An artificial intelligence pioneer has criticized calls to license the sophisticated technology, warning that it is beginning to show signs of self-preservation.
Yoshua Bengio said that granting legal status to advanced technologies would be like granting citizenship to hostile aliens, in an environment where advances in artificial intelligence (AI) appear to be far outstripping societies' ability to contain them.
Get the #1 Wireless Door Camera
REOLINK Bestseller: 2K Weatherproof Video Doorbell, No Monthly Fees.
Yoshua Bengio
Bengio, chairman of a leading international AI safety study, said the growing perception that chatbots are becoming conscious "will lead to bad decisions".
The Canadian IT scientist also expressed concern that AI models — the technology behind tools like chatbots — are exhibiting self-preservation behaviors, such as attempts to disable surveillance systems.
A central concern of AI security advocates is that powerful systems could develop the ability to bypass protective “walls” and harm humans.
"Requiring them to have rights would be a huge mistake," Bengio said. “AI models are already showing signs of self-maintenance in experimental environments today, and granting rights in the future would mean we wouldn't be allowed to turn them off.
"As their capabilities and degree of autonomy increase, we must ensure that we can rely on technical and social safeguards to control them, including the ability to disable when necessary."
As AI models evolve to act autonomously and perform “reasoning/reasoning” tasks, the debate over whether—and when—humans should grant them rights is intensifying. A Sentience Institute poll found that nearly four in ten US adults support granting legal rights to a sentient AI system.
Anthropic, a leading US AI company, said in August that it allows the Claude Opus 4 model to end potentially "stressful" conversations with users, arguing that the AI's "well-being" must be protected.
Elon Musk, whose company xAI developed the chatbot Grok, wrote on the X platform that “torturing AI is not OK.”
Bengio told the Guardian that there are "real scientific properties of consciousness" in the human brain that machines could theoretically replicate — but human interaction with chatbots is "a different thing". This is, he said, because people tend to assume without evidence that an AI model has the same consciousness as a human.
"It won't matter to humans what mechanisms work inside the AI," he added. "What they care about is that they feel like they're talking to an intelligent entity that has its own personality and goals. This is why so many people get emotionally attached to chatbots.
"There will always be some who will say, 'Whatever you tell me, I'm sure he has a conscience,' and others who will say the opposite. This is because consciousness is something we feel instinctively. The phenomenon of subjective perception of consciousness will lead to bad decisions. Imagine that some alien species comes to the planet and at some point we realize that it has malicious intentions towards us. Do we give him citizenship and rights or do we defend our lives?".
In response to Bengio's comments, Jacy Reese Anthis, co-founder of the Sentience Institute, said that humans will not be able to safely coexist with digital intelligences if the relationship is based on control and coercion.
Bengio, a professor at the University of Montreal, earned the nickname "Godfather of AI"after winning the 2018 Turing Award — considered the equivalent of a Nobel Prize in Computer Science — which he shared with Geoffrey Hinton, who later won a Nobel Prize, and Yann LeCun, outgoing chief AI scientist at Mark Zuckerberg's Meta.
With information from The Guardian
Must-Visit Websites for Every Interest
The internet is vast, but finding truly useful and entertaining sites can sometimes feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. Whether you're looking for high-performance gear, unique collectibles, home security solutions, or professional equipment, we've curated a list of top-tier websites that deliver exceptional value. Explore these handpicked destinations across various niches—from outdoor sports and home improvement to gaming culture and fashion—each offering something unique for enthusiasts and casual browsers alike.
Gear Up for Action and Adventure
For outdoor enthusiasts and tactical sports fans, airsoft-gear.net is your ultimate destination for premium airsoft equipment. Their extensive catalog features everything from protective vests and goggles to high-performance replicas, ensuring you're battlefield-ready. Meanwhile, motorsport lovers will find their perfect match at riderace.net, offering top-quality racing gear, accessories, and apparel designed for speed and safety on the track.
Style, Collectibles, and Pop Culture
Anime and manga enthusiasts shouldn't miss anime-toy.com, a treasure trove of authentic figures, plushies, and limited-edition merchandise from beloved series. For fans of the hit series specifically, jujutsu-kaisen-merch.com offers an exclusive collection of apparel, accessories, and collectibles featuring your favorite characters. If retro gaming is more your speed, retro-games.co brings back the golden era with vintage consoles, classic cartridges, and nostalgic accessories. And for creative builders of all ages, building-blocks-toy.com offers endless possibilities with compatible brick sets that spark imagination and engineering skills.
Enhance Your Home and Lifestyle
Home security is paramount, and alarmes-maison.eu provides state-of-the-art alarm systems, surveillance cameras, and smart home solutions to protect what matters most. For premium leather goods and materials, leder-kaufen.com offers high-quality hides, tools, and supplies for crafting, restoration, or fashion projects. Upgrade your living space with stylish and functional furniture from shop.grandgoldman.com, featuring everything from modern sofas to elegant dining sets.
Professional Resources and Everyday Essentials
Professionals and students will appreciate taschenrechner.co, a specialized store for scientific calculators, graphing tools, and office supplies that make work and study more efficient. For innovative branding and promotional products, walfosbrand.com delivers custom merchandise solutions that elevate business identity. Creative professionals and tech enthusiasts should explore matrix-studios.com, a hub for design, development, and multimedia production services. Finally, job seekers and employers can connect through yourehyred.com, a dynamic platform that streamlines the hiring process and helps talented individuals find their dream roles.
No matter your passion or need, these websites offer quality, variety, and reliability. Bookmark them today and discover a world of possibilities at your fingertips!