more consistent approach. One possibility is to treat all handball offenses in the buildup to a goal the same way, regardless of whether another player touches the ball. Another could be to focus solely on deliberate handball, removing the accidental element entirely from goal-scoring situations.

Comparison of Handball Scenarios

Key Takeaways

• Howard Webb calls the accidental handball law "a nonsense" and wants reform.
• The current law creates inconsistent outcomes depending on deflections.
• Webb is "really disappointed" with the VAR error in the Manchester derby.
• Reform could simplify the law and reduce pressure on referees.
• Fans and players alike are calling for greater clarity in handball decisions.

FAQ

Best Products We’ve Tested and Rated

Our testing team has hands-on reviews of extendable outdoor dining tables, quick access gun safe, rifle, handgun car, and fireproof waterproof. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.

Our testing team has hands-on reviews of gun money, home, home centric smart, thermal camera what it is how choose model, and how buy armored door home. Every option below was compared across price, build quality, and real-world performance, with honest pros and cons. We update these guides regularly as new models arrive, so the recommendations stay current.