The EU pesticide law aimed to cut pesticide use in half to protect biodiversity, but newly revealed documents show how Europe's most powerful farming lobby, Copa Cogeca, delayed, gutted, and overturned these sweeping reforms. This exposé details the lobbying strategies that derailed critical environmental policy.
The Power of Copa Cogeca
Copa Cogeca, representing 22 million farmers across Europe, enjoys unparalleled access to EU lawmakers. It has been described as a "partner in policymaking". When the EU launched radical farming reforms in 2020 in response to climate breakdown and the nature crisis, Copa Cogeca swung into action.
Get the #1 Wireless Door Camera
REOLINK Bestseller: 2K Weatherproof Video Doorbell, No Monthly Fees.
Internal Lobbying Strategy Revealed
Dozens of internal documents obtained by Grilled and the Guardian reveal a coordinated effort to delay and undermine the pesticide reduction targets. In February 2021, the lobby group set its strategy, including defending controversial animal products like foie gras and fur "in the same way as tobacco".
Delay Tactics and Impact Assessments
The documents show Copa Cogeca combined delay tactics with intensified lobbying. A September 2022 note stated: "The European parliament elections are in 2024. Perhaps it is worth delaying until then. We must force the Commission to abandon its objectives." The group demanded a new impact assessment, which slowed the policymaking process by six months.
| Action | Impact on EU Pesticide Law |
|---|---|
| Demanded new impact assessment | Delayed policy by 6 months |
| Rejected Parliament report as "offensive" | Undermined legislative momentum |
| Presented privately commissioned research | Influenced EU ambassadors |
Protecting Bee-Harming Pesticides
The documents also capture lobbying to protect bee-harming pesticides, directly opposing biodiversity goals. Member states, the minutes record, "showed understanding" for the industry's position, highlighting the lobby's effective influence.
Key Takeaways
- Copa Cogeca used delay tactics to push the pesticide reduction target past the 2024 EU elections.
- The lobby group commissioned private research to highlight economic impacts, swaying EU ambassadors.
- Internal documents show a strategy to defend controversial products and block environmental reforms.
This case study underscores the immense power of agribusiness lobbying in shaping EU environmental policy. The EU pesticide law remains a battleground between ecological necessity and industrial interests.
FAQ
What is Copa Cogeca?
Copa Cogeca is the most powerful farming lobby in Europe, representing 22 million farmers. It has significant access to EU lawmakers and is often called a "partner in policymaking."
How did the farming lobby kill the EU pesticide law?
The lobby used delay tactics, demanded new impact assessments, rejected parliamentary reports, and presented privately commissioned research to influence EU ambassadors, ultimately derailing the pesticide reduction targets.
What was the goal of the EU pesticide law?
The EU pesticide law aimed to cut pesticide use by half to protect biodiversity and address climate breakdown and the nature crisis.