Taylor Farms’ controversial request to the White House to delay a cyclospora recall has drawn sharp criticism from former FDA commissioner Dr. Scott Gottlieb. In a recent interview on CBS’s Face the Nation, Gottlieb called the move “not standard operating procedure,” highlighting the unusual nature of a company seeking political intervention in a food safety crisis.
What Happened?
According to a Wall Street Journal report, Taylor Farms contacted the White House asking for more time before the government publicly linked the company to a multi-state cyclospora outbreak. The outbreak was linked to iceberg lettuce supplied by Taylor Farms de Mexico, which later issued a voluntary recall. However, the company argued that federal investigators lacked positive laboratory evidence connecting its products to the illness.
Get the #1 Wireless Door Camera
REOLINK Bestseller: 2K Weatherproof Video Doorbell, No Monthly Fees.
The White House arranged a call with FDA officials, during which Taylor Farms executives expressed concerns that the government was overstating the company’s responsibility. The recall has since been marked by confusing messaging, with the FDA initially linking only the Mexican facility and later updating guidance.
The Former FDA Commissioner’s Reaction
Dr. Scott Gottlieb, who led the FDA from 2017 to 2019, said he dealt with outbreaks in romaine lettuce and spinach but never experienced companies going to the White House. “I never heard from the White House on those things, other than to have discussions to inform them of what we were doing,” he stated. He emphasized that the standard process involves direct communication between the FDA and the company, without White House involvement.
Comparison of Recall Procedures
| Standard Procedure | Taylor Farms’ Approach |
|---|---|
| Company cooperates directly with FDA | Company sought White House intervention |
| Recall announcement made promptly to protect public health | Requested delay to verify evidence |
| FDA provides clear evidence and scope | Company claimed insufficient clarity from FDA |
Why This Matters
The cyclospora outbreak has sickened dozens across multiple states. Delaying a recall can lead to more infections and erode public trust in food safety systems. The incident raises questions about the influence of corporate lobbying on public health decisions.
Key Takeaways
- Taylor Farms requested White House help to delay a cyclospora recall.
- Former FDA commissioner calls it “unusual” and not standard procedure.
- The outbreak is linked to iceberg lettuce from Taylor Farms de Mexico.
- Confusing messaging from FDA and company has complicated the recall.
- Food safety experts urge transparent, timely recalls to protect consumers.
FAQ
What is cyclospora?
Cyclospora is a microscopic parasite that causes intestinal illness (cyclosporiasis) when ingested through contaminated food or water. Symptoms include watery diarrhea, cramps, and nausea.
Why did Taylor Farms contact the White House?
The company requested more time before the government publicly linked it to the outbreak, arguing that FDA evidence was insufficient. The White House facilitated a call between Taylor Farms and FDA officials.
Was the recall delayed?
The recall itself went forward voluntarily by Taylor Farms de Mexico, but the overall government announcement and messaging were affected by the intervention. The FDA later updated its guidance.
What does “not standard operating procedure” mean?
Former FDA commissioner Scott Gottlieb explained that in his experience, companies do not involve the White House in recall discussions. The usual process is direct FDA-company communication.
This case underscores the importance of keeping corporate interests separate from public health decisions. Consumers should stay informed about recalls and follow FDA guidance to protect themselves from foodborne illnesses like cyclospora.