BBC Symphony Orchestra Venditti Review: Rossini Stabat Mater 2026

The BBC Symphony Orchestra under Nil Venditti delivered a fervent and lithe-limbed performance of Rossini's Stabat Mater, a work that has captivated audiences since its 1842 premiere. This review explores the highlights of this Proms concert, from the soloists' brilliance to the chorus's precision.

Rossini's Stabat Mater: A Masterpiece of Bel Canto

Rossini's Stabat Mater is a curious blend of bel canto tunefulness and dramatic depth. While some critics have questioned its stylistic fit for the sacred text, the work's sincerity and power, especially in the unaccompanied choral passages, remain undeniable. Venditti's interpretation embraced the lyricism while mining the score for theatrical nuggets, resulting in a pacy reading that favored drama over grandeur.

The Soloists: An All-Italian Lineup

The soloists were led by Federica Lombardi, whose pearly soprano soared in the Inflammatus, battling gleaming brass and driving timpani. Mezzo-soprano Chiara Amarù displayed a warm middle register, though she seemed over-reliant on the score. Nicola Ulivieri lent sombre vocal heft to the Pro Peccatis Suae Gentis, while Dave Monaco, a last-minute stand-in, impressed with gleaming tone and a nailed top D-flat in the Cujus Animam Gementem.

Chorus and Orchestra: Precision and Passion

The BBC Symphony Chorus, bolstered by London's semi-professional Epiphoni Consort, delivered a robust and disciplined performance. Their crisp consonants landed with pinpoint precision, going cheek by jowl with Venditti's brisk direction. The orchestra responded with lithe-limbed drama, avoiding heavyweight grandeur in favor of agility and clarity.

Respighi's Church Windows: A Pale Shadow

The first half featured Respighi's Church Windows, making its Proms premiere. Unfortunately, it proved a pale shadow of his Roman Trilogy. Despite colorful moments, the melodies drawn from Gregorian chant failed to make a lasting impression. Venditti's direction was effective, particularly in the opening Flight into Egypt with its Scheherazade-like clarinet and flute scales.

Performance Comparison: Venditti vs. Traditional Interpretations

Key Takeaways from the Concert

• Venditti's interpretation highlighted the operatic qualities of Rossini's sacred work.
• The chorus's articulation was exceptional, bringing clarity to the text.
• Dave Monaco's last-minute performance was a standout, hitting the high D-flat with ease.
• Respighi's Church Windows underwhelmed, but the orchestral colors were well-executed.
• The concert demonstrated the versatility of the BBC Symphony Orchestra under dynamic leadership.

FAQ