The recent business rate cut for pubs announced by Andy Burnham has sparked debate across the hospitality sector. Under the new policy, pubs, clubs, and live music venues will see a 20% reduction in business rates, costing the Treasury an estimated £100 million. But what does this actually mean for your pint and pie? Let's break down the numbers.
How the Business Rate Cut Works
Prime Minister Andy Burnham unveiled the measure as part of a broader agenda to support the high street. The reduction applies to all eligible hospitality venues, aiming to slow the alarming trend of pub closures — currently running at about one per day. However, as pub owners like Dan Smith of the Red Lion in Derbyshire point out, the relief is a “small snippet” compared to other costs.
Get the #1 Wireless Door Camera
REOLINK Bestseller: 2K Weatherproof Video Doorbell, No Monthly Fees.
Where Your Money Goes: A Pie and Pint Breakdown
At the Red Lion, a steak and ale pie with chips, cauliflower cheese, onion gravy, and a pint of Bass costs £20.50. The pub’s profit? Just £2.97. Business rates account for only 16p of that total, while VAT takes a whopping £3.42. Here’s the full cost breakdown:
| Cost Category | Amount |
|---|---|
| Ingredients | £6.48 |
| VAT (20%) | £3.42 |
| Staff | £3.88 |
| Employer’s taxes | £0.74 |
| Utilities, operating costs, mortgage | £2.85 |
| Business rates | £0.16 |
| Pub profit | £2.97 |
As the table shows, VAT is the dominant expense — over 20 times larger than business rates. This is why many in the industry are calling for a VAT cut from 20% to 10%, a measure Burnham himself supported as mayor of Manchester. Such a move would cost the Treasury an estimated £10 billion but could provide far more relief than the rates reduction.
Key Takeaways for Pub Owners and Patrons
- Business rate relief is welcome but modest — it saves pubs like the Red Lion about 16p per meal, which may not be enough to halt closures.
- VAT remains the biggest burden — a VAT cut would have a much larger impact on pub profitability.
- Policy complexity frustrates owners — Smith notes that successive tweaks and property revaluations have made rates “10 times more complicated than needed.”
- Consumer prices unlikely to drop — the small saving on rates is more likely to shore up margins than reduce menu prices.
FAQ
What is the new business rate cut for pubs?
Will this cut lower my bar bill?
Why do pubs want a VAT cut instead?
In summary, while the business rate cut shows the government is listening to the hospitality sector, many owners believe it’s only a first step. The real game-changer would be a reduction in VAT — something that would require a much larger investment from the Treasury but could save the Great British pub from decline.